Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts

Friday, December 11, 2015

Ma government repays its supporters

DSC08405
Contemplating lunch?

The fearsome concentration of wealth in Taiwan has grown faster than most places....
The number of people whose liquid assets are worth US$1 million or more in Taiwan increased 11.8 percent last year to 125,000 — the biggest growth among the four economies known as the Asian Tigers, according to a wealth report published by Aspire Lifestyles.
Note that this is occurring as the economy lurches to a halt and income remains stagnant. The Ma Administration has rewarded its 1% supporters with delays and obfuscations on the stock transaction tax (finally imposed this year), the real estate assessment, capital gains tax, and other policies which hinder the transfer wealth from the middle and lower classes to the rich. Oh, and in 2009 the Ma Administration lowered the inheritance tax from 50% to 10%. Current KMT Presidential Candidate, Eric Chu, knowing on which side the KMT mian bao gets its 1% butter, is pandering to this crowd with calls saying the capital gains tax had been a mistake. The public knows this, one reason why Chu's numbers are well below 20% now.

The resulting housing bubble is devouring Taiwan, but it is also devouring the KMT. Keelung and Taoyuan are both becoming more pan-Green as young people -- overwhelmingly Green -- move out to those areas to find less expensive housing, changing the demographics of once solidly blue areas...
________________
Daily Links:
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Tuesday, January 13, 2015

What a coincidence. Ko's parents under investigation for tax evasion

The view from the Miaoli 51-1.

New Mayor Ko Wen-je of Taipei is making a splash. Not only did he stir up discussion in China with his simple ways, some of the local citizens are asking why their mayors can't be more like Ko. Very refreshing.

I'm sure it is just a coincidence that since he beat the KMT in the election the tax office is investigating his parents. Yes, surely the KMT would never use the governmental apparatus to punish the opposition.
Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je expressed dismay Monday that Taiwan's tax bureau is going after his parents for possible tax evasion because of a NT$10 million loan they gave Ko to help him pay for a house in Taipei.

Ko, a surgeon-turned-politician, said he was disgusted when the National Taxation Bureau audited his personal income taxes to see if he had reported income from speeches made in a few years prior to last year's Nov. 29 elections.

Ko said that now that the elections were over, the National Taxation Bureau was "going overboard" in having his father go to the agency and explain the matter.

"This goes beyond what any normal person can tolerate," Ko said, publicly asking the agency to explain its actions.
This post-election investigation is standard playbook and has happened to many DPP politicians, though tax evasion is certainly a new wrinkle -- probably because the standard attack is misuse of public funds, and Ko's parents are retired private citizens with no access to public funds. It says a lot about the KMT that it believes that all politicians are misusing public funds...

Sad. But since Ko is an independent, it can only increase his popularity.
________________
Daily Links:
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Thursday, May 22, 2014

Income tax PR move

The rift valley near Yuli.

Earlier this month the government "raised taxes" on "the wealthy" (FocusTaiwan)...
Based on the concept, the tax reform package includes the creation of a new individual income tax bracket with a marginal income tax rate of 45 percent for people reporting annual taxable income of over NT$10 million (US$329,446) a year.

Under the current tax code, the 40 percent rate bracket kicks in at a taxable income of more than NT$4.4 million.

The revision, if put through, is expected to affect around 9,500 people and generate an additional NT$9.9 billion in tax revenues.

In addition, the business tax for banking and insurance institutions will return to the previous 5 percent from the present 2 percent, which is expected to generate an additional NT$21 billion in tax revenues.

Also, the current tax credit afforded to individual shareholders receiving dividends would be cut by 50 percent and would generate more than NT$50 billion in tax revenues. All told, the increases will inject an additional NT$80 billion into national coffers.
This move taxes income, not capital gains, and only affects a tiny number of taxpayers who suffer an insignificant increase in their overall taxes. It is merely a PR move. Except for the reduction in the credit, capital income is not affected. Major tax dodges, such as the assessed value on real estate, remain unchanged. The minister claimed this will help income inequality -- probably in some tiny way, it will. But read your Picketty (I just finished it, fabulous book): as long as returns to capital exceed the overall rate of economic growth, then income inequality will worsen. Unless the government meaningfully tackles the pernicious problem of untaxed accumulated wealth, income inequality will continue to worsen.
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Thursday, April 24, 2014

Taxes and our fading economy


From the link below...

The Taipei Times wrote up a short piece on potential changes to the property tax laws to "curb property speculation"...
Taipei Deputy Mayor Chang Chin-oh (張金鶚) yesterday met with Minister of Finance Chang Sheng-ford (張盛和) to discuss the high housing prices, after Premier Jiang Yi-huah (江宜樺) vowed to reduce the home price to income ratio in the Greater Taipei area from 15.01:1 to 10:1 in two years.

“Under the cooperation established between the central and local governments, we are confident that the average cost of a housing unit [in the region] could be reduced by one-third in two years,” Chang Chin-oh told a press conference after leaving the ministry.

The two sides have agreed to expand the interval of the home tax rate on non-residential properties up to 3.6 percent and stipulate a more accurate definition of what constitutes self-use residences (properties not occupied by the owner).

Currently, local governments determine their own housing tax rate and all of them have adopted a rate of between 1.2 and 2 percent of a residential property’s value, which is the range set by the central government.
Note in that third paragraph the two salient points: (1) tax rate to jump up to 3.6% and (2) accurately defining what it means to self-use a residence. The skill lies in the second; it will be relatively easy for homeowners to evade this milequetoast tax rise simply by redefining their own residency.

The real issue, as always, is that the assessed value has remained the same since 1987. Recall this piece from the excellent mag Commonwealth:
Land in Taiwan has four different values. Aside from the actual market price, there is the "publicly announced land value," which is adjusted once every three years, the "reported current land value," which is the value reported by landowners used to calculate the land tax and can be up to 20 percent higher or lower than the publicly announced land value, and finally the "assessed present land value" on which land value increment taxes (similar to capital gains taxes) are based.

Taiwan's houses also have two prices -- the actual market price and a "standard unit price for housing construction" set by the tax revenue offices of each local government for residential units under their jurisdiction. This publicly assessed price has not been adjusted for 27 years. Legislator Lai Shyh-bao estimates that the current "standard unit price" is roughly only one-fifth of the actual market value.
and of course...
"Taiwan is the only country in the world that uses an assessed present value to calculate housing and land taxes," says the economist Ma Kai. The publicly assessed land and house value usually seriously understates actual market values. "The Palace's apartments are publicly valued at only NT$3 million to NT$4 million," Ma says of the luxury property that reportedly has sold its units for up to NT$ 70 million.

Another Commonwealth piece observed:
On a profit that was in fact NT$82 million but assessed by the government at NT$15.25 million, the investor paid a land value increment tax of NT$3.05 million, an effective tax rate of 3.71 percent. Even when deed taxes and other fees are added, the investor's tax liability was still under NT$4 million, or lower than 5 percent, the lowest marginal rate on personal income taxes.
You can see the problem. The additional tax on non-occupied residences is a fleabite because it doesn't address the real issue, the disparity between the assessed value and the actual value that has remained unchanged since 1987. That disparity is driving the enormous housing bubble in Taipei, an alternate universe of unreal values, spinning off still further alternate universes of housing price bubbles like a bad SF horror movie in other locations in Taiwan.

Still, that bubble of construction and "investment" is probably driving a large part of GDP and thus, no government can afford to prick that bubble. If Ma really wanted to screw the DPP, he'd raise the assessed value on real estate to current levels as his last act in office, but his Administration is owned and operated by the 1%, so don't look for that to happen.

Commonwealth also takes a look at the proposed tax reforms to make up the government's fiscal shortfall. I have a lot of respect for that mag: they produce a ton of useful articles on taxes and on economic growth and economic and finance policy. And they don't subscribe to the fiscal and economic insanity that lowering taxes on the wealthy produces economic growth.

Finally, a couple of weeks ago the 104 Job Bank, Taiwan's most important, produced data showing that average wages for first time job seekers fell below $30,000 NT a month. Other reports set the sum even lower, at 22K, a sum that was the butt of sardonic jokes during the occupation of the legislature. The 104 Job Bank also showed that average real wage is $44,739 for 2013, lower than the real average wage of $44,798 for 1998. Yet prices, the article notes, have risen 10% since then.
______________
Daily Links:
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Saturday, March 15, 2014

Commonwealth: Good news on taxes

Commonwealth notes that taxes in Taiwan are being truly reformed....
Subsequently, Chang announced the details of tax reform. The corporate income tax on financial industry companies will be raised back to 5 percent from the present tax rate of 2 percent. The amount of corporate income tax that shareholders can claim as tax credits to be deducted from their personal income tax, under Taiwan's integrated tax system, will be halved. A tax rate of 45 percent will be applied to the portion of rich people's net income that exceeds NT$10 million per year. If all these changes are implemented, the state will raise an additional NT$80 billion in tax revenue.

Together with the proposed tax hikes, which are supposed to help fill the budget gap, the reforms also include tax cuts for the average wage earner. The 6.47 million wage earners and the some 510,000 people with disabilities will have their tax-deductible quota raised by NT$20,000 to lessen their income tax burden. In terms of corporate taxes, the government is for the first time using tax measures to encourage employment. Small and medium enterprises can claim additional salary expenses multiplied by 1.3 as costs. The government also encourages companies to invest in R&D to boost their competitiveness.
The article frankly states that the idea that subsidizing the rich as America does will help the nation is absurd and untenable. Kudos to the writers. Taiwan's ratio of taxes to GDP is among the lowest in the developed world, the article points out.

Kudos also to the Ma government for setting out to do this in an election year.
______________
Daily Links:
  • If a foreigner like me lead a political protest in Taiwan, I'd certainly be arrested. But when Chinese lead protests.... the police do nada.
  • Ma said it was "undemocratic" but note that prominent pro-Unification gangster Chang An-le appeared to shout slogans and generally criticized the pulling down of the state of Sun Yat-sen. How long before his cohorts start showing up to break up rallies and election activities?
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Wednesday, May 29, 2013

Good-bye capital gains tax, we hardly knew ya

One of the many things this mess with the Phils has enabled the government to divert public attention from the drive to eliminate the capital gains tax. As a tax on the wealthy which kicked in when the stock market crossed 8,500, it was odious to the KMT, the island's party of the 1%. In the latest "economic stimulus" package of the government, it will be killed....
One of the measures involved the legislature passing an amendment to the Income Tax Act (所得稅法) before the current session ends on Friday to drop the 8,500-point threshold that automatically triggers the capital gains tax for individual investors, Jiang said.

The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) has proposed removing the requirement that the TAIEX surpass 8,500 points for the tax to be imposed and replace it with a tax on investors who sell NT$1 billion (US$33.3 million) worth of shares during one calendar year.

The premier said that abolishing the threshold would turn the economy around because it would be like “lifting the cover off a pot” to let the “suffocated” economy breathe.
Alas, removing the capital gains tax will simply result in more capital being hoarded and then shipped out of the country instead of being reinvested here and driving economic growth in Taiwan. It will only make the rich richer, and Taiwan being so expensive, the poor cannot even console themselves with babies.

UDN rightly complained:
Despite the many steps taken, however, nothing has seemed to work. The latest package focuses on expanding consumer spending, boosting domestic investment, encouraging innovation and new business start-ups, and revising the capital gains tax on stock sales. The content is not at all inspiring because it did not go beyond the existing policy framework.

Moreover, the government is planning to invest a mere NT$3.24 billion over five years in the new package. How can we expect it to rescue Taiwan's weak economy?
Figure it out. In US dollars, $3.24 billion is a little over US$100 million, or $20 million annually for the "stimulus". Peanuts.

According to the TT article, the DGBAS lowered its estimate of growth for the year to 2.4%. Recall that industrial output fell for the third straight month in April, as Bloomberg noted in its roundup of economic indicators.
____________________
Daily Links:
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

KMT Wants Stock Transaction Tax "postponed"

There is nothing so permanent as a temporary emergency -- Robert A. Heinlein

The KMT moves to protect one of its most important constituencies, the nation's wealthy non-taxpayers, by mooting a delay in the implementation of the stock transaction tax.
Several legislators called on the government to postpone levying a capital gains tax on stock transactions because the stock market continues to remain sluggish. KMT legislator Sun Ta-chien (孫大千) proposed raising the stock transaction tax from the current 0.3% to 0.35% and postponing the effective date of the recently passed capital gains tax on stock transactions. Moreover, as the capital gains tax on stock transactions would take effect on January 1, 2013, a high- ranking KMT official stated that the Legislative Yuan and the Cabinet could jointly propose a "sunrise clause" to postpone its implementation.
As I've noted a few times since the election (and before), I suspect a key hidden factor in the election was the support of the class of non-taxpaying holders of capital wealth for Ma. Now they are getting their money's worth out of the KMT.

Another factor here is the role of the stock market as an indicator of the nation's economic performance. Obsessive interest in rankings are a key cultural trait of the Taiwanese; playing with the stock market is playing with a major component of the national psyche.
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums! Delenda est, baby.

Thursday, October 04, 2012

Income gap/income stagnation

Ta-ken, Taichung.

On one of the lists I frequent we were discussing the reasons for Taiwan's stagnating income and slowing economic performance, stimulated by a recent short piece in WSJ which touches on some of the issues. A friend point me to this MUST READ article in Commonwealth on the tax situation here in Taiwan.... as I've noted before, the wealthy simply don't pay taxes:
Jim Huang is 35 years old, a member of the third generation of a powerful political family in Taiwan. He does not have a job, but he's doing just fine.

In Taiwan, he lives in a 660 square-meter luxury apartment on ritzy Renai Rd. that he inherited from his father, and he also owns property in Los Angeles, Shanghai and Germany.

Through overseas trusts, Huang also holds stocks in the United States, Hong Kong and Taiwan worth more than NT$1 billion. With the help of two private banking advisers and their use of hedging techniques in the equity and futures markets, he earns a 6 percent return, or roughly NT$50 million a year, on his investments regardless of whether markets are bullish or bearish.

But Huang now faces a major decision. The United States Internal Revenue Service has aggressively pursued overseas assets of Americans in recent years to boost tax revenues, and Huang, who has American citizenship, is thinking about giving it up.

"The United States is cracking down hard. I've been thinking that it might be better to come back and be Taiwanese," says Huang, which is not his real name. "In any case, when you add it all up, the tax burden here is really low."

Because Huang's investments are channeled through a complicated array of overseas trusts and multilayer reinvestment structures, Taiwan's National Tax Administration has him classified as a "low-income household." In 2011, he paid less in taxes than his driver, just one example of how Taiwan has become a low-tax paradise for the wealthy.
Some stats from the article:
  • "...Taiwan's ratio of tax revenues to GDP, known as the national tax burden ratio, fell from 20 percent in 1990 to 11.9 percent in 2010, the world's sixth lowest and even below those of Singapore (13.5 percent) and Hong Kong (13.9 percent), which are known as low-tax havens." 
  • "Taiwan's effective personal income tax rate is only 5.96 percent, the 10th lowest in the world."
  • "In 2010, the central government budget was 18.9 percent of GDP, the sixth lowest of any country around the globe."
  • "...[estimates] there are 96,000 high net-worth individuals in Taiwan. Their assets have grown by 30 percent over the past four years to NT$10 trillion, or roughly 10 percent of all the wealth in Taiwan. Banking executive: "According to our internal numbers, private banking customers pay about 8 to 10 percent of their income in taxes every year."(highest marginal personal income tax rate is 40 percent and alternative minimum tax is 20%).
  • In the five years from 2006 to 2010, household wealth in Taiwan grew by NT$24.6 trillion, according to DGBAS figures. Of that, NT$16.6 trillion, or nearly 70 percent, resulted from capital gains on stock transactions, which are not taxed in Taiwan, and profits from property transactions, which are taxed at very low rates.
Yes, that's right. I blogged on this before (Chen Shui-bian died for your sins). As the Commonwealth article notes, many rich investors have never paid taxes on their capital gains. The recent capital gains tax is a mere fig leaf and changes little. The assessed value on land, the real prize in the game, has not been changed since 1987. The result of the low assessed land value is described in the article as it talks about a luxury apartment sale:
On a profit that was in fact NT$82 million but assessed by the government at NT$15.25 million, the investor paid a land value increment tax of NT$3.05 million, an effective tax rate of 3.71 percent. Even when deed taxes and other fees are added, the investor's tax liability was still under NT$4 million, or lower than 5 percent, the lowest marginal rate on personal income taxes.
The effects of this non-taxation of wealth are totally pernicious. In the go-go days of the 70s and 80s Taiwan's thriving small and medium-sized businesses (SMEs) were funded by informal methods, since the banks were government-owned and generally didn't lend money to SMEs. In other words, local savings were sourced through a variety of methods as local start-up capital for manufacturing businesses which in turn generated growth and new savings, leading to a virtuous cycle of savings and investment. Today Taiwan's wealthy park their wealth overseas -- instead of capital staying local and driving new business growth, it enters vast international pools of global capital and is invested in securities which are backed by other securities or by global stocks, producing no new business growth at home. Taiwan's incorporation into the global financial system has meant that it is essentially being strip mined of its growth capital, siphoned off to global financial networks. Untaxed, too.

The wealthy also invest in land and real estate at home. The assessed value the government uses to calculate the tax on the land has not changed since 1987. This means that real estate is effectively a tax shelter. That's why the $82 million in profits on that house above were only taxed at $15 million. Observe, dear reader, that the government's pious moves to keep government property on or off the market or to play with the interest rates or to assure the public that those big Chinese buyers are just around the corner are just diversions meant to keep the public's eye off the ball, which is the assessed value. That has to be raised. Note also that the luxury building boom is not a construction boom of future apartments for buyers with money returning from China or from Chinese investing in Taiwan. The construction companies are building tax shelters for the rich.

Of course there are a number of other issues. The economy has transitioned from manufacturing to low paying service McJobs. A big chunk of capital has gone off to China, where many businesses struggle to survive and few really make it rich. This is one reason that Korea has done better than Taiwan, it has less exposure to China (and a much bigger domestic economy with global-scale manufacturers). One of the rich ironies of the Ma Administration's China Cargo Cult is that as Taiwan ties itself closer to China Taiwan's trade with that nation is actually in decline. Even worse, the article notes:
Tung Chen-yuan, a professor with the Graduate Institute of Development Studies at National Chengchi University and a former deputy chairman of the Mainland Affairs Council, says that over the past 10 years, Taiwanese businesses in China have paid nearly NT$3 trillion to the Chinese government, roughly twice Taiwan's total annual tax haul.
The article ends with a former finance minister noting how completely stupid it is to believe that tax cuts for the wealthy stimulate the economy -- actually, they simply transfer wealth to holders of wealth while killing economic growth. As we have seen in the US, and are experiencing now in Taiwan.

The China Times offered an editorial last week after the Labor Minister resigned in the wake of the failure to raise the minimum wage, and offered some dramatic stats on the stagnant income....
Official statistics show that income recipients in Taiwan earned NT$611,134 on average in 2011, down NT$3,882 from the previous year and declining to the level of 1998. The level is now 52 percent lower than South Korea, which had lower salary levels than Taiwan in the past, and barely half of Singapore's.
Now you can see one reason why we have a constant flow of foreign-directed controversies -- the Diaoyutai insanity, the Ractobeef mess with the US  -- keeping the media and public looking outward rather than inward towards the true source of the nation's problems -- because a lot more people are going to die from lack of an adequate income than from eating ractobeef.
___________________
Daily Links:
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums! Delenda est, baby.

Friday, June 01, 2012

Capital Gains Tax Dominates the News

Time for Vietnamese food.

Two days ago, in the post below this one, I blogged on the three-ring circus that the capital gains affair has become. The news is coming thick and fast....

First, the Premier formally accepted Finance Minister Christina Liu's resignation over the stock tax issue this week. Liu was apparently cast as the fall guy in this script; the same role her mother Shirley Guo played when she resigned as Finance Minister two decades ago over a similar issue. The various media reports say that people in the executive branch began to distance themselves from her as this issue went into high gear. People don't get into such positions without highly developed antennae to tell them who is political carrion.....

The capital gains tax proposal is slowing taking shape, pixel by pixel. Yesterday the cabinet revised the legislative proposal which Ma had accepted the other day. That proposal had been slammed by civic groups and by analysts as a set of sops to the wealthy and big business, as I noted in my post two days ago. The cabinet revisions are described in the Taipei Times as....
Three major revisions were made at last night’s meeting to the KMT caucus’ version.

First, the tax payment method based on the index level would be eradicated in 2017.

Second, rich people would not be allowed to use the index-based tax payment method.

Rich people are defined as shareholders who own more than 3 percent of the shares of a company, people whose annual income excluding income earned from shares transactions exceeds NT$5 million, and people who live in the country less than 183 days a year.

And third, starting in 2017, only four categories of individual investors need to pay a securities capital gains tax: people who hold more than 1 percent of the shares of a company, people whose annual income excluding income derived from securities transactions exceeds NT$3 million, people who sell shares annually valued at more than NT$1 billion, and people who live in the country less than 183 days a year.
The "index level" refers to the Taiex stock exchange index exceeding 8,500. Hahaha. In the last 120 months, that has happened for precisely 18 months, according to the civic groups cited in the Taipei Times.

But let's look at this. First, the new law really takes effect in 2017 -- 2016 is a Presidential election year, so obviously the year is a deliberate choice.

Who is taxed? Well, not many people. People with more than a 1% share of a company -- does this category cover only individuals, or does it include institutional investors?

I love the third category -- everyone who makes money from securities income provided their non-securities income EXCEEDS $3 million NT, or roughly $90,000 US. This appears to exclude precisely that category of parasites that I've discussed in the past -- wealthy individuals whose sole income is derived from securities trading and thus, have no paper income. In other words, under this regime, if you can manage to live your life solely by securities, you will pay no taxes. At least, that's the way it looks to me. Under this regime, this category pays no taxes until its transactions reach the NT$1 billion mark, or roughly US $30 million. It will not be difficult for such individuals to set up shell companies or trade through relatives so that they can trade without violating this rule; Taiwanese are past masters at evading tax laws in this manner. Under the "rich people" definition that operates until 2017, the NT$3 million exclusion is an NT$5 million exclusion.....

The final category of 183 day people is loud and clear.

As the staunchly pro-KMT China Post put it in an editorial the other day, Christina Liu's failure dooms any genuine stock gains tax. Not much more to say than that. It is hard to avoid the conclusion that Ma and his party never meant for a real reform to take place....

The Taipei Times editorialized similarly:
First, Liu’s resignation opens a new chapter in the crisis facing the Ma administration as the president struggles to recover from record-low approval ratings. The controversial tax proposal that has sparked strong opposition from the business sector and legislators across party lines since late March, culminating in Liu’s resignation, highlights the Ma administration’s long-standing weaknesses in decisionmaking and crisis management.
Quite true. But let me suggest that the appearance of bumbling was possibly deliberate, part of the smokescreen, with Minister Liu the sacrifice (We're so inept, that capital gains tax just slipped through our fingers. Sorry!). The TT editorial also observed that the widening wealth gap and debt problems will hinder national development and cause social problems. The wealth gap and debt issues are really two sides of the same coin: a large slice of wealth in Taiwan goes untaxed, creating a revenue gap. Nor does it look like it will ever be taxed.

WSJ's China RealTime column ran a piece by Jenny Hsu on Ma's declining popularity....
According to various polls, Mr. Ma’s popularity has fallen to 15-35%, a steep drop from his 51% victory in January’s election.

“With the 2014 local elections and the 2016 combined legislative and presidential elections down the pipeline, KMT lawmakers are trying to disassociate themselves from the power center, making Mr. Ma a lame duck president much sooner than expected,” said Joseph Wu, a political science professor at National Chengchi University.
Jonathon Manthorpe has a comprehensive review with much history of Ma and what all this might mean for Taiwan's democracy. Unfortunately he cites mostly pro-Green voices. Although it's certainly way cool that Peng Ming-min was important for the development of international aviation law.

While it makes great news to watch Ma's popularity plummet, it doesn't mean much of anything. Ma also took a plunge after Morakot and remained low in popularity throughout his tenure. He won re-election however and more importantly, the KMT holds the legislature and won 3 of 5 municipal elections. The 2014 local elections are still two years away and the party remains wealthy and entrenched in the major institutions of society. This all may prove to be as transient as a rain squall on a summer day.

Let's not forget that however botched, the things the Administration has done were things that needed to be done. Fuel and electricity prices have to rise -- Taiwanese have been living in a bubble world thanks to heavy subsidies for fuel and electricity. The national health insurance system must be revised and fees raised. A capital gains tax is a necessity. Regrettably, the Ma Administration has failed to give the nation a meaningful capital gains tax. If the DPP wins the next Presidential election and takes the legislature, let's see if they do any better.
___________
Daily Links:
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums! Delenda est, baby.

Monday, March 12, 2012

Taiwan: Greece to Come?

Having fun in a pause between rainfalls. This is a crop; the original is here. I love capturing reflections in water bubbles...

After the election I argued in the Taipei Times that one of the hidden factors in the election of President Ma was the growing wealth divide in Taiwan....
During the 1990s, when then-president Lee Teng-hui (李登輝) was midwifing the birth of Taiwan’s democracy, he essentially made a grand bargain. In return for their silence in his struggle to fend off the Chinese Nationalist Party’s (KMT) regressive right wing and its last-ditch defense of the party-state, it was decided that those who had grown wealthy by suckling off the party-state teat would not have their wealth taxed away through a progressive tax system, particularly a tax on Taiwan’s most important investment, land. Subsequent administrations have also found it politic to keep this bargain.

.....

Such individuals might have concluded that, if Tsai had won Saturday’s election, there would have been a significant reduction in their wealth if a fairer tax system were implemented, especially the paper wealth generated by the Taipei property bubble. Since Ma can be trusted to make noise about fairness, but to do little concrete, he was their obvious choice.

The property bubble is doing more than distorting the economy; it is distorting the nation’s politics as well. Observers have often remarked on Taiwan’s unfinished transition to democracy, yet they have seldom overtly argued that a critical factor in this is the regressive tax system.

As social inequality continues to grow, expect this wealthy class and its class interests to be a silent, but powerful driver of KMT success.
A similar political deal helped impoverish Greece, Spain, and Portugal, while in the US, the transfer of the nation's wealth out of the hands of its producers and into the pockets of a tiny coterie of fantastically rich individuals is having the same negative effect on the public purse, the ability of the nation to invest in its future, and on its democracy.

Surprisingly, the pro-KMT China Times came out with an interesting piece this week on the untaxed wealthy in Taiwan and their distorting effect on the nation's finances.
台灣稅賦公平嗎?一般民眾薪資所得每分錢都得乖乖繳稅,支撐了整個台灣主要綜所稅的來源,但炒房、炒股族卻可享有龐大「租稅優惠」,這部分「遺漏」的資本利得稅,估計每年大概在一千一百到一千五百億之間。

Is Taiwan's tax system fair? Every penny of the general public's wages are obediently taxed to support the whole of Taiwan's main resource of comprehensive income tax, while families with real estate and stocks enjoy huge tax incentives. The capital gains tax on this part of the "missing" taxes has an estimated value of NT$1.1 trillion to $1.5 trillion.
After the article details some of the taxes that have gone missing and their effects, it notes....
換句話說,不動產炒作者與股巿炒手至少年享逾千億元的「租稅優惠」!台北大學財政系教授蘇建榮就指出,依據國際貨幣基金會(IMF)提供資料顯示,當前台灣財政問題核心在於長期的「結構性財政赤字」,形成的原因除了政府支出結構外,主要是「長期的減稅制度」所造成。

In other words, real estate and stock market speculators enjoy tax breaks worth at least NT$1 trillion! Su Jianrong of the National Taipei University Department of Finance pointed out that International Money Fund (IMF) data show that the core of Taiwan's financial problems is the long-term structural deficit. In addition to the expenditure structure of the government, the main reason for the formation of the long-term structural deficit is long-term tax reduction.
...concluding:
長期的減稅制度不僅造成政府財政虛弱,入不敷出,更重要的是政府許多重要的政務,包括提高社會福利、補助弱勢民眾、加強教育投資等,都沒有能力再作擴充。最後必然造成國家與民眾受害。

This long-term tax system not only causes weak government finances, meaning that the nation is living beyond its means, but many important agendas of the government, including improving social welfare, subsidies to vulnerable populations, and increasing investment in education, cannot be expanded. In the end, it will inevitably lead to the victimization of both the nation and its people.
As long as the the government remains KMT, it is highly unlikely this will be fixed. This is a far more ominous issue with far greater ramifications for the future than the level of ractopamine in US beef -- which points to one of the important functions of the constant churning of minor issues like beef: it keeps the public nicely distracted...

UPDATED: Summary of interview this week of Control Yuan President Wang Chien-hsien, who said the government should impose taxes on stocks and real estate. Wang was forced to step down in 1992 when he attempted to levy a tax on real estate transaction based on the market price.
During an interview with the Taipei-based China Times, Control Yuan President Wang Chien-hsien (王建煊) indicted that in order to seek tax fairness and justice, the government should levy a capital gains tax on stock and real estate sales. In particular, he noted, the land value increment tax should be levied “based on market prices” on high-value real estate transactions as well as transactions of non-self-use residences. He went on to say that this would not require any Constitutional amendment, and the government would face less difficulty compared with imposing a new tax on securities exchange gains, so a capital gains tax on real-estate sales should be taken into consideration first. The increase in revenues from this tax could be used to subsidize first-time housing buyers, he noted.
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums! Delenda est, baby.

Friday, March 11, 2011

Luxury Tax Finalized

The proposed luxury tax was finalized this week, according to the Taipei Times:
“The purpose of the bill is to slow down the frequency of property sales and address public discontent with rising commodity prices [partly] driven by consumption of high-priced products,” Lee said.

Lee said the implementation of the tax on the sale of non-self-use properties would stabilize the market rather than deal a blow to the real estate industry, because only an estimated 20,000 property transactions would be subject to the tax.

The draft act stipulates that owners of residential units, commercial units or vacant lots owned for less than one year, would be taxed 15 percent of the selling price, or 10 percent if they had owned the property for more than one year but less than two.

Article 5 of the draft act includes 10 exemptions.

Among them are situations when the seller owns only one property that is not leased out for business purposes; when the property is sold to the government or ordered by authorities to be auctioned off; and when an owner sells a property owned for less than two years within one year of buying a new one.

Owners would also be exempt when they sell property that was inherited or given to them and when they are forced by banks to dispose of property used as collateral to secure a mortgage or pledge.

Lee said the draft act also entitled the Ministry of Finance to make exemptions in certain cases as long as the transactions are made in accordance with the principles of “rationality, normality and non-voluntary transfer.”
It isn't difficult to imagine how exemptions could be obtained quite easily: I gift my gazillion dollar property to my son, who promptly sells it and transfers the funds back to me. Intrafamily transactions are common ways to avoid regulations in Taiwan. Law-evading tricks are the meat and milk of the real estate market, as I blogged on a few months ago. The Taipei Times had a nifty commentary the other day that outlined how the government makes it easy for developers and real estate traders to evade taxation:

As far as dealing with high real-estate prices is concerned, the proposed “luxury tax” is no more than a stopgap measure. The key problem behind the unsound market and soaring real-estate prices is that the tax base is not determined according to market prices.

The tax base for land value increment tax is the rise in the price of land based on the current value of land as announced once a year by the government.

The deed tax, house tax and taxes levied on income from property transactions are all based on the assessed current prices of housing.

Land value tax is based on the announced price of land.

None of these are market prices.

The process of setting these prices tends to be divorced from reality and influenced by artificial adjustments. They are called “current prices,” but they are quite far removed from the market prices.

In addition, the fact that these price announcements are made at fixed intervals results in the strange phenomenon of short-term transactions not being subject to land value increment tax. The costs involved in real-estate speculation are therefore very low, so of course house prices keep going up.

Read the whole commentary; the excerpt only gives a taste. The luxury tax is no more than a nuisance, as the Taipei Times reported the other day. Despite the proposed tax developers are proposing a record volume of development projects this year.
Housing Monthly said the total value of new housing projects put forward in the so-called “golden period” for property deals reached NT$261.6 billion, about NT$39.6 billion more than the 2008 figure for the same period, even though the Cabinet approved a “luxury tax” draft bill earlier in the day meant to curb speculative real estate transactions.
It is clear from data like this that complaints from realtors that the new tax would depress the market are, at best, overwrought.

The real purpose of the bill is right out there in the first paragraph: to address public discontent. It is entirely cosmetic, and will probably have little effect on the housing market in Taipei. Famed Japanese economist Kenichi Ohmae pointed out the external wild card that is pressurizing the real estate market here in Taiwan:
However, the problem soaring land prices in Asia is contagious, Ohmae argued. "China, Hong Kong and Macau have been infected. The price craze is just like influenza," he told Taiwan media at a press conference on the sidelines of the forum.
The luxury goods makers and agents here in Taiwan stated that the tax would not affect their business since the wealthy can afford to pay a little more for quality.

Once again, cosmetics where plastic surgery is necessary.
__________________
Daily Links
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums! Delenda est, baby.

Saturday, July 03, 2010

Chen Shui-bian Died for Your Sins: Land, Taxes, and Inequality in Taiwan

And Aaron shall lay both his hands upon the head of the live goat, and confess over him all the iniquities of the children of Israel, and all their transgressions in all their sins, putting them upon the head of the goat, and shall send him away by the hand of a fit man into the wilderness.

Outsiders know Taiwan primarily through its computer industry, but few understand that the local political economy runs on land speculation and development. Commonwealth magazine recently had a great issue that explored some of the links between inequality, land development, taxation, and income in Taiwan. In an article discussing land speculation, it described why government land is auctioned and then developers sit on vacant lots for long periods, observing:
Taiwan's convoluted property tax system also keeps the cost of holding vacant lots quite cheap.

Land in Taiwan has four different values. Aside from the actual market price, there is the "publicly announced land value," which is adjusted once every three years, the "reported current land value," which is the value reported by landowners used to calculate the land tax and can be up to 20 percent higher or lower than the publicly announced land value, and finally the "assessed present land value" on which land value increment taxes (similar to capital gains taxes) are based.

Taiwan's houses also have two prices -- the actual market price and a "standard unit price for housing construction" set by the tax revenue offices of each local government for residential units under their jurisdiction. This publicly assessed price has not been adjusted for 27 years. Legislator Lai Shyh-bao estimates that the current "standard unit price" is roughly only one-fifth of the actual market value.

The lack of transparency in real estate transactions has also contributed to strange practices. Jwo explains that many property transactions in Taiwan involve three contracts. There is a "public contract," drawn up to show government tax offices, a "private contract," which lists the actual terms of the deal, and a "fake contract," to use to apply for a mortgage.

Why are local governments so impoverished in Taiwan? One reason is the 18% interest on government employee retirement accounts, as I have noted before. But another is the low assessed values of property in Taiwan. These cannot be changed because political campaigns in Taiwan are, pound for pound, some of the world's most expensive. The article observes:

An employee of a prominent company, who is active in government-private sector associations, says that in today's political environment, only the profits on land speculation are sufficient to support an elected official. "Any election campaign now requires at least NT$100 million. Politicians won't have enough if they only rely on cuts from public works projects," the source asserts.

Because of these complex symbiotic ties between politicians and the business community, local governments never adjust the standards for the "publicly assessed land value," "assessed present value," or the "housing assessment value," all of which they have the authority to change without amending any laws at all. NTU's Hua vividly recalls the reaction he got when he suggested to a county chief that he increase the publicly assessed values of land and houses to ease the county government's financial woes.

"He shook his head vigorously and said to me, ‘You're an academic who doesn't have to deal with reality. I still have an election ahead. No way. No way.'"

Because local politicians are deeply involved factions that are up to their ears in The System of land speculation and development that underpins Taiwan's local political economy, it cannot be changed. Perhaps when Chinese developers start to muscle in on local land development, Taiwan's local faction politicians will fight for raised taxes as a defensive measure. Yet the effort that the KMT has spent over years in preventing factions from operating at the national level and keeping them confined to their local areas may mean that Taiwan's localities lack the institutional frameworks and skills necessary to carry out national-level politics of this nature.

The article notes that among the regions of Taiwan, in Taipei the tax on land is relatively closer to the actual value...
Chang-I Hua, an adjunct professor at National Taiwan University's Institute of Building and Planning, argues that the problem with Taiwan's land tax system is not low tax rates but rather the tax base. Of all local governments, Taipei City's present assessed values most closely approximate actual market prices but are still about 30 percent below market. The publicly announced land value is 60 percent below market value. Consequently, while land and housing tax rates may seem high, homeowners' tax burdens are only about one-tenth that found in the United States, according to Professor Hua.
One reason Taipei lives high on the hog is that the local government can actually extract something resembling meaningful taxes, in addition to its greater share of the national budget. Out in the less developed areas, not even that is possible. This disparity in institutional and financial power and resources between north and south is an inequality that seldom makes the news, but is one of the most important drivers of the island's political life.

Perhaps the new municipalities of Taichung, Kaohsiung, Tainan, and The City Formerly Known As Taipei County, with the greater power of their mayors -- recall that in the ROC system a municipality is the equalivalent of a province -- may find the wherewithal to bring land taxes up to more rational levels.That would be progress.

Progress, Frank Herbert once wrote, is a concept by which the terrors of the future can be kept at bay.

There is a National Land Planning Act, evolving from laws proposed and drafted in the 1990s, but it has never been made into law due to opposition from developers via the politicians in their pocket. A bill must pass three readings to become law; the Act had its first reading in 2004, nearly a decade later. Several laws have been passed then that have aided land developers, including the 1999 Agricultural Development Act, which allowed developers to annex and build residences on previously off-limits agricultural land. That act is chiefly responsible for the mushrooming of hideous cookie-cutter housing developments all over the island. Now in draft is another law that essentially allows anyone to open their own industrial district and do whatever they like in it, as one Taipei Times commentary interpreted the legislation a couple of months ago.

The absurdly low taxes on land are just half of the problem; the other half is that wealth in Taiwan is not taxed. The underlying tax inequities are a key driver of the island's rising income inequality. Says Commonwealth:

The salaries and wages earned by Taiwan's 9 million workers account for 72 percent of the reported income on which individual income taxes are paid in Taiwan (Table 1), a far higher ratio than the 56 percent in the United States and the 49 percent average across wealthy OECD (Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development) countries.

In Taiwan, there are 7.54 million households, but only 5.38 million, or 71.3 percent, pay taxes. "Many of those that don't pay taxes are actually high-income earners. These people only pay NT$600 a month in health insurance premiums, and in the future, when premiums are calculated based on household income, this one-third that don't pay taxes may not have to pay health insurance premiums," a former financial official in the central government says.

.......

"Taiwan's truly wealthy people are not the ones you see in public. Rather, they are the quietly anonymous individuals who live in exclusive properties like The Palace," says a former financial official. In an unprecedented move a few years ago, the Ministry of Finance released figures on how much tax Taiwan's richest people paid in 2005, providing a glimpse into the severity of the imbalance. Out of Taiwan's 40 wealthiest people, eight paid no taxes five years ago and 17 paid only 1 percent of their income.

"The taxes that many people pay are totally disproportionate to their incomes," says economist Ma Kai. Many households' accumulation of wealth relies on gains from property and stock transactions, the vast majority of which go untaxed. Even if the wealthy have taxable income, there are many legal or "gray area" tax shelters at their disposal to help them reduce their tax liability, Ma explains.

According to the 2009 IMD World Competitiveness Yearbook, corporate income taxes paid by Taiwan's enterprises are only 3 percent of GDP, lower than the ratio in the other Asian Dragons (South Korea, Sinpapore and Hong Kong), China, Japan and the United States. Reported corporate pre-tax earnings, which account for only 18 percent of all taxable income reported in Taiwan, amount to barely 20 percent of the business income listed in Taiwan's national income statistics. In other words, at least 70 percent of Taiwan's taxable corporate income has fallen through the tax system's cracks.

Of course, it hasn't "fallen through the cracks." Rather, the system is designed so that it has many cracks for wealth to fall through. In fact, as the article notes, the more money a company makes, the less tax it pays...

Commonwealth also notes that the Ma Administration has taken the lead in George Bush style tax cuts.....

Over the past two years, the administration of President Ma Ying-jeou has rolled out a number of tax breaks for companies and the wealthy. Only recently, to compensate big businesses for the loss of R&D and other tax breaks when the "Statute for Upgrading Industries" expired at the end of 2009, the government decided to lower the corporate income tax rate from 25 percent to 20 percent. But not wanting to be underbid when the opposition Democratic Progressive Party pushed a 17.5 percent tax rate, the government slashed the proposed rate even further to 17 percent as part of the new Statute for Industrial Innovation passed April 16. The bill also retained tax credits for R&D expenditures by large corporations and subsidies for small- and medium-sized enterprises to hire workers, even though the latter had nothing to do with innovation.

This so-called "17 plus 1 plus 1" package became the biggest tax cut measure in the history of the Republic of China. It was passed at a time when the country's finances are in their worst shape in the past eight years with the budget surplus of NT$40 billion in 2007 being transformed into a deficit of NT$500 billion.
The Commonwealth piece on the incredibly unequal tax systems describes a representative investor who makes over a million NT a year on investments but pays no taxes because it is all capital gains income. His daughter even applied for financial aid at school, the article says. It then links land taxes, income taxes, and inequality:
Taiwan's government has been unable to institute a capital gains tax on stock or real estate income because of a lack of transparent information and fears of rattling the markets. In the property market, those fears have left the government unwilling to replace publicly assessed present values (on which "land value increment" taxes are currently calculated) with actual market prices, which would boost capital gains tax revenues dramatically.

"Other countries have all done it. Can the government tell us why only Taiwan can't get it done?" Chien asks.

"If you say it's hard to get accurate information on real estate, I would agree. But all stock transactions are completely computerized. To say it's hard to get information is simply ludicrous. The real reason is the fear that the stock market will collapse," says stock brokerage worker Ruan Cheng-yuan.

"Taiwan is the only country in the world that uses an assessed present value to calculate housing and land taxes," says the economist Ma Kai. The publicly assessed land and house value usually seriously understates actual market values. "The Palace's apartments are publicly valued at only NT$3 million to NT$4 million," Ma says of the luxury property that reportedly has sold its units for up to NT$ 70 million.

Far from spurring innovation and upgrading by companies, low taxes mean that the government lacks the resources to stimulate upgrades of the educational and research systems, as well as supply the amenities that attract hi-tech businesses. It also means that much of the island's wealth is tied up in speculation in land and stocks rather than chasing investment in innovative new industries. Finally, the lack of a capital gains tax explains why so many locals so obsessively play the stock market and so obsessively buy land -- because if they win, they can live tax-free. In Taiwan, basically only individuals with salaries from registered companies pay taxes.

Why the title of this post? Rene Girard, the brilliant French thinker, argued in Violence and the Sacred that when social chaos threatens, societies resolve the problem of looming disorder by arbitrarily selecting an individual for sacrifice who is portrayed as both the cause of the problem and the actor through which it can be relieved: a scapegoat. Consider the large, and largely invisible, class of non-taxpayers described above, and consider Chen Shui-bian. It should be obvious by now that one of the most important social functions of the whole Chen Shui-bian affair with its lurid and loudly indignant emphasis on the vast sums passing through his family's accounts, was to provide a scapegoat onto which the sins of the island's quietly untaxed wealthy could be noisily unloaded and then sent into the political wilderness to die, silenced and alone.
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!