Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Tuesday Round-up

Well, the Special Investigation Unit has detained Chen Shui-bian. Interesting move, the latest in a number of DPP politicians swept up in corruption probes. Let loose, Chen might have caused all sorts of trouble for the DPP, but now he has been removed from the political scene, and may well be transformed into a folk hero to boot.

Meanwhile lots of other things are happening in Taiwan, despite all eyes being on the news about Chen Yunlin's visit (complained about in this letter to FT), the protests, the violence, the student protests, and the spate of arrests and detentions. Jon Adams has a nifty piece in the IHT about the way shamans in Taiwan are changing to meet the exigencies of the current era...

Consulting a jitong is a case in point. The practice has not been totally abandoned, just updated. Chang Yin, for example, regularly sends out text messages via mobile phone to about 300 clients. That virtual network has replaced the tightly knit village setting of old.

One Sunday a month, she invites those contacts to her office for an open spirit medium session.

On this particular day, as she answered petitioners' questions, several elderly men lounged nearby on pillows and chairs, watching the proceedings. Children ran in and out of the room. Chang's assistants bustled around in the office and attached kitchen, lighting joss sticks, washing dishes, tending to accounts.

The scorekeeping also continues, with the government's obsession with restoring Kaohsiung to its former rank among the world's ports reaching new heights of absurdity:

Kaohsiung Harbor chief was urged Monday to be tough enough to rev up the performance of Taiwan's largest international harbor so that it could recover the appeal and status it had a decade ago.

Kaohsiung Harbor Administrator Hsieh Ming-hui was urged at a budget-screening meeting at the Legislative Yuan to show his muscle and not to dodge his responsibility as chief of the harbor to do whatever is needed to improve the seaport's performance.

Ruling Kuomintang Legislator Huang Chao-shun, from Kaohsiung, said it is unbelievable that Kaohsiung Harbor, the world's third largest container seaport in the 90s, might be ranked 12th this year, behind even China's Qingdao Port.
Apparently the rise of China is supposed to have no effect on Kaohsiung's position in the rankings (as if the rankings meant anything), nor are the new ports the government has put in supposed to have any effect either, nor is the fact that so many of Taiwan's factories have moved to China supposed to affect our export volume. *sigh*

Neocon Paul Wolfowitz is head of the US-Taiwan Business Council and has a piece in FEER this week on Taiwan and what it should be doing, basically hitting on stuff foreign businessmen would like it to hit on:

Taiwan's energy market is just one example of a sector needing reform. Foreign investors do not look favorably on an environment where there are major questions about the reliability and diversity of electricity supply. Sectors like energy are going to require a significant reduction in the heavy hand of the state.

A second example is the restrictions on technology investments in China. While the Ma administration has moved forward to modernize its semiconductor investment guidelines, Taipei still needs to move away from restrictions that are focused on outdated technology and base future investment guidelines on an efficient export control regime.

A third example concerns the Agreement on Government Procurement under the WTO. Taiwan's participation in that agreement at the earliest possible date is likely to make execution of a number of initiatives more successful, including the i-Taiwan initiative. There are some challenges in shepherding Taiwan's accession, but the Taiwan government should place a high priority on this effort so that Taiwan can accede as soon as possible.

Also in the area of trade, a fourth example concerns an FTA with the U.S. The atmosphere in the United States for any further free trade agreements is bleak and it is likely that the American elections will produce a Congress that is even less friendly to free trade agreements than the present one. While Taiwan should continue to advocate for an FTA, Taipei should also work on advancing the Trade and Investment Framework Agreement, and try to resolve outstanding trade issues—including those surrounding American beef.

Perhaps the most important thing Taiwan could do to become more competitive is tax reform. President Ma seems to understand the importance of reducing Taiwan's tax burden, even despite—or perhaps because of—the slowdown in the global economy. Recently his administration proposed cuts in the inheritance tax that should encourage savings and investment, as well as an increase in the standard deduction on personal income taxes that will help ordinary taxpayers. Another thing his administration could do would be to reduce Taiwan's corporate income tax rate; at 25% it is twice the rate of Ireland, a small island on the other side of the world which managed to make itself a financial center for Europe.

Speaking of the economy, Taiwan Journal has a piece on the "aerotropolis", the free trade zone that the government is erecting around Taoyuan airport.

The draft bill has been submitted to the Legislative Yuan for approval. MOTC officials said the ministry hoped the bill will be passed by the end of this year, so that the planned state-run airport firm can begin operation in 2010.

The bill contains 46 articles divided into nine chapters covering general operation guidelines, program planning and revisions, airport park management, aviation city development and construction.

Under the proposal, the airport park will be granted privileges similar to free trade ports, which enjoy greater flexibility than regular businesses in hiring foreign laborers and local workers.

According to MOTC, the new airport company would be exempt from business tax on airport service charges and other revenues, while airport buildings and airport lots would be exempt from housing tax and land tax, respectively. The airport company, however, will be required to remit part of its profits to the Taoyuan County government to promote local ventures and help finance the nation's airports that are suffering losses.


Conservative columnist Richard Halloran rounds up skeptical commentary on the US election from around the Pacific...

Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said he had written to Obama: "Many issues will claim your attention. May I make a case for the importance of Southeast Asia to the U.S., a region which is not unfamiliar to you?" referring to Obama's childhood in neighboring Indonesia. A writer for the Straits Times, Joanna Lee, however, was skeptical of Obama's emphasis on hope: "Alas, I'm not sure hope is enough."

In New Delhi, the Times of India commented: "Obama will be a breath of fresh air in almost every part of the world ... Why, then, is India keeping her fingers crossed?" The paper said: "There is little clarity on how the chips will fall on several issues ... Pakistan, China, terrorism, nuclear issues, trade, all issues on which India has had a prickly relationship with the Democratic Party."

A columnist for The Australian, Greg Sheridan, wrote: "For Australia, Obama is a very mixed bag. Despite a couple of years in Indonesia as a kid, Obama has little knowledge of, or interest, in Asia." Pointing to President Bush's support for Australia, Sheridan concluded: "Don't expect Obama to be anywhere near as mindful of Australia."


QUOTE OF THE DAY
: From the New Republic blog:

People inside China have no choice but to accept this distortion of language [anti-China]. People outside do have a choice, but we often fail to exercise it. For example, our country's small contingent of "China policy managers" (officials and academics who have kept relations with China's rulers "on track" ever since Jimmy Carter) routinely use the word "China" to refer only to the views, attitudes, and "sensitivities" of the Chinese political-economic super-elite with whom they directly deal. The policy managers speak of "Chinese" sensitivities toward Falungong as if Falungong believers were not themselves Chinese; of "Chinese" views on Tibet, as if forgetting that the Chinese government itself claims that Tibetans, too, are Chinese; and of U.S. congressional critics of the Chinese government not as bashers of authoritarianism but as "China" bashers.

President Chen Taken Into Custody


Student protesters at NCKU.

Former President Chen Shui-bian was taken into custody by the Special Investigations Unit today, as many had predicted. More details tomorrow as the story is clarified.

Monday, November 10, 2008

Interviewing the Student Protesters in Tainan

Students chant during the student protests across campuses nationwide. This video was taken at NCKU on the afternoon of Nov 10, 2008.

I stopped by the student protest in front of the gate of NCKU on Da Shue Rd in Tainan and spoke to a spokesperson for the protesters:

How long are you going to be out here?

"We are going to stay until tuesday. If the government hasn't given us a response by then, we'll probably continue. But we'll vote on that. If everyone decides to continue, then we'll continue."

Has the government contacted you yet?

They've talked to the people in Taipei, but not directly to us. But we are in contact with Taipei and Taichung, where we are carrying out this activity as well. If they get a response in Taipei we'll hear about it.

So what do you call yourselves? The Wild Strawberries? Why that?

Because people say -- in Taiwan many of the media organizations say -- that young people are just like strawberries [weak and easily bruised --mt]. We think we're not like that, and we wanted to show that we could do something.

So you didn't want to recall the "White Lily" student movement of the late 1980s?

We didn't really hope to do that. Many of those people have gone on to enter political parties, and we didn't want people to see us as supporting or connected to one party or the other.

What are these three goals?

First, we hope that President Ma and Premier Liu will apologize for the recent police violence. Our second goal is that the heads of the National Police Administration and the National Security Administration step down. Third, we hope that the Assembly and Parade Law will be revised. We ask that it be revised in four directions. First, we'd like to change the application for a parade permit to a notification system, just like in the US, where you just notify the police that you will march, instead of asking permission to hold a march. That way the police will not be saying who can protest and who can't. The second thing we want changed is the Police Administrative Judgment authority. At present the police can decide when they will go arrest people and when they won't. [drowned out by traffic and crowd noises.] The third change we want is that at present violations of the Assembly and Parade Law are criminal acts under the law and determined under criminal law, so you can be sent to jail for a year or two years, for example. We believe that this is against the freedom of the people. We want that changed so that violations fall under the administrative laws and only fines are handed out for violations of the Assembly and Parade Law, so you won't get a year or two for violations of the law. Finally, we want them to lift the restrictions on places where assemblies and parades can be held. These restrictions are a violation of the basic rights and freedoms laid out in the Constitution. Now [the Assembly and Parade] law is clearly of lower status than the Constitution, but it has [unintelligible] the Constitution. So we think it should be revised.

NOTES: The interview was conducted in Chinese and recorded on my Canon Powershot IS S5 with the permission of the speaker. This is a translation, with some of the more informal and repetitive language paraphrased. Between the passers-by, the protesters chanting, and the traffic, a few parts are not clear.

UPDATE: ETaiwan News' excellent article on the Wild Strawberry protests.

Sunday, November 09, 2008

Student Protests in Tainan



Two images of the student protests in Tainan. Braving the rain, roughly 30-50 students come out to ask for Ma to apologize, senior police officials to step down, and most importantly, reform of the Assembly and Parade law, a relic of the martial law era that is often used to shut down protests. These student protests are separate from the DPP protests and senior DPP who have appeared at them have been asked to leave. Students at leading universities around the island have begun protesting in its major cities since the end of the protests again the Chen Yunlin visit to Taiwan.

UPDATE: Monday's Taipei Times article on the student protests

UPDATE 2: Janice says in the comment

The movement's main website:
http://action1106.blogspot.com/

Other related weblinks:
http://taichung.action1106.org/
http://tainan.action1106.org/
http://hsinchu.action1106.org/
http://wiki.action1106.org/
http://map.action1106.org/
http://taipak2008.pbwiki.com/FrontPage

Taiwan Studies Conferences: Call for Papers fast approaching

Daffyd Fell of SOAS passes around the alert -- looks like some meaty paper themes there! Hurry up and get an abstract in:

++++++++++++

Dear All,

The deadlines for abstract submission of the world's two largest Taiwan Studies conferences are fast approaching. The deadline for the European Association of Taiwan Studies (EATS) conference is November 15 and for the North American Taiwan Studies Association Conference
(NATSA) is November 30.

Below I have pasted and attached the Call for Papers for the EATS
conference and attached the Call for Papers for NATSA.

Best Wishes

Dafydd

Dafydd Fell
SOAS Centre of Taiwan Studies

Sixth Conference of the European Association of Taiwan Studies

Call For Papers
The European Association of Taiwan Studies (EATS) will hold its sixth annual conference on 16-18 April 2009. The conference is co-organized by the Center of East Asian Studies, Autonoma University of Madrid, Madrid, Spain and School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS), Centre of Taiwan Studies.

Venue: Madrid.

The organizers particularly welcome abstracts on the following themes:

1. "Taiwanese Democracy: A Model for Mainland China and Hong Kong?" in the field of Domestic Politics and Democracy
2. "Social Realism" in the field of Literature
3. "1949-2009: 60 years of the ROC" in the field of History and Social Sciences
4. "A New Start? " in Cross Strait Relations
5. "Historical Linguistics" in the field of Language
6. "The impact of changes of ruling parties on Taiwan: Divided versus Unified Government"
7. "The Role of the Media in Taiwan's politics and society"

We particularly invite submissions on these themes for the consideration of an interdisciplinary panel.

Masters and 1st year Ph.D. students enrolled in a Taiwan Studies Programme at a European university are especially encouraged to apply to present their research in the EATS MA panel.

In addition, we will consider outstanding submissions in the following disciplinary areas:

1. Economics and Business
2. Anthropology and Religion
3. Politics, Law and International Relations
4. History and Geography
5. Cultural and Area Studies

Please submit a 250-300 word abstract by 15 November 2008. Please e-mail your abstract to eats2009@yahoo.com

We will announce the accepted abstracts on 14 December 2008. Participants who present papers and affiliated with European institutions will be eligible for travel grants. Details will be
announced.


Saturday, November 08, 2008

"Painful to live in fear, isn't it?"


Now Fear has come again
To live with us
In poisoned intimacy like pus...

I struggled all week on how to write on the Chen Yunlin visit. I struggled not because I did not know what to say, but because I did not want to speak. And so I will let others summarize the events of this week: the detentions, the arrival of Chen Yunlin, the agreements, and the meaning of the protests, and above all, the creeping fear that so many of us now feel as we watch what is happening.

JOHN MANTHORPE, VANCOUVER SUN: At least seven senior members of the Democratic Progressive Party administration of former president Chen Shui-bian are being held under draconian "investigative detention" laws that allow prosecutors to hold suspects for up to four months without charge.

Prosecutors claim they believe the detained officials have been involved in corruption and might destroy evidence if not imprisoned.

But DPP leaders and other observers accuse the new Kuomintang administration of using the judicial system to purge the political stage of its opponents, smearing the reputations of the detained DPP officials by leaking unsupported allegations to the media, and using the detentions to try to extract confessions.

Those detained include a former senior official in Chen's office, the former interior minister Yu Cheng-hsien, former deputy prime minister Chiou I-jen, the former deputy environment minister Dr. James Lee, two DPP municipal officials and a county magistrate.

TING-YI TSAI, ASIAN WSJ: "Chen Yunlin will act like Santa Claus," said Wu Yu-shan, director of Academia Sinica's Institute of Political Science in Taipei. "But the problem is whether the gifts could create obvious benefit to the economy under the current difficult economic environment."

Mr. Ma took office five months ago, promising a new era of peace and economic normalization with China, after years of contentious relations under his predecessor Chen Shui-bian. But his approval ratings have plummeted since, and he has faced growing challenges within Taiwan to his accommodating stance toward Beijing. According to a poll conducted by the Global Views survey center, Mr. Ma's support rate has slipped to 23.6% from 60.5% in April.

JON ADAMS, CSMONITOR: Tuesday's agreements scrap cross-strait barriers erected in 1949 by rival Chinese regimes that refused to recognize each other's existence. The deals extend cross-strait passenger flights and shorten travel times. Before, all flights had to go through Hong Kong airspace.

Direct cargo flights will make it easier for Taiwan businesses to ship equipment and components to the mainland. Direct shipping links will remove the previously needed stop at Hong Kong or another intermediate port. "It's going to save a lot of transportation costs for Taiwan businesses," says Wu Chung-shu, dean of the college of management at Taiwan's National Dong Hwa University. "They're happy to see the government have a more open attitude."

Still, cross-strait links may not much blunt the global downturn's impact on Taiwan's export-dependent economy. "Improving cross-strait links will not totally insulate Taiwan from the current downside risks of a US recession," wrote Standard Chartered's Taiwan economist Tony Phoo in a report earlier this year. "Taiwan remains one of the most exposed in the region to a US-led global slowdown."

Realtime protest broadcasts
Tainan:
http://live.yahoo.com/tainandirect
It started already. (1 pm, Nov, 8th, 2008, Saturday)

Taichung:
http://1106.ezyou.cc/Home/tai-zhong-chang-ci
This one will start 2 pm, Nov, 9th, 2008, Sunday

TAIWAN NEWS: However, Tsai, who was MAC chairman from 2000-2004, stated that what the Ma government had gained in the SEF-ARATS agreements "were what we almost gained but they did not gain any more and at the cost of accepting political conditions including agreeing to Beijing's 'one China principle' and defining Taiwan as a 'region' and not a state."

Tsai stated that the four agreements would tie Taiwan closer to the PRC economy and expose Taiwan to the "increasing risks and uncertainties of the China market" and predicted that only a relatively small portion of Taiwan society will benefit from the new pacts.

The DPP chairwoman warned that if the Ma government does not effectively adopt complementary measures, Taiwan's domestic-market oriented industries, small businesses, middle and lower classes and farmers "will be harmed, incomes and wages will become stagnant and only unemployment will rise."

"This is the reason why the DPP was cautious in handling China policy as we supported liberalization but also believed we had to adopt complementary measures to reduce the negative impact on ordinary citizens and to accelerate industrial restructuring," Tsai said.

Former DPP MAC chairman Chen Ming-tong (陳明通) said the Ma government had failed to gain access to cross-strait shipping for foreign flag carriers or ships flying "flags of convenience" in the cross-strait marine transportation agreement, which he described as "vague" and operationally defined cross-strait shipping as Chinese "domestic" routes.

Chen Ming-tong also noted the air passenger agreement damaged Taiwan's national security by re-routing "northern line" flights from Taiwan to Shanghai and other locations to avoid monitoring by the Japan air defense identification zone (ADIZ) and by excessively shortening air warning times and by effectively defining cross-strait routes as "domestic" by allowing PRC airlines to fly directly to domestic Taiwan airports instead of landing first at the international airports of Taoyuan and Kaohsiung.

FAPA STATEMENT ON CHEN YUNLIN VISIT: The Ma administration knows that the majority of the Taiwanese people do not support a rapid pro-China policy. Yet his administration decided to go ahead with hosting the meeting between Chen and Taiwan’s SEF chief Chiang Pin-kung. This decision is to deliberately provoke the Taiwanese people, divide the Taiwanese society and attack Taiwan’s fragile and hard-fought democracy. We strongly condemn the KMT government’s China policies and protest the government for denying Taiwan’s sovereignty and ignoring Taiwan’s human rights, freedom and democracy.

TAIWAN NEWS: Although Ma and other KMT leaders denounced the "violence" of these unarmed citizens, it is in fact the KMT's monopolization of secret cross-strait negotiations without legislative, media or citizen oversight and its obstruction of the peaceful expression of dissent that forced the people to the streets to protest the KMT's use of state violence.

JOHNNY NEIHU: Now, alas, my buddies in uniform are being sent to clean up a political mess. But it can’t be cleaned up this way for too long, or we will have a police state.

As if in preparation, senior DPP identities are being arrested and locked up in a Singapore-style purge-by-judiciary. Not just the Chen Shui-bian gang, but also sitting elected representatives. Like Singapore, there is just enough legal process to satisfy ignorant foreign media, but way too much for local newspapers and TV stations to be bothered with.

After I turned off the TV, I had a sense of foreboding because I now know how it’s going to play out. Every step of what parachute-packing foreign correspondents call “cross-strait detente” or “rapprochement” or “easing of tensions” will, by necessity, include encroachment on domestic civil liberties — and therefore political liberties — at the reluctant hands of Taiwan’s finest. I also know that there are a lot of people who will fight to stop this from happening.

We’re on our way, dear reader. Will you join me on this journey?

Washington Changes: Obama, Congress

The Apple Daily announces "America's First Black President!" with whites on one side of the picture frame and blacks on the other.

Charles Snyder of the Taipei Times reports on the changes in Congress, as several supporters of Taiwan lost their seats....
In any event, Taiwan lost several of its leading supporters in the House in Tuesday’s elections, and lobbyists for Taiwan are scrambling to find replacements.

A significant loss will be Republican Steve Chabot of Ohio, a co-chairman of the Congressional Taiwan Caucus, who was defeated in his re-election bid.

In addition, the 150-member caucus lost 10 other members.

Four of those retired from the House, including Republican Tom Tancredo of Colorado, perhaps the most steadfast of Taiwan’s advocates in Congress.

Another former caucus member, Democrat Mark Udall of Colorado, was elected to the Senate, and is expected to be an additional Taiwan supporter in that chamber.

In the Senate, where only a third of the incumbents were up for re-election, the fate of Saxby Chambliss, a Georgia Republican and strong Taiwan backer, has yet to be decided.

The other three co-chairmen of the House caucus — Robert Wexler, Dana Rohrabacher and Shelley Berkley — all won re-election handily, as did the co-chairmen of the Senate Taiwan Caucus, Republican James Inhofe of Oklahoma and Democrat Tim Johnson of South Dakota.

It was not immediately clear which of the newly elected members of the House or Senate will join the caucuses or be friendly toward Taiwan.

But, as they look for a replacement for Chabot, lobbyists are looking at representatives such as Republican Scott Garrett of New Jersey, who took on US President George W. Bush on behalf of Taiwan in the Congress, and is expected to be willing to continue espousing Taiwanese causes, Blaauw says.

As for the Obama team, all indications are that it will be a very centrist-oriented team with strong pro-China biases but fairly supportive of Taiwan on the whole, or so I have heard from my friends in Washington. Remember that the Obama Asia team comprises more than 70 people, so pinning anyone down for a future position is hard. But here are some things I've heard.

The Obama team's Asia director is former State Department and NSC official Jeff Bader. He is likely to be a key player in the next administration. Search this blog for his name for some of his writings on Taiwan. Bader may wind up in a high state department policy post, or perhaps (less likely) as ambassador to China. Bader comes out of a China background.

Frank Januzzi, who has close ties to Biden, may end up high in the State Department or in the Vice President's foreign policy office or similar position. Januzzi is an Asia expert with some expertise in military issues.

Richard Bush, former AIT director, longtime Hill staffer, former NIO for East Asia, and Taiwan expert, may also play a large role. Bush authored the "assent of the people of Taiwan" formula and stuck it into our policy. He's written articles and books about Taiwan, and is very supportive of the island.

Other names mentioned include Mike Lampton of SAIS, Ken Lieberthal of the University of Michigan who worked in the Clinton NSC, Evan Medeiros of RAND, Kevin Nealer, former State Department official (Economics) and Japan specialist Matthew Goodman who is at Stonebridge, the consulting firm that helps US corporations in China, with Bader and Lieberthal. Most are big names and there may not be enough seats at the high table to go around.

Other possible contributors on Asia security could be former DASD Kurt Campbell, and former Feinstein staffer Michael Schiffer who now directs Asia programs for the Stanley Foundation. Campbell put in better military to military contacts when he worked in the Clinton Administration. Also mentioned is Jim Steinberg, a candidate for National Security Advisor, who is a good friend of Hsiao Bi-khim, the DPP legislator and foreign affairs official.

People say it is an experienced, centrist, team with many old China hands. Taiwan people on the Hill say that there are people in there who can be worked with.

UPDATE: Taipei Times argues differently today, concluding:

Supporters of Taiwanese democracy must have listened to Obama’s invocation of Abraham Lincoln with a mixture of admiration and wistfulness. Based on the evidence available, despite the warning signs from China and pro-China forces in Taiwan, and despite all the energy that hope can generate, no one can really say if an Obama administration would act to stop a Taiwanese government of the people, by the people and for the people from perishing.

Take me out to the ballgame: Int'l baseball in Taichung

Took Friday evening off from politics, which are now exceedingly depressing, and visited the beautiful new Intercontinental Stadium (BAD: not international because Taiwan is not a country; GOOD: we've been promoted to continent) in Taichung to watch the La New Bears of Kaohsiung play the Giants from Japan. My son and I met up with my friend Karl there. Immediately we adopted the Taiwan side as our own, since we couldn't pronounce any of the Japanese names, especially after a couple of beers.

The new stadium is clean and beautiful.

Buddhist monks? No, a local baseball team watches in uniform.

Fans mob the Giant dugout.

Before the game, cheerbabes provided eye candy entertainment.

The La New team is introduced.

The first batter.

Ready to steal second.

Fans are psyched. The atmosphere, low key and friendly, was very enjoyable.

Cheerbabes lead the crowd.

Cheerbabes hard at work.

Fried stuff, to go with your....

....Blue Girl beer. MILESTONE: Near as I can tell, this image was the 10,000th photo I have posted to my FLICKR account.

Outside the fence fans attempted to watch the game for free.

Great luck! I caught the game's key play -- with men on second and third, the batter hits a deep single to center to bring in two runs, and gets to second when the throw back from center field is screwed up. We take a 6-1 lead.

The cameraman captures the action.

Cheer babes taking break.

Tense action in the 8th, as the Giants score another run to shave our lead to 6-2.

Bottom of the 9th: is the bottom going to fall out of our game? Our reliever is put in and promptly loads the bases: walk, beans a batter, single. The tying run is at bat! New pitcher comes in: bases loaded, no outs. Amazingly, they shut down the Giants, allowing only a single run, to pull out a 6-3 win. Huzzah!

Baseball in Taiwan is good clean fun, and a huge bargain at $220 for infield seating. If you haven't enjoyed a baseball game here yet, put it on your calendar. There are more games this weekend in Kaohsiung (not Taichung!) on Saturday.

Friday, November 07, 2008

Daily Links, Nov 8, 2008


Keeping a sharp eye out for what's on the blogs today....
  • D. Corey asks: are the Taiwanese fed up yet?

  • Temples honoring Japanese officers in Taiwan.

  • The Bushman checks out recumbent bicycles

  • Carrefour to launch mobile phone service in Taiwan?

  • Ken's wife tries to pass the driver's exam in Texas.

  • Pinyin News on Penghu Street signs.

  • Limits on Chinese tour groups relaxed.

  • People moving to China cause new car sales to drop. It has nothing to do with the high price of gas, the convenience of scooters, the rise in bicycle use, or the excellent public transportation.

  • Fili does the east coast.

  • The truth about Obama and Taiwan

  • Protests: Everyone is still struggling to put these in perspective. Don't miss HaiTien's account of the executive yuan protest. And J Michael Cole's. Taiwan regressing? David Reid's eyewitness account. David also worries about the chilling effect of the government's recent moves. The Student Protest, also from David. Now that Chen's gone... from Lao Ren Cha. Agu has tons of stuff to ponder. It's Martial Law 2.0 says maddog. Clashes between journalists and police.

  • MEDIA: Is it too little too late for Taiwan's air cargo firms?

    "Taiwan, compared to Korea - especially for cargo from northern China - is not very viable," remarked James Gagne, chief executive officer for Greater China.

    Being confined to the sidelines of the China boom was doubly frustrating for the Taiwanese carriers, as their own customer base was steadily expanding in the forbidden market. Taiwanese manufacturers have kept shifting production to China, effectively putting their output out of reach of EVA and China Airlines while eroding flows from Taiwan.

    Surfing in Taiwan (with great photos). My university makes a small step in fusion research. Fusion research is like middle age: it is always 10 years ahead of where you are now. Economic growth will remain at around 4.1% this year and next year since inflation is going to go down while government spending will go up, says the China Post. Want Want group buys the pro-KMT China Times. The move is an apparent response to Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai's attempt to buy the paper. Lai is anti-CCP, Want Want CEO is pro-Beijing and pro-KMT. Or so the story goes. Beijing military skeptical of Ma's commitment to sell out Taiwan, continue to push military build up. Sheesh, Ma can't make anybody happy. Economic crisis leads to rise in dumped dogs.

    CHEN YUNLIN VISIT: WaPo reports that the meeting "follow landmark negotiations in Beijing in June that ended nine years of non-contact between the two sides" as if the DPP and the CCP hadn't engaged in negotiations on numerous issues during this time, and there had never been extensive cooperation and contacts between the KMT and Beijing (that didn't go back to the 1990s). Someday the backchannel negotiations between the Chinese Communist Party and the Chinese Nationalist Party will make the regular media and I'll have a heart attack. Chen says the agreements were the high point of his life. NYTimes' Ed Wong with good reporting on the historic meeting and on the agreements. Foreign Chambers of Commerce laud deals, which they have pushed Taipei to make for years. Security people drag off CNA cameraman during Chen visit. Bonnie Glaser and Brad Glosserman weigh in for the US Establishment on the Chen Yunlin talks. I wish I had more time to examine the many problems with this article. Taiwan News deconstructs the "apolitical" aspect of the visit. The Cross-Strait pacts will be submitted to the legislature. Which is controlled by the KMT, but hasn't been very cooperative. Still, there is no reason for the legislature to reject them.

    There's been plenty written on the Chen Yunlin visit and the protests. I'll round that up tomorrow, and comment on it. It's too much, and like so many people who watched Taiwan take another backward lurch today, I'm having some trouble wrapping my head around it all.

    EVENTS: New Taiwanese Foundation has a seminar on the talks on Saturday.

    『江陳會之後的兩岸關係座談會』
    主辦單位:新台灣人基金會
    協辦單位:台灣法學雜誌
    時間:11月9日(星期日) 下午1:00-5:10
    地點:福華國際文教會館14樓貴賓廳 (台北市新生南路三段30號)

    大陸海協會會長陳雲林來台訪問五天,期間簽署四項協議:空運、海運、郵政、食品,
    但也引發出不少的爭議與抗爭活動,終於在今天(11/7)上午陳會長離台後暫時告一段落,
    但陳先生的來訪究竟為台灣人民帶來哪些影響呢?此次座談會討論主題:江陳會過程的省
    思、江陳會對兩岸關係的實質影響。

    本會邀請多位知名的兩岸學者、專家,共同來探討。
    歡迎各位蒞臨參加!

    主題:江陳會對兩岸關係的實質影響
    主持人:蘇永欽 (國家通訊傳播委員會 主任委員) 邀請中
    與談人: 李文忠 (前立法委員) 邀請中
    黃光國 (台灣大學 心理系 教授 ) 邀請中
    林濁水 (前立法委員)
    張五岳 (淡江大學 中國大陸研究所 所長)
    劉憶如 (台灣大學 財務金融系 教授) 邀請中


    姓名: 職稱:

    服務單位:

    聯絡電話: 行動電話:

    電子郵件:

    出席意願: □ 出席 □ 不克參加
    如要參加本活動敬請MAIL回覆或來電報名,感謝您的配合與支持。
    新台灣人文教基金會 執行秘書 吳璟妤
    Tel: 02-8789-4812
    Fax:02-8789-4815
    Phone: 0937-408-063
    http://www.newtaiwanese.org.tw
    台北市信義路五段150巷2號16樓1600室

    Protest Pictures

    Protesters walk by barbed wire.

    A friend who was at yesterday's protest has graciously consented to letting me post some of his pictures here. The complete set is on his Flickr account. Posters on Forumosa, the most important expat discussion group here, noted:
    Actually, a very calm crowd. I remember several times during the Red Tide, we had great difficulty in going out for lunch -and at least once all the doors had to be locked, leaving yours truly outside.

    Traffic, on the other hand, is a nightmare. If anyone has to come to the area, plan accordingly.

    I just got back from the protest. I arrived around 1.30pm. The "violence" from what I saw was tiny, a few dozen people out of tens of thousands. So people, stopped falling for media propoganda. As soon as people starting getting rough wiht the police organizers jumped in immediately to try to stop them.

    This was a peaceful protest and 99.99% of people simply marched and shouted as is their right.

    I took tons of pics and will post some later.

    One thing to consider though. This was gross overkill on the gov's part. I decided to walk around the cordoned area around the presidential building and it took me 1.5 hours. About 2 square kilometres or more were blocked off with barbed wire, metal fences and rows of cops in riot gear.

    Provoke your people like this, act as if you are scared of them, and shit is going to happen.

    The local papers usually announce them. I knew the protest was today and saw the time posted in the Taipei Times when I got up. Since I had a free day I rushed downtown to be part of the fun.

    No problem at all video taping and photographing. Everyone is doing it.

    As for the "violence" well, after the metal fences were pulled down everyone just moved into the centre of the road and sat and stood on the dividers with the palm trees growing out of them. Even the baboo baboo vendors moved in.

    We have seen large numbers of riot police, brutality and barbed wire and water cannons before. Used to be a regular sight not too long ago.

    Its the same old tussle. DPP vs KMT. Taiwan independence vs China.

    Southern Taiwan vs Northern Taiwan (again DPP vs KMT)

    The police tactic is again to let the protestors run amok and cause trouble. The KMT does this time and again to show people that the DPP brings trouble. Gangsters are always employed for this purpose and heaven knows Taiwan is 10pct made up of gangsters and hooligans who just LOVE a chance to riot and get back at the police.

    Yep. You set up a perimetre that takes almost two fucking hours to walk around, put cops in riot gear all over the streets, and barbed wire walls, well, this is provocation. Seriously, everyone should get out there and see just how many cops are about and the ridiculous level of overkill.

    When a government stops trusting the people, then the people start acting in like fashion.

    cjc444, I am interested to know if you saw any violence at all. I saw one incident which was tiny but obviously from the way some people reacted on Fcom the news made it seem monstrously out of control. I also have my suspicions about the guys who started fighting with the police as I was not 30m from the incident. When the walls came down a groups of tough looking guys just suddenly ran around the corner and rushed over to start trouble with the police.

    It was very suspicous as everyone else just hung back or crossed the barrier and proceeded to hang out on the street. You'll see in my pics later.

    I went to all the 3 protests today (afternoon, Legislative Yuan and ZhongShang North Road, and didn't see any violence - even when I was taking pictures of the cops behind the barbwire in ZhongShang N. Road....

    What you see on the news is just what they want you to see.... what about being there, and feeling it?

    What about being with about 200 people and watching more than 400 cops crossing the bridge, watching water tanks coming in and people with video cameras filming everything (but just the protester side, not the police side)?

    I missed the part where the protesters snipped the wires and broke through the barricades so I cannot comment on that and when I arrived at the area around NTU all I saw was a handful of a-bei's beating on the shields. After that calmed down I headed to the protests at the bridge where I expected to see violence, but while I was there the only violence I saw was water bottles being chunked at the fully-armoured pigs. At one point a couple of protesters pulled down one of the barricades and I shit-you-not within 15 minutes a group of guys picked it back up and set it back in place so no one would get hurt.

    When I left at 10:30 it seemed the majority of the protesters were dispersing so I agree with your observations that the violence was done by a select few who were up to no good.

    Overall this week I attended four different protests, and I was very very proud to be involved. I took hundreds of pics these past few days and they pretty much mirror yours MM. And I will repeat again, if these situations happened in our countries, the violence seen here would be minor compared to what we would have seen at home.
    The protest appeared to be following a very common pattern in which it is peaceful until the evening or until the waning moment, when the "brothers" show up to make it "violent." It is best to take the idea of "violent DPP protesters" with a grain of salt. Since the TV media naturally focuses on the violent acts, "I saw it on TV" is not a valid representation of the protest. Realtime camera of one of the protests here.











    As Mucha Man pointed out when he took this, the "violence" is limited to a few people -- in other words, it's the usual thing at protests.

    This last one is from my friend Mr. Boogie.

    Thursday, November 06, 2008

    Taiwan Says Hello To Chen Yunlin

    PRC negotiator Chen Yunlin arrived in Taipei and inked a pact on direct shipping links and direct flights, as well as panda diplomacy (take two, Taiwan).

    Wednesday protesters mobbed the hotel, as reported by Reuters, preventing Chen from leaving for hours. According to AFP he was able to escape back to that symbol of KMT power, the Grand Hotel, in the wee hours of the morning after police threw back over 2,000 protesters. AP said that protesters threw eggs and banged on cars at the Formosa Regent, though BBC said it was only cars with tinted windows. VOA reported that DPP Chair Tsai Ing-wen was in the crowd, urging them to come to a rally the following day. Fox News reported on the protests but also discussed the issue of Chen's use of Ma's title "Regional Administrator President" at the meeting which supposedly was taking place today. The issue was avoided, as Max Hirsch at Kyodo News noted:
    Hundreds, if not thousands, of protesters spilled out into streets surrounding the five-start hotel, with a handful of them managing to get inside the lobby.
    Hundreds of police were mobilized in response, often clashing with demonstrators, who managed to block all exits until 2 a.m., when Chen was quietly escorted out a side door and into a waiting van that took him to his own hotel, Taipei's landmark Grand Hotel.

    Surrounded by barbed-wire barricades, that hilltop hotel has stood its ground against a steady onslaught of protesters since Monday, when Chen arrived from Beijing leading a delegation of some 60 senior Chinese officials. Chen has been dogged by hecklers on virtually every leg of his tour.

    Though a milestone in relations across the Taiwan Strait, Thursday's meeting was unusually brief. Chen stood silently except to introduce to Ma a scroll painting of a horse, a gift alluding to Ma's surname, which means ''horse'' in Chinese. Ma gave Chen a Chinese vase and the two shook hands amid salvos of camera flashes.
    KMT legislative Speaker Wang Jin-pyng even asked Chen to have China dismantle the 1400 missiles that are now pointed at Taiwan. Outside on Thursday DPP Chairman Tsai led a massive rally against the government and the China envoy:

    A sea of protesters with yellow ribbons are now on the streets, and police officers are using video cameras to help track down any possible offenders. According to the Taipei police department, "heavy-handed" police force of 3,000 has been dispatched and the controlled area is seven to eight times larger than the actual protest area.

    Razor wires have been spreaded out in place to deter pro-Taiwan independence protesters from getting close to Chen and crossing the line for violence. Some people slammed the government for overreacting. In the strange political atmosphere, some people could not help but to question: Has the martial law era, which was lifted in 1987, come back to Taiwan again?


    More ominous than the trade agreements, which contained items long advocated by the DPP, were the numerous reportsof police taking action to silence protests and to harass, intimidate, and disperse peaceful protesters. The Taiwan Association for Human Rights has put together an online petition and lists some of the cases. Other people reported that police stopped people with video cameras, were videoing protesters, broke into shops playing music they didn't like, and so on. Police prevented people from waving the ROC flag, and from displaying the Tibetan flag as well. None of this was necessary; Chen Yunlin would not have been harmed by seeing any of it, and all the energy spent corralling the pro-independence side was totally misspent. Taiwan News reported on a coalition of civic groups under the umbrella of the Taiwan Association for Human Rights protesting about the apparent suppression of freedom of speech:

    A coalition of human rights, judicial reform and social movement organizations criticized the Kuomintang government of President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) for "pulling Taiwan's human rights standards down to the level of the People's Republic of China," citing widespread suppression of the freedom of speech of pro-Taiwan protestors during the visit of Chinese envoy Chen Yunlin.

    Taiwan Association for Human Rights Chairman Lin Chia-fan told reporters that over 60 civic reform groups and 100 activists had signed a common statement within 12 hours, including numerous legal and human rights organizations and "July 15 scholars" who had been sharply critical of the previous Democratic Progressive Party administration of ex-president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁).

    "Chen Yunlin stated that he had heard the protests, but what we have heard and seen is how the Ma government has trampled human rights and how citizens holding peaceful demonstrations have been pushed and struck by police and how our national flag has been confiscated from the hands of citizens while the Chinese five-star flag has been allowed to freely fly," said Lin.

    Lin said that the human rights and legal reform groups demanded that Ma "apologize to all our people for selling out the human rights and legal achievements of the Taiwan people in order to meet the demands of a dictatorship."

    Taiwan Sovereignty Watch also made a list of police actions:

    1. The policy confiscated and damaged personal belongings of flags and balloons held by people at protest venues.

    2. In the evening of November 2, four Taichung City Councilors, Chen Shu-hua (陳淑華), Chiu Su-chen (邱素貞), Chi Li-yu (紀麗玉) and Lai Chia-wei (賴佳微), checked in the Grand Hotel where Chen Yulin would stay during his visit. The next morning, they displayed protest banners from the balcony of their room. Within one minute, special agents broke in the balcony and entered their room, without their consent, to remove banners and restrain their actions.

    3. Three bloggers with national flags of Taiwan and Tibet in hand were forcefully taken away by the police when walking southbound along Chung Shan North Rd and passing by the Taiwan Cement Building, where Chen Yunlin visited Cecilia Koo Yen, widow of the former chairman of the Straits Exchange Foundation. The arrest caused the dislocation of fingers of one of the bloggers, but police refused to send her for medical treatment until she provided personal information.

    4. Chen Yu-ching (陳育青), a photographer who visited friends near the Grand Hotel, was arrested and sent to the police station for interrogation for shooting the video of the banned area with hand-held camera.

    5. Hung Chien-yi (洪建益), a Taipei councilman, entered the Ambassador Hotel, where Chen Yunlin's dinner reception was held, in the afternoon. When leaving by himself in the evening, he was dragged away on the ground for tens of yards by several police officers at the front gate of the hotel. He did not shout derogatory slogans or carry any dangerous items but only wore a T-shirt with the mark of "No Conspiracy with China" on it.

    6. On November 4th, while Chen Yunlin was at the dinner reception hosted by KMT leaders at the Ambassador Hotel, a nearby record store was playing some Taiwanese song out loud. The police thought the song would stir up the feelings of the protesters on the scene, so they, in uniform or plainclothes, led by Beitou Police District Chief Lee Han Ching, broke into that record store, asked the store owner to stop the music, and shut the door.

    7. On November 3rd, the Association of Taiwan Journalist issued that Cheng Chieh-wen (鄭傑文), a photojournalist from the Central News Agency, was dragged by the security police for 10 meters while he was doing his job at the Grand Hotel, and that an inappropriate press coverage area plan had caused quarrels between the press and the officials. ATJ declared that press freedom was under severe attack in Taiwan. Meanwhile, the government imposed such strict control over press coverage for this event that several reporters from Hong Kong said they failed to get press passes and had limited rights for coverage.

    UPDATE: David below observes:

    Another incident that should be added to the list is the Freddy incident. Freddy Lim was accosted by police while simply walking down the street. I am sure there are some others that should be noted as well.
    These totally unnecessary heavy-handed police state tactics have besmirched the island's reputation. They may also provide the new generation of Taiwanese a taste of what their grandparents went through -- and we all know what the result of that was -- while showing their elders how the Ma government wastes their taxpayer dollars, fiddling while the economy burns.

    Another point: lots of us, including me, thought the DPP should have let the Olympic Torch in and then let people protest the heck out of it -- but then this sort of police state action may well have taken place on the DPP watch, since it would not have been able to exercise close control over the police all along the route of the Torch.

    FORMULAIC RESULTS: RTT's article on the protests that walled in Chen Yunlin for hours may well have the strangest construction of The Formula ever. Enjoy it in all its glorious weirdness:

    The relations between the two neighbors across the Taiwan Strait soured after the Chinese civil war of 1949, in which Mao Zedong's Communists emerged victorious. However, it has improved recently after the Kuomintang (KMT) party under President Ma Ying-jeou came to power in Taiwan ousting the pro-independence Democratic Progressive Party government in the last elections.

    In fact the article twice says "the Chinese Civil War of 1949." No, I kid you not, though I suspect that it is a translation issue. VOA has the merely historically inaccurate "split in 1949" formulation.

    Wednesday, November 05, 2008

    Obama Victorious


    Watched the returns at the Early Bird (150 Jongming South Rd, just past Gongyi Rd) and enjoyed the great breakfast diner food and good Democratic company.

    Probably some of you noted that I stopped blogging on the election and took down my posts. It was just too divisive. I'm glad it is over.

    We Americans did ourselves proud today. But as my Taiwanese wife said:

    "You Americans are amazing. You elected a black man president. You are so lucky. You have your own country.

    We don't even have a country yet."

    Democrat or Republican, there's much still to work toward on this island that we all love.

    Joint Statement on Detentions in Taiwan

    A Joint Statement from international scholars and analysts concerned with the apparent politicization of the prosecutorial arm in Taiwan. UPDATE: Names are still being added, so contact gerrit@fapa.org if you want to add yours. UPDATE 2: Document is permanently hosted at Taiwan Documents.org

    +++++++++++++

    November 4, 2008

    JOINT STATEMENT

    US, European and Australian scholars and writers express concern about prosecutions in Taiwan

    The undersigned, scholars and writers from the US, Europe and Australia wish to express their deep concern about the recent series of detentions in Taiwan of present and former DPP government officials. To date there have been at least seven such cases (See list below).

    以下聯署的國際學者對於近日台灣政府一連串拘留卸任與現任民進黨政府官員的行動,深表憂慮。直至今日,據我們瞭解共有七件類似案件。

    It is obvious that there have been cases of corruption in Taiwan, but these have occurred in both political camps. The political neutrality of the judicial system is an essential element in a democracy. It is also essential that any accused are considered innocent until proven guilty in the court of law.

    很明顯的,貪污這個問題在台灣依然存在,但是這樣的案例在兩大政黨裡均曾發生。司法系統維持政治中立是民主的基本要素。堅持任何被指控者在裁定有罪前均是無罪的法律理念也是必要的。

    We also believe that the procedures followed by the prosecutor's offices are severely flawed: while one or two of the accused have been formally charged, the majority is being held incommunicado without being charged. This is a severe contravention of the writ of habeas corpus and a basic violation of due process, justice and the rule of law.

    我們認為檢察官所採取的法律程序有著嚴重的缺失:雖然當一、兩位被指控者已被正式起訴時,大多數被指控者卻在未被正式起訴情況之下就遭到收押禁見。這嚴重違反了人身保護令以及正當法律程序、公義與法治。

    In the meantime, the prosecutor's offices evidently leak detrimental information to the press. This kind of "trial by press" is a violation of the basic standards of judicial procedures. It also gives the distinct impression that the Kuomintang authorities are using the judicial system to get even with members of the former DPP government. In addition, the people who are being held incommunicado are of course unable to defend themselves against the misreporting and the leaks in the news media.

    在此同時,檢察官辦公室很明顯地將相關不利消息透露給媒體。這種「透過媒體辦案」的方式違反司法程序的基本標準;也讓外界認為國民黨政府利用司法系統來報復已下台的民進黨政府。此外,被收押禁見的人,在與外界斷絕聯繫的情況下,無法澄清外界不實報導與媒體洩密。

    We do firmly believe that any alleged wrongdoings must be dealt with in a fair and open manner in an impartial court. Justice through the rule of law is essential to Taiwan's efforts to consolidate democracy and protect fundamental human rights.

    我們深信任何宣稱的犯罪行為應該以公正與公開的方式,在中立的法庭裡審判。透過法治落實司法,才能強化台灣民主與保障基本人權。

    We do not want to see Taiwan's hard-earned democracy jeopardized in this manner. Taiwan can justifiably be proud of its transition to democracy in the late 1980s and early 1990s. It would be sad for Taiwan and detrimental to its international image if the progress which was made during the past 20 years would be erased. Taiwan needs to move forward, not backwards to the unfair and unjust procedures as practiced during the dark days of Martial Law (1947-87).

    我們不願見到台灣辛苦得來的民主陷入如此困境。台灣因為在八零年代後期與九零年早期成功轉型為民主國家,而引以為傲。如果過去二十年來的民主進展從此抺煞,這不僅將令人難過,台灣的國際形象也將受到嚴害傷害。台灣必須向前邁進,而不應是開倒車回到過去戒嚴黑暗時代的不公與不義。

    Signed:

    簽署人:

    Nat Bellocchi, former Chairman of the American Institute in Taiwan  
    Julian Baum, former Taiwan Bureau Chief, Far Eastern Economic Review
    Coen Blaauw, Formosan Association for Public Affairs, Washington DC
    David Prager Branner, Director at Large (East Asia), American Oriental Society
    Gordon G. Chang, author, "The Coming Collapse of China."
    June Teufel Dreyer, Professor of Political Science, University of Miami, Florida
    Edward Friedman, Professor of Political Science and East Asian Studies, University of Wisconsin, Madison
    Bruce Jacobs, Professor of Asian Languages and Studies, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia
    Richard C. Kagan, Professor Emeritus of History, Hamline University, St. Paul Minnesota
    Jerome F. Keating, Associate Professor, National Taipei University (Ret.). Author, "Island in the Stream, a quick case study of Taiwan's complex history" and other works on Taiwan
    Daniel Lynch, Associate Professor, School of International Relations, University of Southern California
    Victor H. Mair, Professor of Chinese Language and Literature, University of Pennsylvania
    Donald Rodgers, Associate Professor of Political Science, Austin College, Texas
    Terence Russell, Professor of Chinese Language and Literature, University of Manitoba
    Scott Simon, Professor of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Ottawa
    John J. Tkacik Jr., Senior Research Fellow, The Heritage Foundation, Washington DC
    Gerrit van der Wees, Editor Taiwan Communiqué, Washington DC
    Vincent Wei-cheng Wang, Professor of Political Science, University of Richmond, Virginia
    Arthur Waldron, Lauder Professor of International Relations, University of Pennsylvania
    Stephen Yates, President of DC Asia Advisory and former Deputy Assistant to the Vice President for National Security Affairs
    ---------------------------------------------------------------

    Specific cases of concern:
    -- The arrest and detention on October 15th of former Interior minister Yu Cheng-hsien;

    -- The arrest and detention on October 27th of former Hsinchu Science Park Director and Deputy Minister of Environmental Protection Dr. James Lee;

    -- The arrest and detention on October 29th of DPP Chiayi County Commissioner Chen Ming-wen;

    -- The indictment on October 30th of DPP Tainan City Councilor Wang Ting-yu;

    -- The arrest and detention on October 31st of former National Security Council (NSC) secretary-general and Deputy Prime Minister Chiou I-jen;

    -- The questioning of former Foreign Minister Dr. Mark Chen on November 3rd and insinuations in the press that he might be charged and arrested.

    -- The arrest and detention on November 4th of DPP Yunlin County Magistrate Ms. Su Chih-fen.

    +++++++++++++

    Ma Yung-cheng, another presidential office official in the Chen Administration, was taken into custody on embezzlement charges yesterday. Note how the wave of arrests has coincided with the publicity push over the Chen Yunlin visit.

    Can we see some action in the international media on this? It would be a good way to put into perspective the lack of access to the Chen Yunlin visit that the media were complaining about.

    Tuesday, November 04, 2008

    BREAKING: More DPP Politicians face questioning, possible detention

    Is it looking like a pattern yet? ....it came to my ears that DPP Yunlin County Mayor Su Chih-fen was taken into custody at 6 am this morning by prosecutors for questioning in relation to charges of accepting bribes in an alleged corruption scandal over a waste treatment plant. Su is still under questioning.

    In addition, the Special Investigation Unit this morning issued a subpoena for former presidential deputy secretary general Ma Yung-cheng, the first one for Ma, as a defendant in the first family "money laundering" and state affairs fund case and did not exclude applying to put Ma under investigative detention.

    People in detention are held incommunicado and may not respond to the false reports and "leaks" that appear in the media.

    Stay tuned as this news may change as more details come in.

    ARATS visit round up

    The Financial Times says it all: Top China official to visit Taiwan.

    The Taipei Times has a huge collection of stuff each day in a special feature. An article on taxi drivers parking to protest the Chen-Ma meeting. DPP Chair Tsai pens open letter. Taipei Times' review of world media outlets on the visit. Taiwanese bankers in China call for quick deal on cross-strait financial issues. The Taipei Times also editorializes on the heavy security surrounding ARATS Chairman Chen's visit, and the fact that in Taipei, ROC flags and other objects that might "offend" the colonialists from across the strait, like Tibetan flags, have been banned. In fact Taiwan News reports that police dispersed protesters for unfurling the national flag. On Monday a DPP legislator wrote a commentary on safeguarding Taiwan's national interests. The China Post has a complete rundown of the itinerary. AP reports on the protests over the visit, as does the Guardian and Reuters India. Good work, guys. TSMC calls for China, Taiwan cooperation on semiconductors. The DPP launched a three-day sit in to protest the visit. Taiwan News points out that Ma holds completely different positions on direct links than he did when he was head of the MAC.

    MEDIA MOMENTS: Kudos to Ed Wong of the NYTimes for a very balanced article on the visit, and a miraculous rendition of the Formula:
    The Chinese Communist Party sees Taiwan as a rebel province that split from China in 1949, when the KMT sought refuge on the island after losing the Chinese civil war, and must be brought back into the fold. Many Taiwanese prefer to maintain the current status quo of de facto independence, and some, especially members of the DPP, advocate formal independence.
    Now that takes the same two sentences that all the others do, yet manages to get out both sides of the issue. Great work, Ed! Why can't all the media outlets do that?

    Contrast the very fair NYT article, which manages to note that Ma is deeply unpopular and that many fear a sell-out, with former WaPo Beijing correspondent John Pomfret's bizarre WaPo blog posts on the Chen visit to Taiwan. It's OK right up to the moment it starts talking about the DPP, and then veers into a set of CCP talking points that have only the vaguest connection to reality, ignoring the widespread opposition to the feared sell-out, and Ma's deeply unpopularity for his "moderate" policies on China.

    AFP reports Ma not to "budge an inch" on sovereignty. -- yet despite Ma's concrete downgrading's of Taiwan's sovereighty, for example, saying Taiwan is a "region", not a state, AFP does not report that. Instead we get a paean to Ma's greatness:
    Relations with Beijing have improved dramatically since Ma came to power earlier this year and he has worked to boost business and tourism links with China following eight years of strained relations under a DPP government.
    This paragaph is completely asinine -- it constructs a world where the DPP did not "work to boost business and tourism links" but instead "relations were strained" -- true enough, but nothing like the whole truth. In fact, with $100-$200 billion of investment in Taiwan, the DPP government was by far the most open to China in the island's history, and all the current negotiations simply follow paths blazed by the DPP. But nowhere does AFP acknowledge any of that reality. Nor does it recognize why relations "improved" -- because Beijing refused to talk to the pro-democracy side, and likes Ma the pro-China ideologue.

    US Election: Reuters summarizes the respective positions of the two US candidates on Taiwan.