Saturday, January 19, 2008

Talk of Asian Marketing

My friend Clyde, an Asian marketing expert here at Chunghsing University, has put together a new podcast called Talk of Asian Marketing. Here's what he says....

A few researchers in Taiwan and I have put together a podcast/videocast that emphasizes the local aspects of marketing in Chinese culturally influenced markets, like Taiwan, Hong Kong, and China. The site is a teaching resource that organizes local business research in one place, but more importantly, supplies a location where the local emphasis can gain more visibility for marketing researchers and practitioners. The site is located at http://ccc.qbook.tv and the podcast is called Talk of Asian Marketing.

The site has video covering the Costco Taichung opening, lots of photos and video of local marketing issues, research reports and presentations, and marketing related book reviews.

Clyde, who publishes in top journals in a couple of fields, is one of the most knowledgeable and perceptive commentators on local consumer and cultural behavior that I know. He is also a close personal friend, and someone I admire very much. I'm delighted that he's taken this opportunity to share his knowledge with the online world. Take a moment to listen; you won't be disappointed.

More on the Polynesians and Taiwan

Yet another study on the relationships between Taiwan and Polynesians....

In the research, scientists examined more than 800 genetic markers known to be useful in distinguishing the ancestry of people. These involved mitochondrial DNA, passed down through females, and the Y chromosomes in males. Previous investigations along these lines had been conducted on a much smaller scale, Dr. Friedlaender said.

The new test results were repeatedly analyzed with a software program recently developed to classify genetic similarities and variations among different populations.

Primary support for the study was provided by the National Science Foundation, the Wenner-Gren Foundation of Anthropological Research, the National Geographic Society and the National Institutes of Health.

Further research to confirm the history of the Pacific diaspora, Dr. Friedlaender said, would require an expansion of genetic tests among people in the Philippines and Indonesia, regions that the migrants presumably passed through after leaving Taiwan more than 3,500 years ago, ultimately reaching as far as Hawaii and Easter Island. The Melanesians, on the other hand, probably arrived on their islands about 35,000 years ago, sometime later than the Aborigines reached Australia.

Fascinating stuff.

Post Election Analysis

There's plenty of discussion about the reasons and effects of the legislative election...First, Taiwan Communique has a whole edition out on the elections, with articles by Bruce Jacobs, among others. Go here for the most recent issue. Next, a reader in Calgary reminds me that Willy Lam at the Jamestown Foundation has a piece out on it:

The ruling Democratic Progressive Party’s (DPP) stunning defeat in Taiwan’s parliamentary polls last weekend is expected to lower tension in the Taiwan Straits and speed up economic integration between the mainland and the self-ruled island. The DPP’s Waterloo may help convince President Chen Shui-bian and other pro-independence politicians in the “Green Party” to re-evaluate and perhaps tone down its tactic of provoking Beijing and capitalizing on the antagonism between Fujianese-speaking native Taiwanese (bensheng ren) and mainlanders (waisheng ren) that followed the Nationalist Government from China to Taiwan in 1949. The prospects of Ma Ying-Jeoh, the presidential candidate for the opposition Kuomintang (KMT or Nationalist Party)—which favors eventual reunification with China—in the March 22 presidential polls have also risen. Cross-Straits development in the coming year or so, however, also depends on reactions from the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) leadership. Moreover, the KMT’s total domination of the Legislative Yuan (parliament), which was due as much to the DPP’s falling popularity as to the introduction of a “Japanese-style” electoral system—could upset the delicate balance of power on the island and spell trouble for the future of Taiwanese democracy.

There's quite a lot of people who see the election as one of great harm to Taiwanese democracy -- both Ma and Siew have apparently come out with remarks that one-party rule is a good thing("Just look at Singapore").

++++++++++++++++++++

Also of note is the meeting at the Heritage Foundation the other day, chronicled in the Beltway insider briefing The Nelson Report. Pay close attention to that last paragraph -- and brace yourself for the flow of self-congratulatory verbiage from US officials who will certainly claim that US opposition to Chen's policies helped cause his loss (although not once did I ever hear any Taiwanese mention them).

TAIWAN...very excellent Heritage Foundation discussion yesterday MC'd by Amb. Harvey Feldman, saw KMT rep (and former TECRO official) Jacob Chang come out from behind his usually very quiet positioning, along with DPP rep Mike Fonte, former VP Cheney China expert Steve Yates, and Heritage vet John Tkacik, as they dissected the DPP's devastating defeat in Saturday's LY elections.

If you need the inside baseball version, we urge you to check the Heritage website. For our purposes, the most important parts of the discussion centered on what now seems likely for the Mar. 22 presidential election, especially for the two UN membership referendums about which the Bush Administration has been so critical...at China's behest.

Briefly, Mike did his best...which is always very good...to try and urge perspective on the purely local, purely economic and corruption issues which seemed to feed his party's wipe out.

Discussion there and in other venues generally concludes that the vote against the DPP was genuinely national, and that while presidential nominee Frank Hsieh is personally more moderate than President Chen, the damage done to Taiwan's economy, the corruption problems, and continual discord with the US and China, all add-up to a likely KMT win on Mar. 22.

Jake very calmly and clearly outlined where the KMT did well, what was new about it, and also outlined presidential nominee Ma's promises to improve bilateral relations with both the US and the mainland.

He also made clear that whatever the KMT's goals with China might be, he personally, and Ma personally condemn China's attempt to disrupt Taiwan's democracy...and he strongly denied DPP charges that under a KMT government, the island might "revert to authoritarianism".

And, Chang repeated Ma's "three noes" for the record: no attempt to recall the President, should the DPP's Frank Hsieh be elected; no messing around with Constitutional amendments [one root of the discord with China and the US]; and no bringing of No Confidence votes, despite the massive KMT majority.

Steve Yates, now a private consultant, said that between now and Mar. 22, he didn't think Beijing would alter its fundamental focus on Chen himself, and its basic opposition to the DPP rhetoric and platform...but that he also didn't think China would do anything "risky", in this Olympic year, certainly, but for more basic reasons.

"Beijing is basically risk-averse, and has a lot to lose with the risk of opening a Pandora's Box of 'change' on Taiwan"...making the point that China's slow political evolution compares poorly with Taiwan's dramatic democratic development.

There was a great deal of discussion on whether the strong, even strident US opposition to the UN referendums, and to Chen himself, played a role in the DPP defeat, and in any event, what both the US and China should now say, and do, in the run-up to Mar. 22.

On balance, discussants felt that since it was always clear that nothing Chen or the DPP could say would actually alter the legal status quo, perhaps both the US and China did not have to get so worked-up over Chen's words and threats.

By extension, therefore, it was suggested that the Bush Administration might have kept things calmer had it concentrated on assuring China that "reality" was and is what matters...rather than appearance.

A calmer approach was urged between now and Mar. 22.

A final area of discussion was whether the general deterioration of US-Taiwan political relations can be blamed only on the DPP, or whether the KMT's indulgence in domestic politics at the expense (for example) of passing the defense budget, means that US-Taiwan bilateral relations may have been harmed beyond easy repair.

++++++++++++++++++++

A Taipei Times editorial points to the long-term danger of the kind of permanent majority that the KMT is likely to enjoy, given its superior voter mobilization and gerrymandered districting.....

There is a saying that has long circulated in circles like Washington that "Chinese are too busy making money to worry about democracy."

Author James Mann, however, contends in his book The China Fantasy that this is a fallacy and just a convenient sound bite for foreign businesspeople and politicians who wish to ignore the authoritarian nature of China's current regime while taking advantage of its cheap labor.

The frequent demonstrations seen in Hong Kong opposing Beijing's heavy-handed rule and the lack of democratic progress since its handover to China lend credence to Mann's theory. Just last Sunday, about 20,000 Hong Kongers took to the streets in the latest protest calling for universal suffrage in the territory. The protesters were upset at Beijing's announcement last month that they might be able to elect their leader by 2017. Hong Kongers had been pushing for the right to elect their government by 2012.

It is a safe bet that given the chance, millions of people in China would also help prove Mann right.

Contrast this with events here last Saturday, when Taiwanese voted for a new legislature. The outcome saw the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) gain a two-thirds majority in the legislature, giving the party's presidential candidate, Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九), a huge boost ahead of the March presidential poll.

The KMT backs increasing cross-strait economic ties, arguing that more business with China will help solve what they term "Taiwan's economic malaise."

But despite promises from Ma that he will not talk unification if elected president, the increased business and cultural contact that would occur under a Beijing-friendly KMT government and the sacrifices of sovereignty the KMT will have to make to achieve this will make future expressions of Taiwan's current independent status even more difficult and the drift toward some kind of unification agreement all the more unavoidable.

This could eventually pose a threat to the full democratic rights Taiwanese now enjoy.

Increasing cross-strait business ties and investment will only give China more control over Taiwan's prosperity and will likely result in more wealthy and influential Taiwanese tying their colors to Beijing's mast. People like former United Microelectronics Corp chairman Robert Tsao (曹興誠) bear testament to this.

When Chris Patten, the last British governor of Hong Kong, tried to institutionalize democratic ideals in the territory ahead of its return to China, some of his most vociferous opponents were the billionaire business barons who considered democracy an unnecessary and unwanted obstacle to their continued wealth accumulation.

Mann points out that a similar phenomenon could occur in China's ruling and newly wealthy middle class. This could prevent the move toward democracy in China that US officials seem convinced increased trade relations will eventually bring.

Taking this into account, Taiwanese could also one day find themselves in the same situation as Hong Kongers, where tycoons who hold influence in Taipei and have a vested interest in China continue to oppose democracy.

Of course, Taiwan's already established democratic system would be difficult for China to dismantle, but with Beijing's relentless arms build-up showing no sign of slowing and its burgeoning economic might bringing other powerful countries to heel, 20 years from now Taiwan may be in no position to resist.

How ironic it would be if Taiwan, the first and only true democracy in an ethnic Chinese country, were to buck the global trend and give its hard-won freedom away.

As you can see, much of this analysis focuses on KMT talking points that have become the conventional wisdom, and not on the numbers that point to a very different set of problems for the DPP, as I noted below. Finally, over in Asia Times, an editor argues that All Bets Are Off in our presidential race here. Hsieh may well still win, he says. Over at Thirsty Ghosts Jon Adams of Newsweek here makes the same argument. In case anyone out there is paying attention to numbers, the DPP actually increased its vote totals over 2004, which may mean something. Or may not....

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Daily Links, January 17, 2008

What's under construction on the blogs today?

  • That's Impossible has some outstanding posts on the recent election, redistricting, plans to redraw the map of Taiwan, as well as one on KMT Veep Candidate Vincent Siew praising Singapore....

  • Fox News video reports on the confrontation between Kitty Hawk and a Chinese sub and destroyer. Those idiots believe that Iranian gunboats really did threaten the US Navy. LOL. However, the US Navy says this incident never happened.

  • Bent reports on a KMT supporter who suddenly got buyer's remorse.

  • Todd visits local cultural sites for more great pics.

  • The Only Redhead asks if the US encourages China's militarization of space.

  • Kerim has a nifty piece on the problems of Taiwan copying the Japanese legislative election model in parallel voting.

  • Talking Taiwanese blogs on UNESCO's year of language and Taiwan's language policies.

  • J Michael Cole reviews Taiwan's Security by Bernard Cole.

  • EVENTS: Those of you in South Africa might want to check out this lecture on the Chinese economy by Arthur Kroeber there on Jan 30.

    MEDIA: HSR impacts Taiwan's local airports. CEPD to rejuvenate the island's older industrial districts -- perhaps because more Taiwan firms are coming back to the island from China? Kosovo: the Balkan Taiwan? Stephen Yates criticizes the Bush Administration's overreactions to the referendum. Hey, no shit, been saying that here for months now.

    The KMT will not ease relations...and Taiwan's Indie Music Scene, from Seattle

    Ted Galen Carpenter, whom I've critiqued here on more than one occasion, has an article in The National Interest arguing that the fundamental support for independence here in Taiwan will rein in the ability of the KMT to cozy up to the PRC government:

    If they examine the KMT's position carefully, however, Chinese leaders are likely to be disillusioned. Although Ma does favor eventual reunification, there are three important caveats. First, reunification can take place only if mainland China becomes fully democratic. Ma—and most KMT members—have no interest in having Taiwan unify with China in its current, authoritarian incarnation. Second, reunification can occur only with the explicit consent of the Taiwanese people. In other words, Taiwan would have a veto. Finally, the KMT has reluctantly conceded that all options—even independence—must be available to Taiwanese voters when it comes time to make a decision. All of those caveats are anathema to Beijing.

    The reality is that there is not a huge difference between Ma's positions and the policies that Chen's government has pursued. The KMT is simply more subtle and conciliatory in its language, and more cautious about actions that might provoke Beijing. In the short run, the latter is quite important. Whereas Chen and the DPP have repeatedly pushed the envelope on asserting Taiwan's sovereignty, and thereby threatened to disrupt the fragile status quo in the Taiwan Strait (much to Washington's dismay), a KMT government is committed to preserving the status quo. In the long run, though, reunification would not be much more likely under a KMT administration than a DPP one. And it remains to be seen how long Beijing will be content with a status quo that maintains Taiwan's existence as a de facto independent state.

    Carpenter's analysis doesn't seem to take into account the numerous "short of formal unification" positions available to Ma and the KMT, that would annex Taiwan to the PRC without any obvious change in status. He also takes Ma at his word. Finally, since China defines the status quo in the Strait, he doesn't really get how it can manipulate Washington (and Taipei's image) to its own benefit -- the KMT will have to come round because it will sooner or later be accused of "risking the status quo." Nevertheless, not everyone in Washington is celebrating the KMT victory. Carpenter should be happy -- an AIT official was cited in the Taipei Times yesterday as saying that the era of large weapons purchases may well be over.

    Carpenter's position on the recent election is actually quite nuanced -- much better than a lot of the conventional wisdom running around the media these days:
    True, the rout of President Chen Shui-bian's Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) was an emphatic repudiation of Chen's performance in office. But whether it was a repudiation of his assertive policies toward Beijing is less certain.

    Actually, it was not a repudiation of Chen's performance in office, either, as I noted below. But at least Carpenter, who often doesn't get Taiwan, is clued into the fact that Chen's policies in many ways reflected local will.

    Meanwhile, on the lighter side, the Seattle Times describes Taiwan's indie music scene....

    The musical tastes of Taipei are not too different from Seattle. A recent visit to a record shop there revealed that six out of their Top 10 indie rock titles were from Seattle — and many of those albums were from Sub Pop. Listeners in Taipei must love Band of Horses and the Shins just as much as we do.

    As for their tastes in pop, it mirrors ours, too — with sounds echoing the Britney of old, Jonas Brothers and Justin Timberlake. Have a listen to these hot Asian acts......


    Wednesday, January 16, 2008

    Happenings....

    Everyone's been so focused on the legislative election, but plenty of other stuff is happening. First, Malawi has terminated its relations with the ROC:

    Taiwan terminated its 42-year-long diplomatic relations with Malawi after the southeastern African country agreed to switch its allegiance to Beijing, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) announced at an emergency press conference at 6:30pm yesterday, two hours after Lilongwe notified Taipei of its intentions.

    "In order to safeguard Taiwan's national dignity, we hereby announce the Republic of China government will immediately cease all diplomatic ties with the government of Malawi," MOFA Deputy Minister Yang Tzu-pao (楊子葆) said, decrying Beijing's continuing oppression of Taiwan.

    Yang urged Malawi to follow international protocol by ensuring the safety of Taiwanese nationals who reside or do business in Malawi despite the end of formal diplomatic relations.


    Now we're down to 23 "allies." Nicaragua and Panama reassured Taiwan they are still on board as President Chen left on a trip to Central America. Meanwhile DPP Presidential candidate Frank Hsieh stepped in as Chairman of the Party since Chen Shui-bian has resigned. Consider my call for professional chairman for the DPP to be reiterated. Longtime commentator Ting-yi Tsai has a conventional analysis of the legislative elections in the Asia Times.

    On the home front there's all sorts of interesting stuff out there. The Taitung Animal Propagation Station, first opened by the Japanese decades ago, is considering opening for tourism. It breeds domesticated animals and carries out research. Taiwan got 3.71 million tourists last year. Our bullet trains are still in the red, but improving, according to the Japan Times. Taiwan shows off a key missile base. Finally, the Guardian has an excellent article on the stagnant incomes of our middle class here in Taiwan -- new car sales have fallen to 1987 levels...

    The Kitty Hawk Confrontation Crisis

    The China Times reported on this; Kyodo News picked it up:
    A Chinese attack submarine and destroyer in November last year shadowed U.S. warships in the Taiwan Strait, sparking a 28-hour standoff that brought the group to a battle-ready halt in the tense waters, a report in a Taiwan daily said Tuesday.

    The confrontation occurred as the U.S. Navy aircraft carrier USS Kitty Hawk and other ships in its battle group were heading back to Japan following China's sudden cancellation of a long-scheduled holiday port call in Hong Kong, the China Times said, citing U.S. military sources.

    The carrier strike group encountered Chinese destroyer Shenzhen and a Song-class sub in the strait on Nov. 23, causing the group to halt and ready for battle, as the Chinese vessels also stopped amid the 28-hour confrontation, the Chinese-language daily reported.
    Apparently the destroyer and sub were on their way to the historical port call in Japan. The original report was in the China Times, so grain of NaCl may apply.

    Tuesday, January 15, 2008

    Review: Richard Kagan's New Book On Lee Teng-hui

    The Taipei Times didn't want this, so here it is: my review of Richard Kagan's new book on Lee Teng-hui:

    +++++++++++++

    Taiwan's Statesman: Lee Teng-hui and Democracy in Asia
    Richard C. Kagan
    Naval Institute Press, 2007, 231p

    In an oft-quoted passage, the ancient Roman biographer, Plutarch once explained his philosophy thus: "in the most illustrious deeds there is not always a manifestation of virtue or vice, nay, a slight thing like a phrase or a jest often makes a greater revelation of character than battles when thousands fall, or the greatest armaments, or sieges of cities." Richard Kagan's rich new work, Taiwan's Statesman: Lee Teng-hui and Democracy in Asia, which examines the life of one of the great statesmen of the 20th century, Taiwan's Lee Teng-hui, elevates Plutarch's approach to a entire framework for understanding the life and thought of Taiwan's first democratically elected President. Kagan illuminates Lee's often cryptic and elusive use of words, and supplies a robust account of the origins and development of his personal approach to life and politics.

    Kagan opens with Lee's moment of triumph: the 1996 Presidential election, Taiwan's first direct presidential election. A native Taiwanese, Lee had successfully risen through the ranks of a Kuomingtang (KMT) party dominated by post-1949 exiles from China, out-maneuvered a rear-guard fight to preserve the authoritarian dominance of the KMT, and defeated the rising pro-democracy party at the polls. How did the son of a humble Taiwanese policeman accomplish these feats?

    The answer, according to Kagan, lies in the experiences and values that have shaped Lee Teng-hui's personality: his sojourns in Japan and the US, his study of Zen, his conversion of Christianity in 1961, and his study of agricultural economics. These influences have created in Lee a character and understanding of great depth and flexibility. "If one painted Lee's idea of democracy, it would not hang in a picture frame," describes Kagan. "Rather, it would be splashed all over the neighborhood in expressions of creativity, chaos, and unpredictability with strings of entanglements and loose threads."

    Kagan begins his discussion of Lee's education, dismissing the pro-China criticisms that Lee is half-Japanese for the far more elegant and fruitful exploration of what being Japanese means for Lee. This meant education in a Japanese high school at a time when few Taiwanese were permitted to enter Japanese educational institutions; then a year at Kyoto Technical School (later Kyoto University) before entering the Japanese Army in 1944. In Japan he was deeply influenced by the writings of Nitobe Inazo and Nishida Kitaro. Nitobe was a philosopher and statesman who was also an agricultural specialist – a career that "could be a template for Lee's own." Lee also found the Zen thinker D.T. Suzuki to be a refuge from the militarism that was then sweeping the empire. In addition to encountering Japanese thinkers, Lee read voluminously among western classics in translation, developing an especial fondness for Thomas Carlyle. According to Kagan, Carlyle put words to Lee's feeling that true heroism created a new world order, driven by the energetic, questing spirit. Finally, Lee's Christianity is also treated as an important shaper of Lee's social action (for years, whenever possible, he gave humble sermons in local churches on Sundays even as a high ranking politician). Kagan returns to these resources again and again in explaining Lee's cryptic, contradictory, utterances and his freewheeling, apparently aimless, yet purposeful behavior.

    Thus, this is not a critical biography in the sense that it attempts to separate itself from the moral world of the subject it treats and to exhaustively examine what many might argue are key controversies or episodes in Lee's career. Kagan's reading of Lee's life is extremely sympathetic, and may be open to charges of hagiography. He is seldom directly critical of Lee's actions, often explaining what some might see mere political horse-trading as evidence of Lee's greatness. For example, Lee's support of mainlander Ma Ying-jeou for Taipei mayor in 1998 is presented as a demonstration of Lee's success in "breaking through the ethnic, geographical, and political division between mainlanders and Taiwanese" – yet Kagan never discusses Lee's controversial removal of that same Ma Ying-jeou from his post as Minister of Justice, a move that critics have slammed ever since as a sop to the political corruption on which they allege Lee depended (nor is the controversy over Lee's relationship to the KMT's alleged corruption treated at any great length). However, as Kagan points out, many of these controversies have been treated elsewhere in great detail.

    Despite its weaknesses and its resolutely pro-Lee point of view –unlike many commentators on Lee Kagan is commendably up front in staking out his position on the historical importance of Lee's life and career – this is a rich, entertaining, and educational work. The sections on Lee's upbringing and early life are absolutely fascinating – Lee's service in the Japanese army took him to both Taiwan, where he fired anti-aircraft guns against US attackers, and to Japan, where he helped clean up after the horrific Tokyo firebombing of March, 1945. Kagan hits his stride in his portrayal of Lee's foreign and domestic policy in the 1990s, a period offering many of the same themes that we see today: the President of Taiwan being labeled "provocative" and "a troublemaker" for attempting to break out of the constrictions placed on Taiwan by the US and China. It was Lee himself carried out the first phases of the removal of the Chiang family cult from public life, a fact often lost in the current debates. Kagan also faithfully reconstructs both the headiness of the post martial law period, with its future full of promise, and its fragility, under threat by hardliners in the KMT bent on suppressing the rising democratic feeling. Finally, Kagan sheds much light on the combination of relationships, luck, and achievement that brought Lee safely through the ranks of the KMT to deliver him to the Presidency at a critical moment in the nation's history, and on his relationship with President Chiang Ching-kuo, who in certain respects was much like Lee.

    Looking back on Lee's career, it seems incredible that Lee, who hung with a cabal of independence firebrands at Cornell, including Peter Huang, would-be assassin of Chiang Ching-kuo during his 1970 visit to the US, escaped imprisonment and execution. It also seems incredible, at least to this reader, that anyone who bothered to look into Lee's background could ever imagine that Lee would be an obedient servant of the KMT fantasy that Taiwan belongs to China. Yet during the early 1990s rumors swirled at home and abroad on precisely these points, a major tribute to the master politician that is Lee Teng-hui: Lee had sold out to black gold, Lee was a secret independence supporter, Lee was a Machiavellian power-monger, Lee was a KMT spy. As Kagan's biography of one of the greatest statesmen of the twentieth century so firmly demonstrates, they were all true, and they were not true at all.

    DPP Election Loss: Analysis

    Max Hirsch has a great piece in Kyodo News this week, analyzing the election defeat of the DPP. Hirsch has a very sensible contrast to the well-known blog Peking Duck, where Raj has served a series of KMT talking points presented as a "centrist" analysis. Hirsch notes:

    On the surface, the DPP's huge loss is easily explainable: a string of corruption scandals surrounding Chen and other DPP officials; a lackluster economy; a gridlocked government; rocky relations with Washington and Beijing; and a loss of diplomatic allies and clout.

    Behind the obvious, however, lies a baffling contradiction: Despite its ''worst-ever'' showing at parliamentary polls since becoming the ruling party, the DPP on Saturday actually hit a historic high in terms of its overall share of votes cast in a general election.

    That's what I pointed out in the post below this one: the numbers won't support the theory that Chen chased away voters. Hirsch goes on to say:

    The DPP reaped some 33 percent of the vote in the general election in 2000, the same year it displaced the KMT as the ruling party after its more than 50 years of one-party rule. In the 2004 general election, the DPP garnered nearly 36 percent of the vote after Chen had won another four-year term as president. Ironically, the DPP's performance Saturday in terms of vote share was its best yet, with its share climbing to somewhere between 37 and 38 percent, experts say. This rising trend points to electoral reform as a subtler and perhaps more important reason for the DPP's shocking loss.

    The key point in the DPP loss -- which has hardly a landslide in raw voting -- was that the electoral reform that reduced the number of seats and created a winner take all format, which favored the party with the most money (Hirsch notes that the KMT outspent the DPP by 5-1, citing Taiwan expert Dafydd Fell of the U of London). This, combined with gerrymandering, meant that the DPP was at a massive disadvantage. As a Taipei Times analysis put it on Sunday:

    The pan-blue camp won yesterday's legislative election by a wide margin as its main rival, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), failed to come up with effective strategies that could have helped it overcome the disadvantages it faced under the new electoral system, political analysts said yesterday.

    Except for certain districts in the south, the structure of most electoral districts favors the pan-blue camp by a 55 to 44 ratio, said Chen Chao-jian (陳朝建), an assistant professor of public affairs at Ming Chuan University.


    In a political economy where political identity is the most outstanding single factor, the structure of the districts was the key to KMT dominance that gave it 80% of the seats with only 60% of the vote. Thus, the number one dumb DPP decision was not its party platform but its decision to go along with the legislative "reform" that produced a one-party legislature that is actually less democratic than the "unreformed" version.

    As always, let's look at the numbers. I have added the local elections held since 1998 to the list:

    1998 County Magistrate/City Mayor elections
    KMT 3.56 million + 0.22 million New Party
    DPP 1.15 million

    2001 Legislative election
    Blue vote: 5,136,827
    Green vote: 4,249,030

    2002 County Magistrate/City Mayor elections
    KMT 2.52 + 0.49 million PFP + 0.03 New Party
    DPP 1.27 + 0.10 TSU

    2004 Legislative election
    Blue vote: 4,552,831
    Green vote: 4,228,141

    2005 County Magistrate/City Mayor elections
    KMT 3.54 million + 0.35 PFP + 0.04 New Party
    DPP 1.96 million + 0.20 TSU

    2007 Legislative Election
    KMT 5.0 million
    DPP 3.6 million

    You can see first of all that only in the highly anomalous 2004 legislative election has the total Green vote managed to reach near the total Blue. Indeed in that year the DPP vote exceeded the KMT vote 3.4 million to 3.1 million, with the PFP taking 1.3 million votes, and 600,000 Blue voters staying home. This made the DPP the single biggest party in the legislature. It is 2004, when all those Blue voters stayed home, not 2007, that cries out for explanation. In 2001 there were over 5 million Blue votes, just as there were in 2007 (however, the DPP exceeded the KMT 3.4 million to 2.9 million; the PFP took 1.9 million votes).

    This suggests that another, hidden, absolutely vital component of KMT dominance was its ability to swallow the PFP (and the New Party) over the last couple of years and mobilize former PFP members, as well as its own people, to come out and vote for it. If the PFP were still a mighty force, the KMT might not have had a majority in many districts -- in '01 and '04 the PFP poached over a million votes from the KMT. KMT/Blue voters are far more aware of themselves as a group and an identity than Greens, and many analysts noted the feeling that the party could not concede Taiwan to the DPP. Party discipline was excellent, and in many districts the party made sure voters had transportation and so forth. The KMT cut deals with former PFP members and the two marched in lockstep to victory as the KMT gathered the Blue vote all to itself. The DPP, by contrast, still had to contend with the TSU which obstinately refused to give in and form a Green coalition.

    Note that nary a peep was heard from KMT splittist James Soong, former Chairman of the People's First Party (PFP), as his party basically disappeared into the KMT. The silence from Soong was absolutely deafening. By contrast TSU spiritual head former President Lee Teng-hui was still out there campaigning against the DPP and complaining about Chen Shui-bian. That was just plain stupid from the standpoint of the island's long-term needs. Additionally, in some districts disgruntled DPP legislators ran against their own people. The DPP's lack of party discipline and its inability to manage its relations with the TSU hurt it (Hirsch reports that Lee is set to endorse Hsieh for the presidency).

    In sum, the KMT/Blues got 5 million votes, about the same as in 2001 (suggesting a natural ceiling for KMT legislative election votes), and the DPP actually increased its totals, both percentage-wise and absolutely, from about 3.4 million to 3.6 million (the Taipei Times has a nice chart of the vote totals). The voting trends are very similar to historical trends, and any explanation that relies on the conventional wisdom of Blame Chen! will have to confront the fact, as Hirsch noted, that the DPP actually increased its vote from 2004. There is no evidence in the voting patterns that voters switched to the KMT from the DPP, that the KMT was able to increase the Blue vote, or that the DPP was impacted by any of the negative publicity in recent months. Competent survey work might find such evidence; but at the moment, no such work exists and all evidence is anecdotal. In the final analysis, this was a perfectly normal legislative election by raw vote counts, completely typical. But with the new, gerrymandered, winner take all districts, conventional just wasn't good enough.

    The DPP's failure was the same as we have seen in previous elections: it cannot compete with the KMT's ability to mobilize Blue voters. For better or worse, even though the legislature is far more important than the ROC's weak presidency, Green voters seem to be less interested in getting out there and voting for the DPP at the local level. The DPP is going to have to make some significant investments in the nitty-gritty of voter education and voter mobilization, because in the last three legislative elections it has received 3.4, 3.4, and 3.6 million votes -- which suggests that there is a kind of structural ceiling built into the voting patterns that probably has very little to do with the ebb and flow of campaign rhetoric.

    It would be nice if we could say that the modest rise in DPP voters meant something for the future, but to compete with the KMT, the DPP would have to be able to get 5 million people out there to vote for it at the local level. It has never even come close to such a figure in a local election. In the Presidential election of 2004 6.4 million people voted Green, and 6.4 million voted Blue. That probably represents the upper bound of people willing to come out and vote in Taiwan. If we replay the 2000 presidential election this year, as we have replayed the 2001 legislative elections, the Blues took 7.58 million votes, Chen Shui-bian, 4.97 million votes (source), for about 12.6 million votes cast, which suggests that the Presidential pool is about 12.6-8 million votes, meaning that in the next 70 days the DPP will have to mobilize 6.4 million voters, again. If the Blame Chen! theorists are right, maybe we'll see a return to the 2000 voting levels as swing voters either stay home or switch to Blue. Your guess is as good as mine.....

    Implications for the future? I observed a couple of weeks ago that the DPP strategy in making Chen Shui-bian chair of the DPP was probably to permit the egg from this defeat to stick to the lame-duck Chen, and not land on Hsieh or any up-and-coming politician. In that scenario Hsieh then rides in to become DPP Chairman, as indeed he has, and then the DPP presidential campaign gets a big boost as Hsieh rides in on a white horse to save it. Unfortunately the debacle was so great that any boost Hsieh could have gotten has been swamped by KMT trumpeting of landslide! Like everyone, I await the DPP's strategy for climbing out of this hole -- yet also, note that despite the negatives, the DPP was still able to increase its vote -- whereas despite the negatives for the DPP, the KMT reached its previous ceiling. Does that auger well for the future? Perhaps....

    Where the effects will be felt is at the local level. With the legislature to provide cover, local officials, who are 90% KMT, can now engage in election shenanigans with impunity -- one of the first acts of the new legislature, I suspect, will be to formally or informally pull the teeth of the Ministry of Justice and the Central Election Commission's investigative apparatus, which at the moment is looking at a historic high of 6,100 vote buying cases. Disclaimer: note that I am not saying that local officials WILL engage in shenanigans, I am only saying that they CAN. Of course, I would never assert, in a public forum, that anyone would actually engage in serious illegal election activity.

    Apologies for the lack of blogging recently. It's finals week here -- one reason the student vote was apparently low -- and I am swamped. Couldn't the CEC have scheduled this election three weeks ago when people weren't so busy?

    Sunday, January 13, 2008

    Some preliminary numbers

    Let's start with the polls. Several people have written to say "Looks like those biased polls were right." ESWN has a post on it up on his widely read blog, so let's take a look at his data. ESWN observed:

    But what were the public opinion polls saying? The following table is compiled from the list of polls conducted by TVBS one to three months before the elections. The entries show the percentages for the KMT candidate versus the DPP candidate; the green entries are those in which the DPP candidate is ahead. Before the actual election results in, poll results such as these are contemptuously dismissed as "pan-blue" polls.

    District TVBS Poll Actual Result
    Taipei City 1 57% vs. 26% 60% vs. 39%
    Taipei City 2 51% vs. 27% 52% vs. 46%
    Taipei City 3 51% vs. 25% 60% vs. 38%
    Taipei City 4 50% vs. 27% 62% vs. 35%
    Taipei City 5 44% vs. 26% 58% vs. 41%
    Taipei City 6 59% vs. 24% 67% vs. 32%
    Taipei City 7 60% vs. 19% 66% vs. 32%
    Taipei City 8 55% vs. 19% 72% vs. 26%
    Taipei County 1 49% vs. 21% 58% vs. 40%
    Taipei County 2 31% vs. 24% 40% vs. 43%
    Taipei County 3 47% vs. 29% 48% vs. 50%
    Taipei County 4 46% vs. 30% 52% vs. 47%
    Taipei County 5 45% vs. 33% 52% vs. 47%
    Taipei County 6 51% vs. 28% 57% vs. 43%
    Taipei County 7 51% vs. 24% 56% vs. 42%
    Taipei County 8 47% vs. 31% 60% vs. 40%
    Taipei County 10 52% vs. 23% 60% vs. 39%
    Taipei County 12 45% vs. 17% 52% vs. 38%
    Chiayi County 1 35% vs. 34% 58% vs. 42%
    Chiayi County 2 26% vs. 41% 42% vs. 57%
    Kaohsiung City 1 53% vs. 25% 58% vs. 41%
    Kaohsiung City 2 43% vs. 33% 49% vs. 51%
    Kaohsiung City 3 44% vs. 28% 49% vs. 43%
    Kaohsiung City 4 43% vs. 29% 51% vs. 47%
    Kaohsiung City 5 32% vs. 40% 46% vs. 52%
    Tainan City 1 47% vs. 30% 50% vs. 50%
    Tainan City 2 40% vs. 38% 48% vs. 50%
    Tainan County 1 31% vs. 36% 45% vs. 55%
    Tainan County 2 25% vs. 42% 41% vs. 59%
    Tainan County 3 32% vs. 37% 47% vs. 53%

    The problem with the pro-Blue polls like TVBS (100% owned by Hong Kong Chinese) is not that they are right or wrong in hindsight, it is that they cannot be trusted beforehand because they are pro-Blue and consistently underestimate Green votes. You only have to scan the list and look at the Green column for TVBS poll results and actual results. In almost every case, the poll underestimates the Green vote by 25-50%, sometimes even more. In Taipei county districts 4-12, for example, TVBS had:

    Green vote:
    District 4 projected: 30 actual: 47 disparity: 56%
    District 5 projected: 33 actual: 47 disparity: 42%
    District 6 projected: 28 actual: 43 disparity: 53%
    District 7 projected: 24 actual: 42 disparity: 75%
    etc.

    The phenomenon of pro-Blue polls underestimating Green votes is well known here, and as you can see, TVBS sometimes errs by 50% in its estimates. Such polls are useless, except as propaganda tools -- which is why they exist, and why they can't be trusted.

    Was it possible to predict this debacle? Yes, but not from looking at polling data in the Blue papers, which was worthless. Indeed, numerous ominous rumblings reached my ears last week, but I discounted them for the same reason that I discount polls from the Dark Side: the Green voters conceal their plans, as ESWN's data so eloquently shows. Perhaps the KMT and DPP internal polls showed something, but they weren't releasing their data. Nevertheless, there were people out there who foresaw disaster, though as far as I know, nobody picked the KMT to get over 80 seats.

    Let's now look at the numbers from the last several legislative elections. I gathered them up last year for a post on US State Department official Tom Christensen's erroneous belief that the US kept the DPP from doing as well as expected in the Legislative elections in '04. Here are the figures:
    2001
    Blue Parties, total votes
    KMT 2,949,371
    PFP 1,917,836
    New 269,620

    Total Blue vote: 5,136,827

    2001
    Green parties total votes
    DPP 3,447,740
    TSU 801,560

    Total Green Vote: 4,249,030
    Total turnout (66%)

    ++++++++++++

    2004
    Blue Parties total votes
    KMT 3,190,081
    PFP 1,350,613
    New 12,137

    Total Blue Vote: 4,552,831

    2004 Green parties total votes
    DPP 3,471,429
    TSU 756,712

    Total Green votes: 4,228,141
    (Total turnout 59%)

    2001 Blue vote: 5,136,827
    2004 Blue vote: 4,552,831

    2001 Green vote: 4,249,030
    2004 Green vote: 4,228,141

    2001-2004 difference
    Blue: - 583,996
    Green: - 20,889

    In other words, in '04 the DPP did well because Blue voters stayed home. The '08 totals are up on the CEC website:

    Major parties, 2007 LY election, total votes (election held 1-12-08)

    2008
    KMT 5,010,801
    DPP 3,610,106

    Let's see that another way:

    2001 Blue vote: 5,136,827
    2004 Blue vote: 4,552,831
    2008 Blue vote 5,010,801 (+ 0.38 million New Party) ~5.4 million

    In other words, the Blues manage to raise their votes back to their 1998 levels of 5.3 million -- the most Blue votes in an LY election in a decade. Meanwhile, what about the DPP and the Greens?

    2001 Green vote: 4,249,030
    2004 Green vote: 4,228,141
    2008 Green vote 3,610,106 (+.35 million TSU) ~4.0 million

    There's going to be lots of temptation to criticize the DPP. What were the DPP's vote totals?

    2001 DPP 3,447,740
    2004 DPP 3,471,429
    2008 DPP 3,610,106

    Yes, you're not going blind. The DPP actually raised its vote total by 140,000 votes over 2004, despite the barrage of negative campaigning. Where did the Greens lose out? TSU votes plummeted, from 756,000 votes in 2004 to just 344,000 in 2008.

    The short answer to today's election loss is really quite simple -- the KMT was effective in getting out absolutely everyone who would vote for it. The long answer is one I'll have up in a couple of days, when I digest what's being written and said about this disaster for Taiwan and its future.

    UPDATE: the number I am using is the number for party ballots. Voters cast two ballots in this election, one for the candidate and one for the party. The party ballot figure is lower, so I figured it is more conservative. I haven't seen constituent numbers yet.

    Saturday, January 12, 2008

    Not a post about the election, thank god: reservoirs

    As I was contemplating another South Korea success vis-a-vis Taiwan -- South Korea inward FDI fell for the third straight year, whereas Taiwan's hit record levels last year (but don't worry, we can solve all our economic ills by imitating the South Korea economy) --and this one too, where S Korea's financial industry is well behind our financial industry -- my jaundiced, pro-Taiwan eye, always interested in water policy here, fell on this article on Taiwan's attempt to deal with water quality in its reservoirs....

    ...Taiwan plans to spend US$6 million on cleaning up its reservoirs:

    The Environmental Protection Agency under the Executive Yuan will allocate NT$200 million (US$6.16 million) over the next four years for a eutrophication control project to improve the water quality at four reservoirs around Taiwan.

    EPA officials said the project to clean up the Shimen, Feitsui, Tsengweng and Kinmen reservoirs will improve the quality of water supply for 10 million residents.

    The project is being launched in line with a Water Resource Agency plan to conserve reservoir catchment areas.

    The officials said that although the extent of eutrophication at Taiwan's three largest reservoirs has not reached the worst possible levels, the situation is not ideal. They noted that as the reservoirs supply water to almost half of Taiwan's population, the decision was made to deal with the problem comprehensively.

    The problem is eutrophication, which destroys water quality as nutrients in the lake lead to algae blooms:

    Eutrophication is a degradation process originating from the introduction of nutrients from agricultural run-off and untreated industrial and urban discharges. Impairment of water quality due to eutrophication can lead to health-related problems.

    ...

    For example, Wei continued, the main causes of eutrophication at the Feitsui reservoir are run-off from fertilizers used upstream and bait discarded by people fishing in the reservoir.

    This 2005 paper warns that the threat to the Feitsui Reservoir will require a 55% reduction in run-off:

    Several NPS [non-point source] reduction schemes had been proposed for the watershed and were tested using this model to develop allocation strategies. The purpose of this study is to estimate the TP [total phosphorus] yield loading from the entire watershed to Fei-Tsui Reservoir such that an appropriate NPS pollution control strategy can be developed for managing the Reservoir. Results of this study show that a TP reduction of over 55% is necessary in order to prevent the onset of eutrophication in the Reservoir.

    Meawhile the article shows that Taiwan's water management policies are sometimes both imaginative and environmentally sound:

    He said that in addition to the Water Resource Agency and the Taipei Feitsui Reservoir Administration cooperating to eliminate the sources of eutrophication at the reservoir, the EPA will work with communities near the reservoir to build an artificial marsh system as well as a buffer zone between agricultural fields and water systems that flow into the reservoir.

    As for the eutrophication problem at the Kinmen reservoir, Wei said the EPA plans to use a method that has proven successful at the Hsinshan reservoir in Keelung City, in which the EPA will introduce oysters and other bivalves in areas around the reservoir to feed on microalgae -- the main culprit behind eutrophication at the reservoir.

    According to this Taipei Times article from last year, water quality is worst in a couple of Kaohsiung reservoirs:

    The degree of pollution is measured using the Carlson Trophic State Index (CTSI), which assesses the eutrophication of a lake. Eutrophication occurs when nutrient levels in water increase too much, causing excess algal growth.

    The enrichment of nutrients in an ecosystem and the cloudiness of the lake resulting from micro-biomass are all measured, Lu said.

    Water transparency, total phosphorus levels, and chlorophyll a levels -- which indicate the density of phytoplankton -- also contribute to the index, he said.

    CTSI is scaled from 0 to 110, with each 10 units indicating a doubling of algal biomass.

    The Feng Shan Reservoir has a CTSI of over 70, the EPA said.

    The Cheng Ching Hu Reservoir in Kaohsiung County's Niaosong Township (鳥松) is suffering similar pollution levels.

    However the reservoir has seen gradual improvements over the years, with its CTSI dropping from a historic peak of 66 to 50 this June, Lu said.

    "But citizens need not worry, since the water still needs to go through a water treatment plant before it runs into the taps at home," he said.

    Shihmen Reservoir, Wu She Reservoir, Te Chi Reservoir and the Sun Moon Lake reservoir are among the country's cleanest reservoirs, the EPA said.

    Twelve reservoirs received neutral scores, including Feitsui Reservoir, which provides drinking water to Taipei City.


    One thing I learned in Kenya was to appreciate the importance of water and water policy....

    Friday, January 11, 2008

    Election Pics Again

    The election is tomorrow, so I thought I'd inundate you with more election pictures, so everyone in the world can be overwhelmed with the sound and color of elections here in Taiwan.

    One predominant myth that colors academic discourse on Taiwan, which I have frequently argued against, is that local voters prefer candidates who are not corrupt. I think this election will forever do that myth in. The middle class here does not want clean government -- it wants government that will assure the flow of funds from the center out to the electorate -- and clean government won't do that. The preference for corrupt candidates -- of which there are countless examples here in Taiwan -- also bodes ill for democratic development in China. Jim Mann has already argued in his recent book The China Fantasy that the middle class in China will ally itself with the authoritarian state to protect its privileges against urban and rural poor. Here is another incentive for them to keep the authoritarian state in being -- corruption helps sustain the political economy of local contracting and development that keeps local middle classes happy.

    Feiren emailed me the following from FTV:

    進入投票所依序會領四張票,分別是區域立委選票、不分區政黨選票,及兩張公投選票。公投選票,領了也可以不投,只要退給選務人員就好,但千萬別撕毀,或把選票帶出去,以免觸法。再次提醒您,立委合併公投選舉,投票時間1/12早上八點到下午四點,展現民主精神,別忽視你手中神聖的一票。
    Each voter should collect 4 ballots: one for the local district legislative representative, one for legislator-at-large, and two referendum ballots. After picking up the referendum ballots, voters can choose not to cast them, but they must be returned to election officials. The ballots must not be torn-up or taken out of the polling station. Fines will apply to those who disobey. Voting for the legislative election and the two referendums will begin at 8am and close at 4pm in the afternoon. So bring your id, chop, and voting card to be sure that you will be able to exercise your right to vote, and don't forget to return the referendum ballots if you decide not to participate. (Feiren trans.)

    Feiren observes that this will mean you will have to get back in line to return the ballot -- perhaps increasing the incentive to vote for the referendums -- if this report is true.

    Everyone I've been listening to is saying the same thing -- the DPP will not do well. 40 seats only, by some sources.

    The government is investigating a record number of vote buying cases.

    The whole DPP brain trust backs this candidate.

    Regardless of sex, candidates love to be seen in athletic poses. This year, because of the success of pitcher Wang Chien-ming with the Yankees, everyone is into baseball.

    On a sunny Tainan street, a candidate looks down.

    Because there is a limit on the amount of money that can be spent on a gift to a voter -- NT$30 -- most candidates hand out pens, notepads, and tissues.

    Signs frequently overlook intersections.

    One of the most annoying aspects of KMT success in this election is going to be another interminable load of crap from the Talking Heads inside the Beltway about (1) how the US influenced the election and (2) how Taiwan's independence movement is fading.

    In many adverts for KMT candidates Ma and Siew, party affiliation is absent. The rhetoric is also Taiwan-centered.

    Shelly Rigger has a good explanation of the changes in the legislature and the election in the WSJ this week.



    Lee Teng-hui, please fold up the TSU and retire. Please.


    Someone has scratched out their faces.

    In Hell, the sound trucks run 24-7.

    The DPP candidate in the center has the strong support of local KMT officials for getting the job done. Legislators are commonly involved in all sorts of local affairs -- even to the extent of getting calls from constituents if they get involved in a traffic accident.

    Note how "China" is written in simplified Chinese.

    One of the reasons election ads are so fascinating is that they are often juxtposed with ordinary ads, in quite striking and ironic ways.

    Ma and Siew on the side of a bus. The color scheme is quite attractive. Note also the open necked shirts, in contrast to Hsieh and Su, who often appear in ties.

    More Establishment Dreck from IHT: A Time for Moderation

    Longtime China commentator Andrew Nathan and Yun-han Chu had an editorial in the International Herald Tribune on the upcoming election in Taiwan, under the now-familiar Establishment rubric of "moderation." Although writing like this is perfectly awful, it achieves its air of insight through deployment of restrained language that creates a moral equivalence between China and Taiwan. To wit:



    Yet the most important result of the elections is all but predetermined: Taiwan's next president will be a relative moderate on cross-strait issues.

    The key to this surprising development is a shift in the mood of Taiwan voters. Chen's efforts over the past eight years to open up more international space for Taiwan hardened Beijing's position while producing a loss of support for Taiwan in Washington. The economy went through a recession in 2001 and has not strongly recovered. A stream of corruption scandals engulfed high-ranking officials of the governing Democratic Progressive Party and the presidential family.

    Note the pro-KMT slant of the opening frame -- Chen caused Washington to curb its support for Taipei -- even though, as former Cheney advisor pointed out here a few weeks ago, it is Washington's obsession with its defeat in Iraq that actually led to the fall-off in support for Taipei. Note also that it is Chen Shui-bian that caused Beijing's position to "harden" even though it was Beijing that refused to negotiate from the start -- even though the DPP has wanted negotiations for eight years. The article even echoes the KMT propaganda claim that the economy is bad, even though we have been growing strongly in recent years and are now the #2 exporter to China. In other words, this is a farrago of nonsense. I suppose it is pointless to observe that Chen was widely hailed as pragmatic and conciliatory when he came to power in 2000 and has remained a "moderate" -- only in the Cloud Cuckoo-land of writing on cross strait relations can a lifelong moderate who advocates peaceful democratic change like Chen Shui-bian be portrayed as a "radical." But heck -- why refer to the complexities of history when you can source ideas from the KMT so much more easily?

    The article then presents the cross-strait policies of the two candidates Frank Hsieh and Ma Ying-jeou. Next, it opines:



    Taiwan's shift toward moderation remains fragile. The next president will have to deal with a divided legislature and a politicized media. Consolidating the shift will require results early in the new term.

    It's amazing that anyone could write "Taiwan's shift toward moderation remains fragile." Taiwan threatens no one. It carries out policy by peaceful means. It has done so since anyone can remember. And yet, pundits can write that our moderation is "fragile." At any moment, we could break out into.....what? A public referendum? An attempt to enter the WHO? The mind reels. For crissake we're a frickin' democracy here! We're moderate by definition.

    Chu and Nathan finally point out that China is a problem too...in a whole entire sentence....



    The last mainland-Taiwan accord was a 2006 agreement to allow certain kinds of charter flights to fly directly between the two sides, which sidestepped sovereignty issues by putting forward the two sides' airline associations as signers. Many similar ideas are on the shelf and afford opportunities to create momentum: ideas for scheduled direct flights, exchange of tourists, currency exchange, and direct cargo transfer through islands near to China that belong to Taiwan. Stronger gestures by Beijing could include a relaxation of its full-court press on the few remaining countries that still recognize Taipei; relaxation of opposition to Taiwanese membership in the World Health Assembly (associated with the WHO), relaxation of the ban on high-level Taiwan participation in APEC, and a slowdown or even freeze on the deployment of medium-range missiles pointed at Taiwan.

    Such steps could begin to reverse a legacy of mistrust on all sides. Beijing and Washington must not waste this opportunity to put the triangular Taiwan Strait relationship on a path of declining tension.

    Nathan and Chu's point of view shows the same relentless lack of imagination and understanding that haunts Establishment commentary on Taiwan. No recognition anywhere in this article that the major problem is not the lack of moderation in Taipei but the threats of aggression emanating from Beijing. Note that their radical plan for building trust is to "slowdown or even freeze" the missiles pointed at Taiwan -- not a condemnation of the threat of force followed by a call for their reduction and elimination. What -- we're supposed to build trust with a nation that is threatening us more slowly?

    Finally, observe how the restrained language, as Orwell noted in his masterful essay on Politics and the English Language, serves as a kind of euphemism that covers up the deeply unethical position of Nathan and Chu (who lack even the moral cojones to call for the removal of the missiles threatening Taiwan). According to Chu and Nathan, there's a "legacy of mistrust" which exists "on all sides." Although it sounds balanced, it actually once again creates moral equivalence between perpetrator and victim. Mistrust exists because China wants to annex Taiwan and Taiwan does not want to be annexed, simple as that. If China did not threaten Taiwan there would be no issue; the two sides would be as friendly as Canada and the US. There is no "legacy of mistrust" "on all sides", because there are not two morally equivalent sides here.

    UPDATE: I've roasted Chu's misleading, pro-KMT writing before on this blog. As blogger Feiren pointed out in a private email, Taiwan is not the problem in the negotiations -- Nathan and Chu fail to point out that it is China that has refused to do further negotiations on charter flights and tourism using non-official negotiating teams.

    Thursday, January 10, 2008

    Fun with campaign volunteers

    My wife drives up to our house on her motorcycle, and to her undying joy, is greeted by a campaign worker dressed in the regalia of our local DPP legislative candidate. Our neighborhood is getting blitzed almost daily with literature from the local KMT candidate, but we haven't seen anything from the DPP. The worker hands her some literature and asks:

    "So, are you voting for the DPP on Saturday?"

    "Of course! Thanks so much for the pamphlets!"

    "So how come you're not voting for the KMT? They have good people too, you know."

    That threw my wife for a loop, but she came back strong. "If they are good people, how come they're in the KMT?"

    "You should vote KMT, don't you think the DPP has messed everything up?"

    "The legislature was messed up by the KMT, not the DPP."

    "A-ya." The worker exclaimed. "The DPP has ruled long enough. It's time to give the KMT a chance."

    " Why should I give them another chance to hurt Taiwan even more? They're going to sell us out. Do you want to be part of China?"

    "Why not? What's wrong with that?"

    At this point my wife gave up and went in the house. Lots of dirty tricks this year. Tricks like this also show how, by canvassing in this manner, the KMT can find out the political affiliations of local voters.

    Wednesday, January 09, 2008

    How the Referendums Will Be Defeated

    The pro-Green Liberty Times (Chinese) has been reporting on how the legislative election referendum is being beaten: at the local level.

    Each neighborhood or precinct has a captain who is the local chief administrator, the li chang or the lin chang. The hierarchical administration of Taiwan society begins with them -- they handle neighborhood affairs, such as getting potholes or streetlights fixed. They are sensitive ears and eyes of the government in the neighborhoods. They are also about 90% KMT.

    During election it is their job to distribute voter notification slips, which they have to present so they can vote. According to the law these notifications must be placed in voter hands, not left in mailboxes. In this election they are supposed to give one for the legislative election and one for the referendum. According to the Liberty Times report, in many districts voters are reporting that KMT precinct and neighborhood captains are simply refusing to distribute the referendum notification, without which voters cannot obtain a referendum ballot -- and thus can't vote for the referendum.

    UPDATE: In the comments below people say you can still vote for the referendum without the notice, the idea is to make you think you can't vote for it. As STOP_MA points out, and we've noted before, the whole idea of two-ballot voting is to enable local KMT machines to know who votes DPP. It's basically undemocratic.