So much headache this week. I think I'm going to invest all my retirement funds in tranquilizers, since everyone in DC must be taking them by the handful now...
Yeah, hopefully Trump will start trolling on another topic, so I don't have to write any more posts like this and can go back to writing on domestic events.
Wilfred Chan, whose stuff is excellent, observed what I have been saying publicly and privately in a Tweet:
Suggestion: whenever you feel rising panic about a China thing, look to see how Taiwanese people are reacting. They've dealt with it decadesWatching these panics happen periodically is very instructive in maintaining that Zen-like calm in the face of hyperventilation in the Commentariat. I also recommend dogs, whiskey, and bicycling...
...my very sharp man Solidarity, now studying in the US and new proud father (congrats!) also tweetly observed:
If I were Zhongnanhai I'd be wondering how else to take advantage of Western media liking me better than they do the incoming US presidentI made a mistake, actually. When I pointed out that the media was teaching China what topics were safe for it to be tough on, I forgot that it was also teaching our future President what topics were sensitive enough for successful trolling.
As for Trump's most recent remarks, J Michael Cole said it in one China, Many Trumps:
But one thing is certain: the likelihood that the United States will scuttle “one China” is next to nil, as such a policy goes against even what the more creative (and pro-Taiwan) of Trump’s advisers on Taiwan and China, people like John Bolton, have argued over the years. In Bolton’s case, his argument has been that dual recognition might be possible, albeit under a “one China” framework. The logic behind this is that there is nothing in the United States’ “one China” policy that prevents dual recognition. (Whether such an argument would be palatable to Beijing or Taipei is a different question altogether.)This is exactly right: not much will change because Trump is surrounded by people who will keep policies that help Taiwan in place and expand around the edges where they can. Whenever there is policy change, there is pushback from opponents who are powerful and heavily invested in the current framework. Leaders might make noises about revolutionary change, but change usually occurs incrementally, if it happens at all.
You're just watching that pushback against Trump's possible future policies in realtime...
A couple of small things... many pieces contended that Taiwan was a "core interest" of China. The is one of the ways the media noise helps conceal what is actually going on, supporting Beijing inadvertently. Taiwan is not a core interest of China. Let's spell this out for future reference:
Taiwan is not a core interest of China. Annexing Taiwan without interference from other Powers is the core interest at stake here.PRC nationalism has now invested Taiwan with deep expansionist significance -- two generations have been brainwashed. It will be difficult for the PRC to decouple itself from this train. Let's hope it can find a way, but in the meantime... keep talking to the individual Chinese you meet.
The overreading into Trump's remarks (On video) was comical. Many commentators over-read "I heard the call was coming probably an hour or two before" to mean he never knew about the call, but the comment was not meant in so literal a way. Much of the noise is driven by the media's profound anti-Trump bias. And no, I am not defending Trump (pointing out media bias is not the same as defending Trump). Nor am I a neo-con (now that's comedy -- I'm so pink there's a shoot-on-sight order on me in Saudi Arabia).
Is Taiwan going to be used as a bargaining chip? It some ways it always has been, but no, the Trump Administration isn't going to sell Taiwan for oil drilling rights for Exxon or for lower tariffs on US goods or for a different currency policy. Could things get worse? Well, the NY Times sententiously warned us that Bad Things Could Happen. Salvatore Babones laffed:
The NYT warns that China could buy Airbus, trade with North Korea, burn coal, snub Taiwan, and trade with Iran. So?Things China is doing anyway. Ye gods.
Yes, our newspapers are always pointing out what China could do to the US. We never hear what could happen in return. A tit for tat trade war helps no one, which is why it won't happen.
Meanwhile, Trump's foreign policy trolling is a success: that much less attention and space in the mainstream media is given to his Administration picks....
______________
More Links:
- DON'T MISS WaPo: Steven Goldstein explains why Trump's words are a problem, and even correctly and openly states the US one China policy. Good stuff.
- National Interest: Cole on one China, many Trumps
- TIME: Trump's one China doubting sparks fear and hope in Taiwan
- WashTimes: Tkacik on Five Myths about the US one China policy
- WaPo: China paper says Trump ignorant as baby
- NYTimes: What China could do
- Vox: Trump is using Taiwan as bargaining chip
- Brookings: Obama asia chief Jeff Bader on Trump-China-US
- QZ: What China could do
- Cole: The Call: domestic side
- IBTimes: One China policy not for trading
- National Interest: The Call heralds new Asia policy
- SCMP: Trump = wild card, previous presidents got more "pragmatic"
- Video: Bill Sharp kicks ass on tourists and other stuff
- Video: Trump's remarks on Fox
- Audio: Shelly Rigger on Trump-China-US
- Audio: Bonnie Glaser on Trump-China-US
- Foreign Policy: Another call for Taiwan to be Taiwan
- Bloomberg: Japan watches uneasily
- NYTimes: Obama says Taiwan "close ally" of the US
- TT: US includes Taiwan in military bill, upgrade of relations
- BBC: (here for completeness)
- National Review: Taiwan is America's BFF, and Trump was right on phone call
- LATimes: Taiwan is trending, and Taiwanese-Americans have mixed feelings
- The Guardian: Donald Trump... nah, forget it. It appears Simon Tisdall knows even less about US China policy than Donald Trump.
- Chinese Foreign Ministry: China official met with Flynn to exchange views
- Foreign policy: Tsai Ing-wen in their Global Thinkers.
- DOMESTIC
- Banyan: Taiwan debates gay marriage
- Hong Kong independence activists assaulted by pro-China groups on visit to Taiwan
- Japan Times: The excellent Jeff Kingston on the gay marriage culture war
- Conscription to end in 2018
- Slow grow over next 2 years forecasted
- Airport MRT line to be operational.... any minute now.
- Tsai urges bilateral trade deal with US. Yes, please
