Who could have imagined that?
Laudably, AmCham called on Washington to move closer to Taipei and to either resolve or ignore the idiotic beef issue.
The Taipei Times reported:
“Taiwan should pursue greater balance by consolidating its economic connections with such other major markets as Europe, Japan, Southeast Asia and especially the United States, the world’s biggest economy,” AmCham chairman Bill Wiseman told a media briefing on the release of the organization’s annual white paper.Over-reliance on one market is risky? No kidding? Wasn't that the warning sounded repeatedly by the pro-Taiwan side in the run-up to the 2008 election? Didn't we all know what would happen? Ironically Wiseman's remarks took place even as dependence on China actually fell quarter on quarter, 42.8 percent in the first quarter last year to 40.9 percent of Taiwan's trade over the same period in 2011 (here).
Wiseman’s warning came a few hours before the release of Taiwan’s latest trade data, which showed China accounting for 40.2 percent of exports last month, while the US took only 12.3 percent.
“Over-reliance on one market is always risky,” Wiseman said. “Taiwan should not turn away growth when it can get it, but it needs to lock in the future. It needs to go and start broadening its economic relationships beyond focusing so much on China.”
Taiwan is almost doubly dependent on China, which drove 47 percent of the country’s economic growth last year, sharply higher than the 25 percent average with the G20 nations, he said.
According to the AmCham press release, the White Paper recommended that Taiwan focus on developing its European, Japanese and US markets. But at the same time, it remains strongly supportive of ECFA and urged the government to continue
Who could have imagined that the Ma Administration would be too focused on China?
The other point they made, also a criticism, relates to the government's resolution of issues important to AmCham.
The organization found that of the 114 issues and sub-issues raised last year, only 14, or 12.3 percent, were resolved or showed satisfactory progress — the lowest in its history of tracking issues seven years ago.Many of these issues have been around for years.
Time Travel: just for fun I searched my blog for some previous AmCham comments. I've been following AmCham's institutionally pro-KMT stance for quite some time. Remember when AmCham complained that the TSU was gettin' all in their face with ideology? That was in 2006...
The editorial in AmCham's latest issue of TOPICS magazine criticizing the TSU's opposition to closer economic ties with the mainland yesterday infuriated TSU politicians, who warned the chamber against interfering in Taiwan's internal politics.Yes, with a million Taiwanese in China at that point, the head of AmCham was worried that Taiwan would become like North Korea or Burma.
The editorial even provoked comments from former President Lee Teng-hui according to local news reports.
Vuylsteke said the chamber's stance on closer ties with China was similar to views held by the majority of the public. He warned that too much economic isolation would make Taiwan a nation similar to North Korea or Burma.
From the 2008 White Paper, which was quite reasonable in many ways, came this scolding:
AmCham reiterated its long-held position in favor of eased economic interflows across the Taiwan Strait, with particular reference to expanded non-stop charter flights. If air travel between Taiwan and mainland cities becomes time-saving and convenient, more multinational – and Taiwanese – companies will choose to locate more key personnel and business units in Taiwan for reasons of quality of life, IPR protection, and other rule of law issues, it said. The Chamber called on Beijing to appreciate the special opportunity created by the current political environment in Taiwan, and therefore to respond positively to the Ma administration’s initiatives. In addition, it asked the Taiwan government to take action on measures that it could implement unilaterally, such as removing caps on direct Taiwanese investment in China and on mutual fund investments with China holdings, and eliminating “frivolous” items such as potato chips from the list of products banned from being imported from China.In 2009 I asked when AmCham was finally going to learn. AmCham was complaining that the government's plan to lower the cap on credit card rates. The Taipei Times ripped them because of course all of us who are familiar with the KMT's long-term behavior knew precisely what was going to happen. But in that post I quoted my 2007 post...
One of the major problems with Taiwan's economy, from outsider's perspective, is that it is often a game outsiders are not allowed to play. The Chambers of Commerce appear to be of the opinion that this will change if Ma is elected. Lotsa luck, guys. Because after Ma "opens" the economy, AmCham editorials are going to read like this:____________________
"While in principle we welcome the new openness shown by Taiwan during the first two years of President Ma's administration, AmCham wishes to express its growing concern over the preferential treatment given firms from China....."
- Ben Goren flipped me this hilarious sendup of Taiwan Today's Pollyannish Presentations
- Foreign Policy looks at the South China Sea: Crowded Waters
- Pressure for F-16 sale building in Congress
- I don't think the MAC polls are trustworthy anymore.
- New blog: Saving Siraya, on the Siraya people of south-central Taiwan.
- Don't Miss: Philip Bowring's awesome article on Chinese expansionism
- Don't Miss: Jared Diamond on the Austronesian Languages, Taiwan's gift to the world.
[Taiwan] Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums! Delenda est, baby.