Saturday, November 22, 2008

Freedom House Calls for Inquiry into Clashes

Freedom House had some tough words to say on behalf of Taiwan this week (emphasis mine):

"A public investigation of the violence—which involved both sides—will send a critical message that the new government of President Ma Ying-jeou is interested in upholding the democratic values of transparency and accountability," said Jennifer Windsor, Freedom House executive director. "The inquiry should examine evidence on both sides and recommend any needed reforms to police practices and the legal framework governing demonstrations."

Hundreds of university students are currently staging a sit-in in Taipei's Freedom Square and several other cities to protest the government's handling of the incident. During Chen’s visit, police reportedly used heavy-handed tactics—including physical assault, arbitrary detention and destruction of property—to prevent Chen from seeing symbols of Taiwanese or Tibetan independence, as well as broader demonstrations against the Chinese regime. Demonstrators also employed violence against police, throwing rocks and petrol bombs outside Chen's hotel on November 6.

The clashes reveal a need for police to undergo crowd control training that adheres to the standards used in other democracies. Likewise, demonstrators and political advocacy groups must recommit themselves to orderly protests that avoid violence under any circumstances.

The inquiry commission should examine controversial passages in Taiwan's Assembly and Parade Law, such as restrictions on where people are allowed to demonstrate, and determine whether they need to be liberalized to protect citizens' rights to freedom of expression and assembly. The commission should also investigate claims that police are selectively enforcing the law.

The visit by Chen, the most senior Chinese official to visit Taiwan since it split from China in 1949, and the recent arrests of several opposition party figures are raising concerns that that President Ma and his Kuomintang Party may rollback democratic freedoms.

They hit on everything -- police behavior, student protests, general fears about democracy. Nice work, guys.

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Daily Links, Nov 20, 2008


So what's being sprayed across the blogs out there?
  • Chinese Consumer Connection, Clyde Warden's podcasts on marketing in local culture, with a certain pudgy, balding blogger on marketing wine in Taiwan, and with Robert Reynolds holding forth in an excellent podcast on centralization vs deregulation in the educational system and elsewhere in local society.

  • Interview with Taiwanese-American actor Kevin Yu.

  • Fili on hong kong myths.

  • The China Beat on the Wild Strawberries.

  • The Mouse-Eared Kiwi does SYS.

  • Patrick on an old Tainan treat.

  • The Foreigner on the Obama Administration.

  • Old Taiwan photos from LIFE.

  • Latin American blog looks at Taiwan's struggle to maintain its "allies" in the Americas.

  • A-gu argues Ma does not want to sell out Taiwan to China, but will unintentionally.

  • D. Corey confronts Chinese students in America bent on stamping out pro-Taiwan statements.

  • Robert long and eloquent on the health care system here and the barbarism that is the US system.

  • Jerome on Annette Lu's statement on the recent detentions.

  • Stephanie at Tea Masters blogs on Da Yu Ling Oolong.

  • Mark goes to the same baseball game I did.

  • David on human rights here.

  • The Wild East: Revolutionary Agriculture right outside Taipei.

  • Everything of Niao-sung, photos of a small town in southern Taiwan, in English and in Chinese. A labor of love.

  • Kelake on micro-blogs.

  • The China Beat on the growing mess in China. Will nationalism + depression = war?

  • MEDIA: A very garbled view of Taiwan's history from Romania. An essay from a mainlander who discovers she is a global citizen in one of China's representative offices in the US. China says US is "needling" China with arms sales to Taiwan. US moves 60% of sub fleet to Pacific to offset China's growing threat. Who are the other 40% aimed at? And isn't China our benevolent strategic partner? An interview with the new Taiwan representative to Japan. Way cool: Taiwan, Lockheed in OTEC project in Hawaii. 29 Taiwanese fishermen missing after burnt out boat found off NZ. Adult children of foreigners to be able to stay in Taiwan. Because Taipei consumes a wildly disproportionate share of the nation's budget, other places are combining together to become "special municipalities" or "special regions" like Taipei. Now Kaohsiung is thinking about it. Giant economic stimulus on the way. Taiwan economy contracts in the 3rd quarter. Chen Shui-bian hospitalized. Call President stupid, get 30 days off.

    EVENTS: Don't forget, Tuesday Heritage hosts Dr. Shieh to talk about his experiences in an apparent political prosecution.

    Obama's New Policy Team: Sutphen

    Obama's new White House Deputy Chief of Staff is Mona Sutphen, who works for Stonebridge International, the big consulting firm that does a rousing business with China. Here is an article she co-wrote from a year ago in the LA Times. It gives a good idea of how the US foreign policy establishment views China, and probably the major premises of an Obama foreign policy. An excerpt:

    Embrace China
    The burgeoning powerhouse often is painted as a threat to the U.S. It should be viewed more as a partner.

    By Nina Hachigian and Mona Sutphen
    December 22, 2007

    .....

    John Q. Public has it more right than the politicos. America’s relationship with China is not zero-sum. Like other world powers – India, Russia, Japan and the European Union – China is more partner than threat. Many of our security interests overlap.

    China actually helps us protect our shores from radiological terrorist attacks by allowing the U.S. to station inspectors in the ports of Hong Kong, Shanghai and Shenzhen, the key departure points for more than 3 million shipping containers headed to the West Coast each year. Like it or not, we also rely on China – ground zero for avian influenza and other potential pandemics – to spot and contain outbreaks. Without Beijing’s deep involvement and cooperation, the U.S. will never persuade North Korea to dismantle its nuclear weapons program. Together, the U.S. and China represent both the problem and the solution to the global climate crisis.

    As it gains influence, China no doubt will continue to give solace to America’s detractors, such as Hugo Chavez, and to derail U.S. plans that do not further its interests, as in the case of U.N. sanctions against Iran. But China is not a direct military threat, nor could it be for decades to come. Moreover, because China and the U.S. posses nuclear weapons, mutual deterrence will discourage a clash, as it did during the Cold War. Even with the status of Taiwan, which remains the most dangerous flash point, there is ample room for peaceful outcomes. Direct confrontation between the U.S. and China could certainly occur – it would not be the first time a war made no sense – but what a disaster that would be for the world economy and global stability.

    Even on the economic front, where the news is full of reports of how China manipulates its currency, buys our companies and takes our jobs, the big picture is positive. Overall, its economic growth buoys our own. Trade with China has been responsible for measurable if modest growth in our GDP. Morgan Stanley estimates that China’s cheap exports have extended the paychecks of low-income Americans to the tune of $600 billion over 10 years.

    Many of the criticisms don’t really hold up. All of foreign outsourcing is only responsible for about 2% of the jobs lost in the U.S. If the U.S. is to avert recession, it will be in part because of the dynamism of economies like China’s – and because the Chinese are willing to invest in American companies.

    Finally, China is not an ideological competitor. It doesn’t have a coherent ideology to export even if it wanted to, beyond, perhaps, “Show me the money.” Beijing trades with despicable regimes, but it certainly isn’t alone in that regard. We rightly deplore how China represses its citizens, and the U.S. should call Beijing to task forcefully, but we have to acknowledge that our leverage to influence its internal political evolution is very limited.

    We cannot rule out that China will become a hostile aggressor one day, and our military must stay prepared for that distant threat. For now, though, the challenge is this: How can we channel China’s energy into solving the raft of pressing global problems? How can we get Beijing to pay for the privilege of having a seat at the big power table?

    China’s growth will cause some Americans to lose their jobs or get paid less. But it is America’s job to ensure that our working class is equipped to deal with these disruptions – not China’s. And it is America’s job to address the problems that hamper our nation’s ability to thrive in a world with multiple strong powers: our broken education system, expensive and inadequate healthcare, budget deficit, crumbling infrastructure and an addiction to oil. All these are problems we have to solve ourselves.

    In an election year, it is always tempting for politicians to point the finger at another country. But American voters shouldn’t buy it. We should stay focused on the country we have the power to change.
    China is our partner -- like Japan and the European Union! Wowweee!

    It is not our ideological competitor because it has no ideology to export, claims Sutphen. Which misses the point that China, and our willingness to do business with it while ignoring its odious authoritarianism, simply legitimates other political regimes which are open for business as authoritarian governments. China floating by itself in space somewhere may not have an exportable political ideology, but when we let it into the international system, that most certainly provides support for a certain political ideology -- one which constantly undermines our authority as a beacon of democracy. If Obama intends to restore our moral authority in the world, taking a strong position on human rights in China would be a good start. But we all know that nothing of the sort will happen during the Obama administration, just as it didn't during any of the six previous administrations.

    MEDIA: Note the LA Times blurb on them:
    Nina Hachigian is a director for California at the Center for American Progress. Mona Sutphen is a managing director at the business consulting firm Stonebridge International. They co-wrote the forthcoming book “The Next American Century: How the U.S. Can Thrive as Other Powers Rise.”
    The LA Times manages to mention that Sutphen works for Stonebridge without mentioning that its major business focus is.....China. Sutphen is one of many Obama Asia staffers who work for that firm.

    Wednesday, November 19, 2008

    Vouching toward Bedlam

    The US Postal Service annexes Taiwan to China. Was there a change in policy I missed?

    The voucher plan details are slowly emerging, showing how the government plans to shower cash all over Taiwan....

    Under the plan, by Lunar New Year on Jan. 24 each citizen can receive vouchers worth a total of NT$3,600 from his or her household registration office by showing documents that prove citizenship.

    The expiration date of the vouchers will be Dec. 31 next year, while the face amount of each voucher note has yet to be determined.

    Liu said that the program did not exclude the wealthy because it is designed to “stimulate more consumption to get the economy going” and “not to provide social assistance.”

    “Wealthy people or people who are not in need of the vouchers can get a tax break by donating the vouchers to charities,” Liu said.

    The government expected to see an increase of 0.64 percent in next year’s GDP based on the assumption that all the vouchers are used to purchase goods and services and are not converted to cash and deposited in bank accounts.

    We taxpayers but non-citizens cannot get one. Noting that the voucher plan has to get around laws that sensibly limit public debt to capital expenditures -- in other words, debt that creates useful stuff. One legislator noted:

    The KMT administration has already allocated NT$300 billion to source its 12 major construction projects in debt financing, and it proposed an NT$82.9 billion budget for the coupon plan, so the government will have around NT$400 billion in debt financing only six months in office, Tsai said.

    A number of groups, including the DPP, have argued that a cash gift or tax credit might be better idea. The vouchers are only usable at legally registered businesses, so many small businesses will be left in the cold. The Taipei Times pointed out:

    The KMT marketed Vice President Vincent Siew (蕭萬長) as an economic wunderkind when he and President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) ran for office. With Taiwan facing a serious global and domestic economic challenge, how ironic it is that tough times should feature yesterday’s men sprouting confused policies.

    The other irony is that the KMT legislative caucus recently denied the Democratic Progressive Party caucus a tax cut, saying that there wasn’t enough money. Now it is saying that there is enough money — in the form of mounting debt for our children — and all this during a global financial earthquake.
    Isn't it good to know "the adults are in charge"? And why are we taking on debt to spark the economy -- isn't our lurch toward China supposed to result in a rain of Chinese investment to stimulate growth? Guess the Chinese tourists are all flying Amelia Earhart Airlines.... If the KMT Administration were a fish, it would be flounder.

    Even more confusing are the rules. My wife and I read with vast amusement one set of explanations from a media outlet that said you couldn't sell them (but you could give them away) while another media outlet said that there would be no problem selling them through internet auction. Could criminals use them? The rabidly Blue United Daily News posed this question as "Could Chen Shui-bian use them? -- Yes." So much for journalistic detachment.

    If a stimulus is desired, a much greater effect could be had simply by spending the quatloos on infrastructure. Effects vary, but at the end of the day, infrastructure spending leaves the economy with useful things like roads, bridges, and ports that continue to generate economic activity years into the future. The voucher plan? Our kids will be paying the interest on it, years into the future.

    UPDATE: Enjoy this fellow with eight wives and 32 kids, getting $150K worth of vouchers.

    Strawberry Fils Forever

    The Wild Strawberries student movement, still ongoing, has three demands -- an apology from President Ma, resignations of the police and security chiefs, and amending of the Assembly and Parade Law. The first two are highly unlikely to occur, but the third was a possibility. A few days ago the KMT had a caucus which they billed as an "open forum" at which some "NGOs" appeared...
    Although they agreed that the pre-approval system has its defects and should be replaced with a pre-notice system, many KMT lawmakers were still worried the change could bring social chaos.

    “The pre-approval system could be changed to the pre-notice system, but there should still be some kind of application and check process,” KMT Legislator Wu Ching-chih (吳清池) told the public hearing. “For the sake of social stability, adequate restrictions should still be implemented, otherwise [demonstrations] may lead to anarchic situations. It’s very dangerous.”

    The chairwoman of the Taipei International Cultural Exchange Association for Professional Women, Ling Yu-ying (凌瑜英), expressed strong opposition to amending the Assembly and Parade Law.
    With "social opinions" like this, you can imagine the results, reported by the Wild Strawberries in their press release of Nov 18:
    The Executive Yuan has raised the issue of revisions to the Assembly and Parade Law recently. However, the new version adopts a “compulsory notification system” whose content preserves restrictions including “assembling without notification is illegal”, “establishing forbidden areas”, “police have the right to alter the time, place, and form of the parade”, “the police can command dissolution of the parade without explicit standards”, and “the criminal and administrative sanctions relating to assembly”. Namely, the revision contains no practical improvements, only the change of name from “permission” to “notification”.
    I am reminded of the period right after martial law was lifted, when the KMT passed a new national security law that was martial law in all but name. Hopefully the DPP and concerned KMT lawmakers can move to make meaningful revisions to the law.

    Meanwhile the Strawberries, numbers dwindling, are planning to build a "strawberry tower." I stopped by the NCKU protests on Monday and was told that parents are putting lots of pressure on the students in the university not to participate. "Concerned parents" are also bombarding the counseling center with demands that the counselors do something about the "mentally ill "students demonstrating. I do know a few students whose parents encouraged them to get out and do something. Public support has been overwhelming, with many stopping by to leave donations of food and equipment. The students have become a cause of "chaos" and like any cause of distortion in the social order, the pressure gradient to conform becomes steeper as time passes. One of the many bizarre bits of fallout from the definition of order in Chinese society is that peaceful student demonstrators are a cause of "social disorder", but mad drivers and construction vehicles blocking streets are of no concern...

    Tuesday, November 18, 2008

    On the Blogs today...

    A couple of things on blogs I'd like to point to today. First, Taoyuan Nights, has an analysis of the idiotic voucher plan in Let’s hand out free money, and other stupid ideas. I was going to blog on this, but his is so much better. Don't miss his distinction between taxpayers and voters. All I can say is that thank heaven our financial system is being run by elite experts with years of training at the best universities in the world, otherwise we'd probably be having a global financial crisis or something.

    Meanwhile, Melinda Liu on the Newsweek blog China Calling has an excellent rundown of the Chen Yunlin protests and everyone's fear of where we might be heading with the recent spate of arrests. A taste:

    These events have left a society long used to fragmentation - where most academics, analysts and media organisations are on one side or the other of the political divide – still reeling at the increase in political tension under President Ma: “Chen Shui-bian was a very divisive figure,” says Frank Muyard of the French Centre for Research on Contemporary China. “People hoped Ma would be more conciliatory – they saw him as a gentle, well-educated, nice person who would help Taiwan come together and do something for reconciliation. But he hasn’t done that. Now many people see him as partisan, too eager to please China – they don’t trust him to defend Taiwan’s sovereignty.”

    For the mainland government, which has reported the opening of cross-strait links with great fanfare as a ‘win-win’ situation for both sides, there’s a clear degree of satisfaction in seeing Chen Shui-bian under arrest. Beijing despised him for his background in Taiwan’s pro-independence movement of the 1970s and 80s. “Chen Shui-bian in handcuffs” was the banner headline in the popular nationalist tabloid newspaper the Global Times on Wednesday. And for months China’s state-run media has revelled in reporting every detail of the various allegations of corruption against Mr Chen, his wife and associates (in marked contrast to the minimal amount of detail it gave in the corruption case of another Chen, former Communist Party Secretary of Shanghai Chen Liangyu, who was jailed for eighteen years in April.)

    Ma Ying-jeou’s popularity with China’s leaders, on the other hand, is clearly at an all-time high: as well as agreeing to direct links and the One China principle, he has also relaxed restrictions which prevented Taiwanese companies from investing more than 40% of their assets in the mainland, further boosting economic ties. Yet recent events suggest his actions may also risk provoking a deeper anti-mainland backlash, at the very moment when physical links between the two sides of the Taiwan Straits have become closer than ever.

    Hopefully we'll have a formal article from Newsweek on these issues.


    Monday, November 17, 2008

    Richard Bush on Obama Policy

    The CNA carried an account of Richard Bush's speech at a gathering of the Taiwanese American Association in Washington DC. Bush, a longtime Taiwan specialist with the US government whose work on Taiwan both academically and policywise has generally been excellent, is likely to have a strong say in Taiwan policy under Obama, and may end up with a position at AIT at some point. The CNA reported:
    An American expert familiar with Taiwan affairs said Sunday that he believes the incoming U.S. government led by President-elect Barack Obama will continue policies aimed at pushing for closer relations between the United States and Taiwan.

    Richard Bush, senior fellow and director of the Center for Northeast Asian Policy Studies at the Brookings Institution, as well as a former chairman of the American Institute in Taiwan, made the remarks at a gathering of the Taiwanese American Association in Washington, D.C.

    Bush, who was also one of Obama's election campaign staff in charge of diplomatic policies, was honored at the event with an award for his distinguished contributions to U.S.-Taiwan affairs over the past several decades.

    In May, Bush attended the inauguration in Taipei for Republic of China President Ma Ying-jeou as a member of the U.S. government delegation and he is widely regarded as a likely point man in handling cross-Taiwan Strait affairs in the Obama administration.
    This is pretty much boilerplate -- the Obama Administration foreign policy is going to look a lot like previous American foreign policies on Taiwan. I don't know anyone educated who thinks an Obama Administration is going to be good for Taiwan, but at least it isn't going to be a shipwreck. Bush said that the Taiwan-US relationship is a two-way street, and Taiwan needs to take US priorities into account, a dig at the Chen Administration's foreign policy. Bush did say, however, that the Obama Administration is committed to fostering good relations with Taiwan.

    The problem is in this paragraph:

    Bush urged Taiwan to maintain an opposition party that is efficient in monitoring the administration, describing such a party as a crucial element in the maintenance of a democratic system.

    If our foreign policy leadership really believes that a functional opposition is important, then why did they go to so much effort to attack the DPP during the campaign on the referendum, which not only was not going to past, but would have no effect if it did? Dozens of George Bush Administration officials spoke out on that, including Secretary of State Rice. Nor can Richard Bush and the Obama team avoid the mud on their face; they have written approvingly of this campaign.

    To put that stain on US diplomacy in perspective, let me remind the reader of this. For the better part of five years, the KMT-controlled legislature blocked the special budget for the arms purchase. While the DPP was certainly not blameless, the KMT was primary obstacle to the passage of the arms bill. Sure, US officials came over a couple of times, but even when Ma Ying-jeou demonstrated his devotion to US interests by promising to pass it but then doing nothing, US officialdom maintained silence. There was criticism of "Taiwan" on the issue, but rarely did anyone point to the KMT as the source of the problem.

    In other words, when the DPP proffered a pointless referendum that affected nothing and could never pass, even the US Secretary of State came out to serve China's interests on that one, but when the KMT blocked billions in cash to US corporations and American workers for weapons Taiwan desperately needed, our foreign policy establishment gave a whine, a moue, and a little what-have-you shrug. Did the Hon. Condoleeza Rice ever speak out on the behavior of the KMT? Why, after four years of blogging on this stuff, am I still asking questions like that?

    The irony is even thicker because Bush said at the gathering Taiwan should build a sensible, credible deterrent on defense. Good thing US officials were all over that referendum instead of wasting time publicly criticizing the KMT at the Secretary of State level for not buying needed weapons!

    Simple fact: the US followed a policy that was intended to weaken the DPP -- a pro-US party, whatever you may say about their incompetence -- and lever the pro-Beijing Ma Ying-jeou into the Presidency. Now suddenly foreign policy experts lecture Taiwan on keeping the opposition strong.

    Probably should have thought of that sooner, eh?

    UPDATE: Obama announced that the Deputy White House Chief of Staff will be Monica Sutphen, who has some Asia in her background, and is in the firm of Stonebridge International along with several other Obama Asia people -- said firm being a consulting firm that does business with China.

    Sunday, November 16, 2008

    Sunday Media Round Up

    The Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) has its paper on the China stimulus online here. The media is also reporting government plans to stimulate the development of more industrial clusters, and to encourage consumer spending.

    The Wild Strawberries protest has entered its tenth day. The Taipei Times says that Ma has invited the students to negotiate with him. As if in response to the student protests, now going on in several cities, the Liberty Times said today that the jiao guan system, the posting of military officers to universities, is going to be revitalized and revived. In the martial law era these officers functioned as political officers who kept an eye on student political thinking. Today they do various administrative and counseling tasks, as well as teach the required courses in military science that all university students must take. Because this system is overwhelmingly and reliably pro-KMT and many within it worked to influence the students in that direction, the DPP had frozen the system and had been slowly reducing its influence and size. It is too early to say whether this represents a long-term move to politicize the university system, whose administrative apparatus already tends to be strongly pan-Blue, but it is not a hopeful sign. The media is also reporting that former Kaohsiung Mayor and DPP Presidential candidate Frank Hsieh is starting an alliance of lawyers to help future 'victims' of 'police abuse.'

    The Solomons Star has a great article on the state of our democracy here. It's like reading news from that alternate universe I sometimes visit. Cindy Sui has a more measured but definitely good article on the Chen Shui-bian detention for BBC.

    The net was abuzz with the report that Peru had referred to Regional Administrator Ma Ying-jeou as "President" in conjunction with the upcoming APEC meeting there. The Ma Administration hailed this as progress, though it refused to ask the representative from China to call him "President." KMT logic has it that whatever happens, whether they call Ma president or not, it is a sign that Ma's foreign policy is a success. In other news, Oceania is still at war with Eastasia.

    If you find the political news too depressing, there is always this poetic article extolling the scenic wonders of Taiwan from Andrew Jeffords in the Financial Times.

    Saturday, November 15, 2008

    The Impudence of Being Earnest


    Bystanders at the protest talk amongst themselves.

    Friday afternoon and evening I stopped by the Taichung protests to take some pictures and chat with the students and their audience.... the Taipei Times reported the other day that Hong Kong students are engaging in a sympathy demonstration for the Wild Strawberries in Taiwan. The paper also reports that the Taiwan students have repeatedly asked the government to explain the excessive security measures taken by the police and security forces during the Chen Yunlin visit in early November.


    A student holds up a sign for my camera.

    The Wild Strawberries have planned many activities for today. The schedule is here on the sidebar.


    Discussions.

    Note also that this is an act of civil disobedience: the Wild Strawberries, who are protesting the restrictions of the Assembly and Parade Law, did not apply for permits for these assemblies. The Taichung group reported that on the first day two policemen had warned them to leave or be arrested, but apparently some behind the scenes pressure was applied to the police and they are being left alone.


    A law professor at Tunghai speaks to the crowd.

    Students are like saints in Chinese culture; their protests carry weight all out of proportion to their numbers. Their earnestness displays an important characteristic for success in local culture: the doggedness to beat your head against the wall again and again until the wall gives.


    Politics as usual for these longtime DPP supporters.

    BONUS INTERVIEW: USAToday interviews Ma Ying-jeou on the cross-strait talks, the protests, and US-Taiwan relations. You can see the huge benefit that the KMT accrues from having a President who speaks smoothly in English and not in the bombastic, emotive style so common in political communications here. Americans experience that latter style as speaking out of one's own subjectivity, and downgrade speakers who use it. Ma does not come across that way, and thus scores points. Note how he connects himself to Obama too.


    Addressing the crowd.

    Cargo Cult Consumer Confidence and Melamine Mayhem

    The Taipei Times reported plunging consumer confidence in Taiwan, where Taiwan was one of 14 markets in Asia that saw falling consumer confidence....

    In its latest report, MasterCard Worldwide found that consumer confidence in the Asia-Pacific region fell 7 points compared with six months ago, with 70 percent of the respondents saying they planned to cut back on discretionary spending in the next 12 months.

    Consumer confidence in Taiwan was the lowest among the 14 markets, with 90.8 percent of consumers saying they planned to reduce discretionary spending in the next 12 months.

    The report showed that Taiwan and Hong Kong were the hardest hit by the recent global economic turmoil, with Taiwan’s index falling to 32.1 points from 71.3 points six months ago and Hong Kong’s index falling from 83.1 points to 41.8 points.

    Wang attributed the plunge in Taiwan’s consumer confidence to the “awakening” of local consumers after switching their focus from the presidential election campaign in the first half to the worsening economic conditions.
    Wang doesn't want to say that what happened was not an "awakening" -- economic growth was 6% in the first half of the year -- but plunging economic growth since the KMT administration took office (I contemplate with laughter the many claims that "now the adults will be in charge" describing the KMT). But what's the solution? The China Cargo Cult:
    However, Wang expressed confidence that Taiwan’s consumer confidence would improve following the resumption of cross-strait talks, which he expected would help stimulate the nation’s economic growth.
    China solves all ills! I'll be curious to see what emerges in practice with these cross-strait deals, since we've all seen how successful the previous deals on flights and tourism were.

    Speaking of ills and China, a friend alerted me to her wonderful blog Taiwanese Greek, by Taiwanese who live in Greece. This post on the melamine safety procedures is a great look at safety in the Potemkin Village state. The blogger was inspired by another blogger who noted:
    Excerpt from Eric's writing:

    ...So what has been the reaction from the KMT government in Taiwan? It can be described as slow, laughable, and worst of all, deadly for Taiwanese citizens. The KMT’s Department of Health (DOH) on Wednesday night, in a move that defies all sense and reason, actually loosened the food safety standard for melamine from 0 parts per million (ppm) to 2.5 ppm, meaning that imported Chinese food products to Taiwan can contain up to 2.5 ppm of deadly melamine. Even in China, pig feed must have below 2.0 ppm of melamine...
    Read the whole post, it's a fear ride.

    Presbyterian Church in Taiwan on Recent Events

    For those of you who do not know, during the martial law era, when many mainstream Churches were in bed with the regime, the Presbyterian Church fought hard for human rights in Taiwan. This is a powerful voice with a deep and glorious history. They are passing around a "prayer letter" on the recent events.

    +++++++++++++


    台 灣 10647 台 北 市 羅 斯 福 路 三 段 269 巷 3 號
    THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH IN TAIWAN

    3, Lane 269, Roosevelt Road Sec. 3, Taipei 10647 TAIWAN
    General Secretary: Rev. Andrew T. C. Chang


    11 November 2008


    AN APPEAL BY PCT TO THE GLOBAL CHURCH FAMILY FOR PRAYERS CONCERNING THE ABUSE OF JUSTICE AND VIOLATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS IN TAIWAN

    On behalf of the Presbyterian Church in Taiwan (PCT) and out of unyielding concern for the dignity and selfhood of the 23 million people of our nation, as well as for peace in the Asia region, we sincerely appeal to you our sisters and brothers in Christ to join us in expressing concern and offering prayers for Taiwan.

    Ever since the Legislative Elections of January 2008 when the Nationalist Party (Kuomintang KMT) garnered the overwhelming majority of seats and later the KMT candidate, Ma Ying-Jeou, won the Presidential Election on 20 May 2008, the Presbyterian Church in Taiwan (PCT), along with many others in our land, have held deep concerns and reservations for the future of democracy and human rights in our country Taiwan.

    Sadly, the performance of President Ma and his KMT administration the past six months has time and again underscored our fears. We in particular express our grave concern for recent events:

    1) the detentions of both present and former government officials of the opposition party, Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) accused of corruption. We understand one or two detainees have been charged but several accused are still held without being charged and incommunicado, this is a basic violation of due process of justice and rule of law. Furthermore, we are concerned the prosecutor’s office is seemingly leaking information to the press while the accused are unable to defend themselves. This “trial by press” also violates justice and the norm that any accused should be considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Since only members of the DPP opposition party are targeted this action implies the KMT is “using” the justice system to retaliate the former government under Chen’s administration.

    2) the visit to Taiwan (3-7 Nov 2008) of Mr. Chen Yun-Lin, Chairman of the Association for Relations Across the Taiwan Strait (ARATS) from China; and the signing of the four cross-strait accords between the ARATS chairman Chen and the Straits Exchange Foundation (SEF) represented by its Chairman, Chiang Pin-Kung. This action to develop direct aviation, shipping, market trade and economic relations with China accelerated fears that the methods used by the Ma Administration are costly in terms of the legal process, Taiwan’s dignity and sovereignty as well as being a real threat to democracy in Taiwan.

    3) the violation of human rights, freedom of speech and expression, undergirded by the government’s action to deploy more than 10,000 police including riot police officers, to Taipei city to “guard” the visiting dignitary Chen and the sixty people who accompanied him. These measures to “guard and protect” the visiting envoy from China were excessive and disturbingly reminiscent of the dark years under Martial Law.

    With this letter we add a brief overview of some of the events of last week that hopefully will help you further understand the reason for our concerns.

    On behalf of the PCT and Taiwan, thank you for your support and we ask that you kindly share this prayer request with your church members.

    Sincerely yours, in grace and peace

    Rev. Chang Te-Chien (Andrew)

    General Secretary

    ++++++++++++++

    The money paragraph:
    Furthermore, we are concerned the prosecutor’s office is seemingly leaking information to the press while the accused are unable to defend themselves. This “trial by press” also violates justice and the norm that any accused should be considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Since only members of the DPP opposition party are targeted this action implies the KMT is “using” the justice system to retaliate the former government under Chen’s administration.
    The way that the Ma government is moving is usually described as regressing backwards towards authoritarianism, but actually they are moving forward...... in the direction of Singapore.

    Thursday, November 13, 2008

    Daily Links, Nov 13, 2008


    What other wild creatures can be observed on the blogs today?

  • Cycling in Taiwan: a visitor observes.

  • Taiwan: on the protest front-line from Global Voices, and the student protests.

  • Red State blogger discusses the threat to Taiwan from Obama in total ignorance of actual Bush Administration policy.

  • Save the Dolphins on the Dolphins see off Mailiao.

  • Signs in Lukang

  • The Former Native Speaker shows you how to tell the Obama Administration your hopes for Taiwan.

  • Michella with a deeply moving post on her experiences of violence at the Chen Yunlin visit.

  • A-gu has a comprehensive MAC poll on sovereignty issues.

  • Todd actually got a shot of this bug I also spent 15 frustrating minutes trying to get the other day.

  • Taiwan Identity on the richness of non-mandarin culture in Taiwan

  • Jenna's excellent blog post on the sit-ins. Don't worry Jenna, the int'l media will be reporting soon!

  • Urban farming in Neili from Patrick.

  • J Michael on the assumption of Chen's guilt.

  • The Foreigner's thoughts on Chen Yunlin....

  • The last of the BlackCat Commanders.

  • PETITION: You can sign on to the petition on the erosion of justice here.

    MEDIA
    : Taiwan donates $200K to help resettle families after a hurricane. Laughably, AP suggests in a poorly-balanced article that Chen Shui-bian's arrest calls into question the independence movement. If I had a nickel for every time the independence movement was said to be in decline, I'd be a wealthy man indeed. A Businessweek blog entry compares Chen Shui-bian to Bill Clinton. Kaohsiung tour operators complain that there are few Chinese tourists. Imagine that...falling NT dollar good news for Taiwan's silicon foundries. CDC urges you to get your flu shots! Chinese bride claims fax to China is "domestic" and shouldn't get international rates. There's 240,000 of these yammerheads in Taiwan. Freighter runs aground, spills 100 tons of oil. Taiwan's central bank cuts interest rate for fourth time in two months. Watch out for a plummeting NT! Ma and Tsai to meet? Ma save us! Exports fall. Commonwealth Mag on the economy's worrisome fundamentals. Taiwanese drug trafficker busted with 100 kg of horse. Seems like Horse is causing all sorts of trouble these days. TFT-LCD maker Chunghwa pays $65 million in price fixing fine, FBI announces.

    WILD STRAWBERRIES STUDENT PROTESTS: First from their blog, Cheng Hua has updated the students' statement. TaiwaneseAmerican.org on the Wild Strawberry Movement. Five hundred scholars sign on in support. President Ma rejects the student demand for replacing the Chiefs of the Police and NSA. The students should drop their first two demands and focus on the changes in the Assembly and Parade laws. The CNA report on the student demands. Ma addresses students by radio. Taiwan cannot allow human rights rollback, warns Taiwan News. Groups demand revisions to Assembly and Parade Law. Sit-in: a lesson for preserving democracy. Jenna's excellent blog post on the sit-ins. The Bala Daily on their possible exit strategy.

    EVENTS AND ANNOUNCEMENTS: Kaohsiung Charity Book Sale

    Taiwan Communique, latest issue, is up.

    Latest meetup information from Jerome, please RSVP to him as he needs a head count:
    Topic: Taiwanese Media: Behind the Scenes.
    Saturday November 29, 10 am

    Speaker: Tzen-ping Su who served as Chariman of the Board of Taiwan's Central News Agency from July 2002 to June 2008.

    Tzen-ping graduated from the Department of Economics at National Taiwan University and obtained a further degreee of Diplom-Volkswirt from the University ofFrankfurt in Germany.

    He taught Economics at Soochow University, then worked forthe German Trade Office as senior staff and then became a journalist. From 1988 on he was a reporter, researcher, department head and then editorin chief at the Independence Evening Post Group. From 1996 to 2000 he worked for the Taiwan Daily as chief editorial writer.

    In 2000 he was appointed the first non-mainlander DirectorGeneral (minister level) of the Government Information Office (GIO) and stayed there until the cabinet resuffle in Feb. 2002. After that he went to the Central News Agency for the regular six year term as Chairman.

    Hewas also a co-initiatorand once president of the Association of Taiwanese Journalists, the first independent journalistorganization in Taiwan and now a member of the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ)

    With those credentials he can give us a good look behind the scenes of the media situation in Taiwan..

    Venue: the same restaurant where we have been meeting on AnHe Road, just north of HePing.
    Time: 10 am. RSVP to Jerome at jkeating@ms67.hinet.net

    Chinese Students to Come

    The Ministry of Education (MOE) has been working on plans to allow students from China to study in Taiwan's universities. The local university count, now up to 170, is much too high and even though Taiwan's high school students were almost all permitted to enter college under the new national testing system, there are not enough local students.

    What happened was that during the 1990s and under the later DPP administration, subsidies to universities increased rapidly, and many conglomerates with a construction company opened universities as a way to farm the government for subsidy money. Private universities, after all, are for-profit entities and many of them quietly return profits to their owners. When a university has a certain level of facilities, for example a lighted track -- a least one university I know qualified with a track paved with tarmac -- and a certain number of students, it automatically qualifies for subsidies. The government is unwilling to shut down universities though many are unneeded, partly because they function as jobs programs for the PHD holders Taiwan is also now churning out in overly large quantities. This cycle of subsidy - expansion - more subsidy - more expansion appears to have hit its limit. Thus one proposed solution has been importing warm bodies from China.

    During the election Ma promised to do this, and now the numbers are in:

    Under the plan, Chinese students from universities and colleges with “distinguished academic reputations” would be allowed to study in the country, with numbers limited to between 0.5 percent and 1 percent of total nationwide enrollment at colleges, four-year technology institutions and two-year junior technological and vocational education colleges.

    The estimated number of Chinese students coming to Taiwan to study each year would be between 1,000 and 2,000, based on the 200,000 vacancies at 170 institutions nationwide, Vice Minister of Education Lu Mu-lin (呂木琳) told the press conference.

    Some of the local papers were reporting that the students would receive Taiwan government scholarships but the MOE has ruled that out: no gov't scholarships for these students. Other restrictions, such as no future residency or jobs here in Taiwan, would also apply. Like the promised tourist bonanza from China that hasn't materialized, the number is too low to have any marked effect on the university system here.

    International Criticism on its Way?

    Lots of communication from friends and acquaintances asking how we can get more international pressure on the local political situation. It's coming folks, slowly, as awareness dawns. Please write to your local newspaper, your local Congressman, your local Amnesty International Chapter, and tell them your concerns. Nothing will be done until people know there is a problem.

    UPDATE 2: According to the Taipei Times, AIT Director Steve Young commented on the Chen Shui-bian case, asking for a "transparent, fair, and impartial" resolution to it. He said he also expected that the Ma Administration would have further dialogue with the DPP. More, please, Mr. Young. Dutch politicians have also expressed their concerns.

    Meanwhile some commentary in the media is appearing. Today in the South China Post Jerome Cohen of the US Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), the Establishment elite think tank, has an article in the South China Morning Post (SCMP) out of Hong Kong. Cohen was current Taiwan president Ma Ying-jeou's mentor in law school. Here is the article:

    Ties that blind
    Improved cross-strait relations appear to have come at a cost to some civil liberties in Taiwan
    Jerome Cohen
    Nov 13, 2008

    ......[snipped]....

    After police in Tainan failed to prevent an assault on Mr Chen's deputy, president Ma Ying-jeou's government was obligated to do better during Mr Chen's visit. Although police could not prevent Mr Chen from being trapped in a hotel for eight hours by a huge mob of protesters, they did defend him against bodily harm throughout a stressful week.

    In doing so, they went beyond the limits of a free society, forbidding peaceful protesters from displaying Taiwanese and Tibetan flags, confiscating flags from demonstrators, closing a store that played Taiwanese songs and seeking to minimise the visitors' awareness of the protests. There were also incidents of police brutality, albeit sometimes in response to violent provocations by demonstrators.

    The police misconduct even outraged many local supporters of Mr Chen's visit. Mr Ma, in addition to implementing his campaign pledge to sponsor revision of the Assembly and Parade Law to eliminate protesters' need for advance official permission, should recommend amendments prohibiting the kind of undemocratic police practices that recently occurred and order training designed to enhance police compliance with the law. It is encouraging to note that Democratic Progressive Party chairwoman Tsai Ing-wen, who led the massive opposition demonstration, has subsequently called not only for a government review of police misconduct but also for a re-examination by her own party of its failures to maintain order among its demonstrators. The DPP, if it is to fulfil its essential role as democratic opposition, must not degenerate into an army of street fighters.

    Some Taiwanese and foreign critics took the occasion of Mr Chen's visit to call attention to another crucial feature of democratic government - the fair prosecution of current and former officials suspected of corruption. The critics voiced three serious complaints about recent arrests and incommunicado detentions of prominent DPP figures who have served as government officials. They imply that the DPP is being singled out for prosecutions while corruption among Kuomintang leaders is being ignored. They also claim that: most DPP suspects have been held incommunicado without a court examination of the justification for their detentions; and that prosecutors' offices have been leaking detrimental information about the suspects to the media while denying them knowledge of the leaks and a chance to refute the "trial by press".

    These practices, it is said, bring into question the political neutrality of the judiciary, and the presumption of innocence and other elements of due process required for the fair and open trials essential to democracy, raising the spectre of the unjust procedures of "the dark days of martial law" (1947-1987). It is not clear whether critics' claims of "selective prosecution" are well founded. Recent arrests may simply reflect massive corruption by the DPP, which dominated executive government for the past eight years - corruption that allegedly reached as high as former president Chen Shui-bian and his family.

    Oddly, although during the Chen administration some prosecutions were brought against both DPP and KMT figures, some obvious KMT targets were overlooked despite reportedly thick dossiers compiled by Control Yuan investigators. Mr Ma should appoint a commission of impartial experts to review such prosecutions.

    It does not appear that any of the recently detained DPP figures were denied a court hearing or their right to counsel. Moreover, there is a legislative basis for the courts' decisions to detain them incommunicado for up to four months of investigation if there is a reasonable basis for believing that the suspects might otherwise falsify evidence. Yet, in view of the harshness of this pre-indictment sanction and the obstacles it creates to mounting an adequate defence, it ought to be invoked rarely.

    Certainly, the Legislative Yuan, or the commission suggested here, should re-examine legislation to strike a new balance between the threat of corruption to a democratic government and the threat of incommunicado detention to civil liberty.

    The charge of biased prosecution leaks to the press seems to be the most straightforward of the critics' complaints. Such leaks, which occur in many countries, do appear to have taken place and cannot be allowed in a democratic system.

    Jerome A. Cohen is co-director of NYU's US-Asia Law Institute and adjunct senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations
    I have to wonder what Cohen and his fellows among the US Establishment imagined they were doing when they supported Ma Ying-jeou for President. There's a simple formula: the closer Taiwan gets to China, the more civil liberties here will have to be suppressed. When Taiwan is China, as during the martial law era, civil liberties are completely suppressed. Still, criticism of any kind, however lukewarm, is welcome, and definitely preferable to silence.

    Cohen's piece is highly apologetic and defensive, possibly because Cohen strongly supported Ma and the KMT in the 2008 Presidential election and now bears, in some ghostly way, at least a moral responsibility for what is happening ("It is not clear whether critics' claims of "selective prosecution" are well founded. Recent arrests may simply reflect massive corruption by the DPP, which dominated executive government for the past eight years - corruption that allegedly reached as high as former president Chen Shui-bian and his family.") ROFL. Detainee Su Chih-fen, Yunlin County Commissioner, has no connection to Chen and is an elected official doing her job. It's very clear what's going on -- but at least the international media is starting to wake up to the issue. More articles please!

    UPDATE 1: I've decided to keep expanding this post as new commentary rolls in, so it is going to get loooooong. This from the National Review blog...

    Things look bad in Taiwan. Former president (2000-2008) Chen Shui-bian has been arrested on corruption charges by the government of his successor (since May this year), Ma Ying-jeou. Chen was pro-autonomy; Ma is much keener on "cross-strait relations." Chen's arrest comes after some ugly scenes last week during a visit to the island by a ChiCom flunky, in aid of further "improving cross-strait relations." There were public protests, dealt with very brutally by the police.

    On the corruption charges: I wouldn't be surprised, though the administration has acted very high-handedly in making evidence known, and in its treatment of Chen. He was for example manacled, quite unnecessarily. (See this editorial from today's Taipei Times.) But then, "un-corrupt Taiwan politician" is pretty much an oxymoron, and I doubt Ma's affairs would bear very close scrutiny. His party is the KMT, after all — the party, that is, of the late Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek, know in his time to American newspapermen as "General Cash My Check." What's going on here is the criminalization of politics; and if the ChiComs don't have a hand in it somewhere, then their Intelligence and Covert Ops people are not doing what their employers pay them to do.


    Wednesday, November 12, 2008

    Chen Shui-bian Held [UPDATE: DETAINED]

    Jon Adams in the CS Monitor has the call with a very fair article on the issue....

    Chen's own legal woes began with allegations that he embezzled money from a special fund designated for Taiwan's diplomacy. But as a president he was immune from prosecution.

    He was named as a suspect on May 20, the day he stepped down from office. The probe led to allegations of far more serious graft, involving millions of dollars moved through a complicated array of foreign accounts and shell companies. Prosecutors have focused on possible kickbacks or bribes during the government-led privatization of some of Taiwan's state-run banks, which sparked fierce competition among prospective buyers.

    The legal push against him has stirred criticism of Taiwan's legal system – particularly prosecutors' right to hold suspects for up to four months without charge. Nine pro-independence party figures are currently in such detention, according to local press reports, which has fueled charges of a political witch-hunt.

    Mr. Chiang say the detentions point to the need for legal reform in Taiwan. "Our rule of law still has a long way to go," says Chiang. "The legal process is not well respected in some cases."

    The Ma government insists it is not interfering with judicial proceedings, and prosecutors argue the detentions are necessary to prevent collusion between suspects.
    Under the law Chen can be detained for 60 days, and then, with re-application, for 60 more. If you like the idea of detaining people without charges for long periods of time, you can apply for a job at Guantanamo. No evidence? Just put them in detention indefinitely, and sooner or later "confessions" will result.

    Adams nicely contextualizes the Chen arrest by putting in the context of other arrests over the last couple of weeks of DPP politicians. The prosecutors claim that detentions are necessary to prevent collusion between the defendents, but not everyone detained is involved in the Chen case. Detainee Su Chih-fen is on a hunger strike right now to protest her detention, and she has nothing to do with Chen.

    Chen has, as of last night and early this morning, not actually been formally detained. He is being held while prosecutors ask the court for permission to formally detain him, according to the Taipei Times. There were reports that he was roughed up, which both pro-Blue TVBS and pro-Blue ETTV said were basically true according to what I heard, and he went to the hospital last night to be checked. UPDATE: Prosecutors received permission to detain him this morning, he sustained only a minor muscle tear, according to AP. UPDATE 2: After reviewing information in comments and on various websites, it appears that Chen was basically being bombastic again, and nothing very serious occurred.

    I know everyone despises that hopeless miscreant, and frankly, the thought that we might go months without hearing any of his bombastic twitticisms is relieving. I know you must also be delighted to see him get his comeuppance, for the way he totally betrayed Taiwan, his party, and its longstanding ideals. If his were the only case that had been pursued recently, I'd be overjoyed. Let the bastard rot. As Antonio Chiang, Chen's former National Security Council and current Apple Daily editor in chief said in the CSM article:

    "He's intentionally distorting and twisting everything, trying desperately to get support from some diehards at the expense of the DPP [the pro-independence party]," says Antonio Chiang, former head of the National Security Council in Chen's government. "He's destroyed the value of democracy and the significance of the Taiwan independence movement, and destroyed the dream of Taiwan for Taiwanese."

    Chiang exaggerates, but it captures the way many of us felt when Chen admitted he broke the law.

    But unfortunately, the fact that Chen is a confessed tax evader and may well have taken bribes as well, does not mean that this is not a political prosecution. No KMT politicians are being investigated and none of the local gangsters in the DPP are being investigated. This is aimed at DPP higher-ups. Nine DPP politicians have been detained or indicted recently, by a government that has repeatedly said it looks to Singapore as a model.

    Let him who has ears, hear.