Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts

Saturday, March 25, 2017

The sad case of DPP Justice Minister Chiu Tai-san

Onions. Because Chiu Tai-san makes me cry.

Our DPP Justice Minister revealed himself to be not only a retrograde thinker, but a Han nationalist to boot. Speaking on gay marriage at a hearing that was live streamed, Justice Minister Chiu Tai-san said:
“The Civil Code stipulates that marriage shall be between a man and a woman, and as such it is not unconstitutional. The Constitution guarantees citizens’ right to marry as that between a man and a woman, while marriage between people of the same sex is not covered under the Constitution,” Chiu said.

“For thousands of years in the nation’s history, society has instituted traditions and codes of conduct regarding marriage. Has there ever been a cultural institution or social phenomenon for same-sex marriage?” Chiu said.

“Without a doubt, there has been none,” Chiu said.

He then quoted one section of the Chinese classic I Ching (易經), also known as the Book of Changes, which reads: “With the existence of the earth and the sky, there came all living things. With the existence of the earth and the sky, there came men and women,” which he said illustrates that Chinese marriage traditions have — since ancient times — been based on a union between a man and a woman.
This kind of argument is completely idiotic -- projecting modern institutions into the past in order to legitimate them. Jenna (added: actually her quietly brilliant husband) tracked down this website giving some examples of different kinds of marriages in China over time. Recall that polygamy was common, with not only multiple wives but also concubines. And women marrying a set of brothers was a known marriage form. Any competent anthropologist could give many examples of other forms of marriage not only in China but all over the world.

The issue is exactly the same as in the US, where "conservatives" scream the lie that marriage has always been one man, one woman. Reality is always the opposite of such fantasies. It is not difficult to find the many works that depict the deep roots of homosexuality and same-sex marriage in Chinese culture. Take the introduction to this book, which remarks on the commonality of homosexuality in Chinese culture:
Many times homosexuality acted as an integral part of society, complete with same-sex marriages for both men and women. 
You don't have to know anything about gay marriage in Chinese history to know that if a social conservative is asserting something about marriage and history, he's almost certainly wrong. Indeed, in many Buddhist circles where reincarnation is believed, it is also believed that two souls are fated to marry each other irrespective of sex, which provided religious sanction for homosexual marriage in ancient Chinese society. Of course many regions had their own traditions of gay marriage. Chiu's claims are a perfect melding of idiocy and ignorance.

Why O why can't science and scholarship form the basis of our public discourse and decision-making?

Despite Chiu Tai-san's claim, the ROC Constitution does not mention marriage, as far as I can see. Article 7 guarantees equality before the law, while Article 8 guarantees personal freedom. How you interpret that is up to you. But it seems to me that it is hard to uphold Article 7 yet oppose gay marriage.

Citing the I Ching is unwise, at best. A DPP minister should take the view that Taiwan can form its own traditions, customs, and cultures, and that China should be left behind. Using Chinese historical hokum as the basis for arguments in modern society should never be a DPP practice, it tends to create connections where none are necessary.

Moreover, anti-homosexuality in modern Taiwan has its roots in another discourse -- that of state power and control, the heterosexualization of society, and the faux Confucian morality of the KMT's Party-State. This paper observes:
During the first two decades of Kuomintang (KMT) rule, Taiwan experienced steady economic growth but changes to the political system were not permitted; the corporatist model of KMT rule was omnipresent. Taiwanese society between the 1950s and 1960s could be described as heterosexualized in terms of discourse; “family values” were regarded as deriving directly from a stable Confucian and Chinese tradition and public discourses of same-sex desire were almost non-existent:
...revealing the fundamental truth: that assertions of "family values" are the code language of right-wing nationalist state power and control.

Hence, when Chiu Tai-san marginalized gay marriage (and implicitly, gayness) as "unChinese", he was invoking decades of this rightist, ahistorical, inhuman discourse that helped form the basis of KMT power in Taiwan.

Thanks, Chiu Tai-san. You're a genius.

Imagine if Chiu had taken another view -- that gay marriage was an ancient practice in south China from whence many ancestors of Taiwanese arrived. Imagine if his use of history had been informed, sensitive, and progressive. Imagine if he'd envisioned gay people as human beings like himself....

Total fail on all fronts by Chiu Tai-san.
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Thursday, February 16, 2012

Lawyers on the rise

My friend Michael Fahey pointed to this post at the Winkler Partners blog on the rising number of lawyers in Taiwan.
The number of lawyers in Taiwan increased significantly in 2011 as a record 964 candidates passed the bar exam.

Despite a population of 23 million people and the world’s 19th largest economy, Taiwan has just 7,000 practicing lawyers according to the Ministry of Justice. The California State Bar, for example, has nearly 200,000 members. The Netherlands, with a population of 6 million, had 15,000 lawyers in 2007.

According to Ministry of Examination figures, the pass rate for the 2011 exam was 10.6%.

While this may seem very low by the standards of other jurisdictions, it is unprecedented in Taiwan. During the martial law era (1949-1987), pass rates were below 1%. Between 1950 and 1989, just 782 lawyers became members of the bar. In 1981, two years after the Kaohsiung Incident, just six passed. This was widely understood to signal the government’s displeasure with the profession after a team of lawyers defended the leaders of the rally that triggered the incident.
It's a fascinating look at a completely different legal climate. The whole post is full of excellent observations. Jane Kaufman Winn, who did work in Taiwan in the 1990s on various aspects of the legal system, formal and informal, has an extensive paper on the legal profession as it emerged from martial law in the early 1990s. She notes:
Before the recent reforms to the bar admission system in Taiwan, there were several avenues to admission to the bar that were at least as important as, if not more important than, the official bar exam. These included service as an attorney for one of the armed forces, and passage of a minimal bar examination for those holding positions above a certain rank for a certain period of time within a law faculty in Taiwan. These “backdoors” to admission to the bar were very important when the passage rate for the official bar examination averaged around 1-2% a year, as it did before 1989. For many years, obtaining a J.D. or other advanced law degree in the US before returning to Taiwan to take up a position teaching part-time in a law faculty was a more certain path to admission to the ROC bar than sitting the official bar examination, at least for those with the resources to study abroad.
The Winkler piece observes that one reason for the small number of lawyers is that there are many routes to dispute resolution in local society -- the government bureaus resolve many disputes that might go to lawyers in other countries. The police also play a similar role, resolving disputes before they ever arrive in court. Certain kinds of transactions are handled by specialized paralegals in Taiwan and also never see the hand of a lawyer. Finally, they note that legal work in Taiwan is expensive and many simply can't afford it.

Further review: The MOJ's English database of laws in Taiwan
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums! Delenda est, baby.

Friday, January 22, 2010

PRC in Taiwan: New Restrictions on Defense Lawyers Demanded by MOJ

Read the whole thing, but Jerome Cohen has done the island another service in publicizing the proposed Ministry of Justice curbs on defense lawyers. It compares Taiwan to the PRC, savage in its civility. Read closely and carefully.
....By contrast, the Taiwan government’s new interest in curbing vigorous defense lawyers does constitute “news”. Although Taiwan’s president Ma Ying-Jeou recently took the occasion of the island’s Law Day to call for greater government efforts to promote judicial reform and human rights, his Ministry of Justice (MOJ) has been moving in the opposite direction.

Last year, the Ministry, concerned about the conduct of ex-president Chen Shui-Bian’s defense lawyers in its ongoing corruption prosecutions against him, failed in its efforts to impose disciplinary sanctions against one of Chen’s lawyers for supposed ethical violations. Now it is trying to introduce legislation to punish “obstructions of justice” that will inevitably restrict defense lawyers’ activities.

The MOJ has proposed to amend the criminal code in several ways that threaten the modified adversarial legal system that Taiwan adopted a decade ago. Instead of supporting the equal contest between prosecutors and defense lawyers on which that system is based, the MOJ proposals, reflecting traditional Chinese distrust of defense lawyers, would subject Taiwan’s lawyers to some of the same dangers confronted by their counterparts in China, including significant prison time.

One amendment would punish anyone, including lawyers, for abetting defendants or others to “fabricate, alter, destroy or conceal” important evidence in criminal cases, even when their advice has been ignored and caused no harm! Further, it would punish anyone for abetting defendants to make false statements concerning important facts in trial or investigation. Thus, if a court rejects the defendant’s claim that his pre-trial confession was coerced by police, his lawyers might be prosecuted for having urged him to repudiate the confession. This “Sword of Damocles” hangs over Mainland lawyers, sometimes intimidating them from giving such advice, despite the prevalence of pre-trial torture.

Equally troublesome is the proposal to punish “illegitimate use” of important evidence outside of court. But what use is “illegitimate” and what evidence is “important”? The MOJ has stated that the provision is meant, among other things, to prevent documents from public trials being revealed at press conferences. Yet this would prevent freedom of speech and information essential to monitoring of the judicial process by the media and the people. Such restrictions, to the extent they exist in other democratic societies, are generally justified by the need to protect jury deliberations against media pressures, but Taiwan has no juries.

Even more problematic is the proposal to punish lawyers not only for contempt of court but also for contempt of prosecutors! Legal systems require effective and fair procedures for punishing refusal to heed reasonable court orders. But, in a system where lawyers and prosecutors are supposed to be equal competitors in their efforts to persuade a neutral judge, it is ludicrous to punish lawyers for failing to obey prosecutors.
The Ministry of Justice's response in Chinese is here. Note how the Chen case is being used as leverage against defense lawyers, once again providing evidence that the Chen case is all about politics. But seriously Dr. Cohen, what did you guys expect when you helped lever Ma into power?

__________
More Daily Links
_______________________
Don't miss the comments below! And check out my blog and its sidebars for events, links to previous posts and picture posts, and scores of links to other Taiwan blogs and forums!

Saturday, May 03, 2008

Did you know? Warren Court and Taiwan's Justice System

This book review observes that Taiwan's justice system was influenced by the Warren Court:

....In East Asia, the pattern was somewhat different. Thomas Ginsburg, an associate professor of law and director of the Program in Asian Law, Politics, and Society at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, chose three places (Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan) as case studies. These cases suggest that in East Asia, the Warren Court's rulings in the area of criminal procedure, and especially the rulings formulating the exclusionary rule (_Mapp v. Ohio_[1961]) and finding the right to counsel for criminal defendants (_Gideon v. Wainright_ [1963]) in state courts, have had the biggest impact. Other landmark Warren Court rulings, such as _Brown v. Board of Education_ (1954) and _Baker v. Carr_ (1962), have had much more limited influence there, Ginsburg finds.

Saturday, November 17, 2007

Chen Chu Wins One

Chen Chu, the DPP Mayor of Kaohsiung, won her appeal that reversed a lower court decision to annul her victory in the Kaohsiung mayoral race.

An appeals court ruled Friday that the mayor of Taiwan's second largest city was elected fairly, reversing the decision of a lower court.

The island's High Court said the razor thin electoral victory of Chen Chu in the southern city of Kaohsiung last December was legal and that she could remain in office.

In June the Kaohsiung District Court had accepted the claim of opponent Huang Jun-ying of the main opposition Nationalists that the vote was unfair, nullifying her election by 1,114 ballots out of a some 770,000 cast.

Huang had said Chen's camp smeared him by presenting a video on the eve of the poll allegedly showing vote-buying on a bus returning from his campaign rally.

In its ruling Friday, the High Court said Chen's allegations of vote-buying by Huang did not force voters to necessarily choose her candidacy over his.

"Chen Chu's campaign did not compel voters to vote one way or the other," the court said.

The ruling is not subject to appeal.

At issue were allegations of vote buying that surface at the end of the campaign. The weird logic of the ruling is in response to the lower court's ruling that originally annulled the election:

Judges decided that accusations Chen's camp made regarding Huang Jun-ying (黃俊英), her main rival, on the eve of the election and on the polling day influenced election results.

The district court stressed in a news release that "Chen's polling-day action of making public a videotape showing a man giving money to passengers on a bus and urging them to vote for Huang could be regarded as a surprise attack against Huang and thus to have made the election unfair."

The night before the election Chen Chu and her supporters found evidence that the Huang camp had been vote buying, and trumpeted it to the public. That was after the election activities were supposed to have ceased, a seeming violation of the law.

According to a report in the Taipei Times about the vote buying, KMT candidate Huang's campaign manager admits that he knew the vote buyer:

Su Wan-chi (蘇萬基), the executive of the KMT mayoral candidate's campaign team, admitted that he had asked Yang, who also is from Yunlin, to help mobilize support for the candidate. But did Su give Yang NT$60,000 to pay voters to participate in rallies? If he did not, then where did the money come from?

Lin Ping-feng (林平峰), chairman of the Yunlin Association, admitted to prosecutors that the association rented 10 buses for Huang's election-eve rally, but that it did not include the two buses Yang had organized for his mobilization activities.

However, Su, a former chairman of the Yunlin Association, had already admitted that he asked Yang to mobilize supporters for the rally, and he managed to fax the map of the rally to Ku.


I have a long revew of vote buying as a tactic in Taiwan here.

Did the vote buying influence the election? The numbers, as always, won't support Blue fantasies. As I wrote last year:

In Kaohsiung, things were just the opposite. Chen's Chu's narrow victory was almost certainly the result of the presence of the TSU candidate in the race. In 2002 the DPP won by more than 25,000 votes, 386K to 361K, with no TSU or PFP candidates in the race. In 2006, the KMT gained 17K votes to reach 378K -- which looks like a huge gain, until one recalls that in 1998 they spiked at 383K. Had they merely reached their 1998 levels, they would have won handily.

By the same contrast, the DPP's 379K vote was 7K less than 2002. One might argue that the DPP has fallen off, except that the TSU took 6,500 votes. The 2006 TSU + DPP total is 386K votes. Hence Chen Chu's showing was not some statistical blip or DPP failure, but the direct result of the TSU poaching votes from the DPP; the number of Green voters remains unchanged. Meanwhile the KMT gain was due entirely to success in getting out the vote, not to voters switching parties due to some putative disappointment with the DPP. Again, had the KMT reached its 1998 level, it would have won.

In other words, had the TSU not had a candidate in the race, Chen Chu would have won by a much bigger margin. The Courts split evenly on this one, but how screwed up is the justice system? News came out today that Lee Tai-an, sentence to 18 years for helping to murder his brother's Vietnamese wife, got out on bail prior to his third and final hearing. Lee became a folk hero in the Blue community after getting busted for setting up an elaborate conspiracy to murder for insurance money, a conspiracy that also threatened the innocent passengers on the trains Lee helped derail. Claiming persecution by the justice system, he actually showed up as a celebrity at Shih Ming-te's anti-Chen protest in Taipei, one of the many excesses that helped discredit those faux protests. Lee got out on -- hold your breath -- NT$20,000 in bail. That's not an error, folks. $NT20K. I think we're looking at yet another in the long line of KMT-loving criminals who will mysteriously manage to vanish from Taiwan and turn up in China...


Friday, May 11, 2007

Taiwan Court Expertise Expands

Gotta love those Taiwan courts. First they claimed expertise in English grammar, now they have knowledge of exorcism that puts clergymen to shame....

Four clergymen were ordered yesterday by the Taoyuan District Court to face a detention of 30 to 40 days for injuring a woman during an attempted "spiritual healing" of her.

The priests allegedly used bed linens to bind the woman when trying to exorcise evil spirits from her, following the same practices as seen in the movie "The Exorcist."

Refusing to accept this kind of healing, the woman got hurt while struggling to become free.

The four clergymen were invited to expel evil from the woman by her younger sister, who thought something must be wrong with the woman, as she liked to stay home alone.

Now, you or I might agree that the priests were out of hand, and pointed to small problems like the failure to obtain the consent of the possessed, or the use of violence against another human being. We might also have had a few tart questions for the gendered nature of the conclusion that exorcism was necessary (would a man who liked to be alone have been construed to be possessed?). But our Taiwan courts, heroic in their omniscience, gave the real reason why the priests had to be jailed: they were incompetent exorcists.

Taoyuan District Court ruled to have the priests detained for 30 to 40 days, on the grounds that exorcising evil spirits does not require such violent practices.

See? If only they had asked the judge first, he would have told them how to handle the exorcism properly.